ReasonForOurHope

Monday, September 28, 2020

New Evangelizers Post: Faith in Science

  


 


I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  

This article is a follow up to the one I wrote last month about Faith and Science.

As I wrote there, while modern people have a strange notion that scientific truth and religious truth are in conflict, the reality is that they are not. However, this cultural perception is so strong that it leads some young people to leave the Church. In his article “Young People Leaving the Church Because of ‘Science’ “ Christopher M Grany points out a 2017 study from St. Mary’s Press of Minnesota and Georgetown University’s Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate that a number of younger Catholics are leaving the Church. While this is not necessarily new information, what was fascinating was the significant percentage of respondents who pointed to science as a reason for their loss of faith.

There could be a great many factors to this. I suspect also that for many that using “science” as a reason for leaving is a fig leaf for other more personal and moral reasons. But leaving that aside, let us take this at face value.

One thing that I have noted as a teacher is a very strange notion that science will eventually overcome faith and make it obsolete. As Scott Neidich wrote in his article “Denying the Resurrection: An Atheist’s deconstruction of Historical Arguments for Jesus,” the author claims “ Science explains that which is previously unexplained, and one day will answer questions we don’t have an answer to.“ In other words, take anything that we can only possibly attributed to God, like miracles. The modern notion is that a miracle has a scientific explanation, but we have not reached the level of sophistication yet to explain it. A similar line is said in the first Thor movie where they say magic is just science we don’t yet understand. However, the modern notion holds that one day we science will peel back the curtain and remove all superstition and religion.

When St. Thomas Aquinas wrote his Summa Theologiae, he tried to answer every possible question about the faith. When doing so, he would always come up with at least 3 of the best arguments for his beliefs and refute them. Even non-believers tend to agree that St. Thomas did not give “straw-men” or weak versions of his opponents arguments, but only gave the opposing side the strongest arguments possible. And as I wrote, he always have at least 3 objections to his own position.

Except for one place: the question of God.

On the question on whether or not God exists, St. Thomas only gives 2 objections. This is not because he is afraid of the other arguments. It is because he can only find two arguments against God’s existence that are worth considering. You may believe that he is wrong about this. But St. Thomas was not inclined to side-step difficult arguments.

The reason why I am bringing this up is that one of those objections touches on this modern misconception that science. St. Thomas says that one of the only strong arguments against the existence of God is the belief that science will one day explain away those things that can only currently be explained by religious faith. St. Thomas writes:

“For all natural things can be reduced to one principle which is nature; and all voluntary things can be reduced to one principle which is human reason, or will. Therefore there is no need to suppose God’s existence.” (Summa Theologiae I.2. q2 a3 obj. 2)

In other words all that is miraculous could eventually find a cause in the natural world, thus making God an unnecessary hypothesis to explain anything. And from this point of view it is thought that scientific fact will one day overcome and eliminate faith and belief.

However, there is an enormous logical flaw with this way of thinking.

The idea that science will one day overcome belief is itself a belief.


You can read the whole article here.

Sunday, September 27, 2020

Sunday Best: Emmy Results 2020

 


I wrote last week about how the Oscars have become irrelevant.

This week it is the Emmys.

The award show for 2020 was the lowest rated in its history.

There are several factors to this that include the lack of a red carpet, which draws a great deal of interest.  I know my wife always likes watching what the stars are wearing for the ceremony.  The lack of a live audience also makes the show less interesting. Yes, the nominees were connected like the most star-studded zoom conference in history, but that is not the same as the energy you get from a live audience.  The jokes on these award shows tend to be flat and boring, but without even the polite laughter of the audience, the silence underscores the lack of humor.

On top of this, you had Jimmy Kimmel as a host who brought with him a lot of politics.  In fact, many of the winners took the time to speak out about the election.  Again, whether they like the president or not, about half of the audience does.  It seems strange to alienate half of your potential customer base.

I've also mentioned in the past the problem of winners coming from obscure TV shows.  But this is just a result of the larger problem that no one seems to talk about:

There are too many TV shows.

I don't mean that there shouldn't be a wonderful variety of things to watch.  I mean that there is too much content to sift through and judge in terms of quality.  At least for the Oscars I sometimes try to make an effort to see all of the movies nominated for the major awards so that I have some context as to how people are voting and why.  This requires a few hours a week to catch up in time.  

But for TV, you would need to watch hundreds of hours of programming in order to be caught up on all the nominees.  I just caught up on Cobra Kai, a show that has been around for a few years.  How am I to have time to watch the entire series of Schitt's Creek and Succession, even if I wanted to?  I have a list of shows that I still want to watch that have since been cancelled like Person of Interest, Once Upon a Time, Bones, and Heart of Dixie.  

Before the inclusion of cable and streaming shows, the Emmy's only awarded things on broadcast television.  While this may have been a tad elitist, it also made it possible for more people to engage in the awards.  You catch a few episodes of each of the nominated shows and get a sense of what they were all about.  And even if you didn't watch one or two of the shows, you still had a good handle on the rest.

With that being said, you can understand that people would not be that interested to tune in to see the unpopular Schitt's Creek sweep the categories.  That isn't a knock on it's quality.  I have a very good friend of mine who swears by its humor.  My wife and I gave it a few episodes and it wasn't our taste.  I would have been ecstatic if The Good Place swept the categories, but that is also a show that not a lot of people watched.  The Emmy's tried to suck us in by nominating popular shows like The Mandelorian  and Stranger Things in the Best Drama category, but I can't help but feel tricked.

And this should have been a much bigger year for television.  With the lockdowns people had time on their hands to gobble up TV shows.  But instead of rewarding viewers for tuning in, the Emmy's once again held up content that most people have never seen. 


So what were the results last week.

1.  Schitt's Creek Sweeps

Again, I don't watch the show, but swept the comedy categories.  

2. Watchmen wins big.

I don't have HBO, but as a huge fan of the original source material, I am curious about this show.  I've heard that it starts off like political allegory, but then it moves beyond that to tell an actually compelling story.  I will try and catch this on DVD when I get the chance.

3. Succession

I have no idea what this show is about but people love it.

4. The Ubiquity of Comic Book Characters

I was struck by how many of the winners have also played comic book characters in movies or TV.  Obviously, you have the content for Watchmen, but 5 of the acting winners total have played characters in super hero films.

5. Only 2

Only two winners were from show's I have seen: 

Julia Garner from Ozark.  She is very good, though the show is just way too dark for me.

Billy Crudup from The Morning Show.  Again, he was good, but the show was so insufferable that I dropped it in the middle of the fourth episode.

6.  MIA

Now, I am usually an advocate for cutting down the amount of awards given on the night, but I looked at some of the shows that won awards in the secondary categories and they more like shows I watch or want to watch like: Dave Chapelle: Sticks and Stones, Rick and Morty, Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance, SNL, This is Us, The Mandelorian, The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, The Masked Singer, Star Trek: Picard, The Superbowl, and Stranger Things.

It's almost like the things that run towards my tastes have been rated to the "kids table" of awards while the adults can honor the more "sophisticated" material.

Perhaps it is foolish of me, but I'm sad that I have lost my excitement for these award shows.  Perhaps I am finally putting aside childish things.  But I miss the fun of it all.


Thoughts?

Thursday, September 24, 2020

Chaplet of Life

 Hello,

I do my best to avoid politics on this blog simply because I find that this subject can dominate and overshadow all other considerations.  What I am about to write is not political in intention, but it involves the political process.

As there is an absence on the Supreme Court, a new justice may possibly be placed on the bench.  With this comes the possibility of finally overturning Roe v. Wade, the court case that opened the door to legalized abortion and the slaughter of millions of children in the womb.  All that is needed are five justices on the Supreme Court who understand that all people, even those unborn, have the right to life. 

There have been times where the possibility of overturning Roe has come up but not realized.  For that reason, I am not terribly optimistic, but I am always hopeful.  In fact, I would say that at this moment we are closer to overturning Roe than at any time since it was handed down.

A common misconception is that if Roe v. Wade is overturned that abortion becomes illegal throughout the country.  That would not be the case.  If Roe is overturned, then the laws return to what they were before the case was decided, which is that each state gets to make its own laws regarding abortion.  I believe that is why in the last few years some legislatures, like in New York state, have passed laws that legalize abortion up until birth.  So if Roe is overturned, states like New York will still be able to legally kill children in the womb.  But my state, Ohio, might pass more restrictive laws.  

With that in mind, we must remember that the most important thing we can do is pray.  Yes, making our voices heard to our politicians and being present at the marches is important as well, since these are public demonstrations of our morals.  But we will not be able to achieve this important goal except by the grace of God.  Only He can save the unborn.  We are merely workers in His vineyard.  Christ said that some demons you can only remove by prayer and fasting (Matt 17:21).  And if we want the demonic murder of these children to end, we must also take up prayer and fasting.

For the last twelve years, my wife and I have been praying a Chaplet of Life for the unborn every day.  I would like to share this Chaplet with you and invite you to pray with us, especially at this moment in history.

The Chaplet is prayed on a rosary like the Chaplet of Divine Mercy.  The way you pray the Chaplet of Life is this:


Pray 3 "Glory Be's."

Pray 1 "Our Father."

Then on the "Our Father" beads you pray a "Hail Mary."

Then on the "Hail Mary" beads you pray:

"Jesus, Mary, and Joseph... we love you, save souls and unborn children."

After 5 decades, you close with the Memorare:

"Remember, O most gracious Virgin Mary, that never was it known that anyone who fled to thy protection, implored thy help, or sought thine intercession was left unaided.

Inspired by this confidence, I fly unto thee, O Virgin of virgins, my mother; to thee do I come, before thee I stand, sinful and sorrowful. O Mother of the Word Incarnate, despise not my petitions, but in thy mercy hear and answer me.

Amen."


However you pray, let us join together in prayer that Our Lord may deliver our country from the scourge of abortion.

Tuesday, September 22, 2020

Trailer Time: Marvel's WandaVision


Marvel is trying a very bold experiment with their MCU by bring the characters to series.  Yes, we've had MCU series before like Daredevil and Agents of SHIELD.  But this is really the first time that main members of the Avengers cast have a series of their own.  The gamble seems to be paying off in Star Wars with The Mandelorean, so this may also be a good thing.

The show looks... funky.  I don't mean that as a bad thing.  It looks like the concept is going to be incredibly trippy and will intentionally mess with your head and make you question what is real and what is not.  I'm glad they dealt with the elephant in the room right away by addressing Vision's death in this trailer.

I really like the conceit to classic TV as well as the nods to the characters original comic book costumes.  Everything about this series screams "experimental."  I'm good with Marvel taking chances, as long as they keep true to their characters.

Thoughts?

Sunday, September 20, 2020

Sunday Best: Oscars Are Irrelevant

 I love the Oscars.

Growing up I would stay up all night to see who would win in the big categories.  For someone who loved movies, this was my Super Bowl.  There was excitement, competition, upsets, drama... the works.

For one reason or another, the Oscars was supposed to be the night where those who had achieved excellence in the field of movie-making would be honored.  However, I doubt that anyone looking back on the last 10 years could make that claim.

Instead, the Academy voters chose movies that had buzz or were edgy rather than looking at actual artistic merit.  Feel free to disagree with me, but I saw The Shape of Water.  There is nothing in that movie that would ever make me think that it was worthy of a Best Picture Oscar.  The only thing that seemed to be in place was that it was thematically in line with the world-view of those working in the film industry.  But best picture?

I have often stated on this blog that I tend to dislike Christian movies.  As a devout Catholic, these movies often are perfectly in line with my world-view and values.  But for the most part, I can evaluate them on artistic merit.  And yet Hollywood cannot seem to do the same.  I maintain that one of the greatest comic books ever written was Watchmen, even though its central philosophy is absolutely opposed to what I believe.  But Watchmen is not a propaganda piece focused on changing your world-view.  It is a piece of art that challenges you to think differently.  Ultimately I reject the world-view it shows, but I cannot deny its artistic merit.  I can say the same thing about a film like Apocalypse Now, which seems to say that the root of the human soul is horror.  But the movie still deserves all the accolades for its artistic merit.

Recently, the Motion Picture Academy set out a set of criteria that movies will have to meet if they wish to qualify for a Best Picture nomination.  I have looked at the criteria and there is nothing terribly shocking about it.  I have read many people upset because none of the new criteria have anything to do with artistic merit.  I'm not very shocked, because the Motion Picture Academy is merely codifying what it was already doing culturally: rewarding films for having the approved world-view.

The best movie from last year that I saw was Joker.  It was a film that raised a lot of interesting and disturbing questions without giving very clear answers.  In other words it made you think and let you draw your own conclusions.  I actually don't know if I agreed or disagreed with its world-view, but I recognize the mastery that it took to make it and I appreciate that it lets its audience be active engagers instead of passive recipients in the theme.

I have no problem with the Academy imposing technical restrictions on a film.  They already do.  Movies need to be at least a certain length and (at least pre-COVID) have a limited theatrical run.  But as I said, the criteria are not technical, nor artistic, they are cultural.   This has nothing to do with whether the criteria is a social positive.  Even though I am a Christian, I would be opposed if the Academy stated that a certain percentage of those involved in the production had to be Christian and in order to qualify for Best Picture.  The point is that art should be judged on its artistic merits.  That doesn't mean that themes don't have a place in these artistic judgments, but that theme is one aspect of art, not its only aspect.  And while the cultural condition in which a piece of art arises is important, it is different than the art that these conditions produced.

But the Academy disagrees.  Instead, in a few years, you will have a Best Picture that was chosen first for its non-technical, non-artistic qualities before other considerations.  As I said, it seems like the Academy has already been doing this in practice, which is how we get Best Pictures that are as irrelevant as they are forgettable like The Shape of Water and The Artist.

The Academy Awards have already slipped into cultural irrelevance.  To give you an idea of how out of touch the Oscars are, the combined domestic box office of the last SIX Best Picture winners (Parasite, The Green Book, The Shape of Water, Moonlight, Spotlight, and Birdman) is less than the domestic box office of Joker.  And while box office does not equal artistic merit, it is a good indicator of how much of an impact you have on the culture.

Will I keep watching the Oscars?

I suppose I will.  But as a ceremony awards excellence and crowns future classics, it has never been more irrelevant.

My advice?  Do what I have been doing for the past few years: make your own awards list and share it with others.  You may take a lot of flack and get into a great deal of debate.  But it will be a lot more fun than watching the Oscars.

Friday, September 18, 2020

Film Review: Bill and Ted Face the Music

 





Sometimes a lot of goodwill carries a movie further than it has any right to go.

That is the case with Bill and Ted Face the Music.  

Thirty years after they were supposed to unite the world with song, Bill S. Preston Esq. (Alex Winter) and Ted "Theadore" Logan (Keanu Reeves) are nowhere near where they thought they would be.  Like many musical acts that have been left on the cultural ash heap, our heroes are playing smaller and smaller venues while exploring more and more experimental sounds.  Their lack of practical focus has been a strain on their wives (Erinn Hayes and Jayma Mays) and the scorn of Ted's father (Hal Landon Jr.).  However, they are idolized by their daughters: Thea Preston (Samara Weaving) and Billie Logan (Brigette Lundy-Paine), who carry their fathers enthusiasm for life, music, and friendship.  The plot kicks off when Kelly (Kristen Schall), Rufus' daughter, comes and brings Bill and Ted back to the future.  There, they are told they must produce the song that unites the world by that evening or the universe could end!

Yes, the premise is convoluted and silly, but Bill and Ted Face the Music never pretends to be anything other than convoluted and silly.  Like the other films, the plot has more than enough holes to be ridiculous.  But the power of a Bill and Ted film is that the leads are so likable and charming, that the plot holes don't really matter.

And that is still true for this film.

Winter hasn't lost a beat as Bill.  He still has the same wide-eyed energy and enthusiasm that he had decades ago and he never lets up.  Reeves is a slightly different story.  His performance is in now way bad.  But while Winter is still able to capture the innocent and optimistic outlook of his character, Reeves feels a little too hard-boiled.  He still comes off as kind and affable.  But there is always just a hint of John Wick peaking out of his eyes so that you get the feeling that Ted could make a dark turn at any moment.  Despite this, Reeves and Winter still have terrific comedic chemistry and have a wonderful rhythm like Mike Meyers and Dana Carvey.  

Weaving and Lundy-Paine take a larger role in the story than the trailers may let on.  They have their own B-story that feels very similar to Excellent Adventure.  Like their on-screen dads, the actresses are affable, but it doesn't feel as genuine.  Lundy-Paine in particular feels like she is doing a constant impression of Keanu Reeves from the original films.  Despite that, they understand that the key to these characters isn't that they are necessarily the funniest, but that they are incredibly endearing.  The movie pivots a little too much to the daughters and even though this move is telegraphed way in advance, it feels like a bit of cliche let down.

There is something unrelentingly nice about Bill and Ted.  That sounds as though it makes them bland, but it is quite the opposite.  They are like the buddies you had in high school who you enjoyed hanging out with, because they could always lift your spirits with their attitude.  That is why when Bill and Ted encounter increasingly dark versions of themselves in the future, it is particularly appalling and funny.  The movie explores that mid-life identity crisis where our characters have to decide how much they have to let go of their dreams of youth without morphing into something jaded and cynical.

Schall, Hayes, and Mays are fine and fit into the feel of the Bill and Ted universe.  Anthony Carrigan is a wonderful addition as an inept death robot sent from the future.  Carrigan is able to crack up the audience with his wide-eyed facial expressions.  William Sadler is also a welcome return as the over-the-top embodiment of death.

The movie does look like it was filmed on the cheap side.  The CGI looks like what you could find in a high-end fan film.  But the movie doesn't rely too heavily on these gags, but focuses on the silly comedy where it takes place.  He is able to make the movie sail better than Bogus Journey, but it never quite reaches the audaciousness of Excellent Adventure.  

The directing is serviceable, but nothing that will blow you away.  Dean Parisot knows how to visually bring these characters to life.  Writers Chris Mattheson and Ed Solomon (who have written all of the Bill and Ted movies), give the movie just the write tone.  There is a dumb, silly joke in the third act that is so stupid that I could not stop laughing.  But I think I was more receptive to the movie's silly humor because of all the good will that has been built up, especially from Winter and Reeves.  It is clear that everyone involved is having a good time making this movie.

The movie's themes are about how love and kindness, along with the power of music, can unite us as a people.  I remember when I was in high school, a mused to a friend of mine that I wished that there was a universal language.  She replied, "There is: music."  Without trying to get too deep, Bill and Ted Face the Music presents and optimistic message that what unites us all as human beings across all time is much stronger than what divides us.  And if we could someone communicate with each other, maybe by entering into the same song, we wouldn't be at odds all the time.  While this might be overly naive, you buy into it because Bill and Ted and the other characters are totally invested in this most excellent idea.

Bill and Ted Face the Music is not a movie that is earth-shattering in its importance or excellence.  It is just a movie that is filled with good times, good laughs, and good characters.  And with the amount of cynical garbage floating around the enterainment industry now, this movie feels like a breath of fresh air to remind us to be excellent to each other and...

...PARTY ON, DUDES!


 

Tuesday, September 15, 2020

Trailer Time: The Mandalorian Season 2



The Star Wars fandom has been fractured ever since The Last Jedi.  People have staked out strong and definitive opposing camps as to what Star Wars should and shouldn't be.

But one thing that I think most Star Wars fans agree upon is that The Mandelorian is great.

The first season exceeded all of my expectations as to what the show could be and got my award for Best TV Drama for the year.  This trailer teases more excellence.

The heart of the show is the bond between our main anti-hero and the Child.  It is an odd and unlikely pairing that is both endearing and dramatic.  And this trailer puts that relationship at the center of everything.

The opening shot is fantatic, with Din Djarin's ship limping along, struggling to get to the planet ahead.  It portends the struggles and dangers our heroes will face.  Their success is not guaranteed.  We saw the return of Cara Dune and Greef Carga.  We saw a return to Tatooine and perhaps some Jedi spying on the heroes.  And we saw a LOT of stormtroopers.

My favorite part, though, is when the Child understands that horrible violence is about to happen and hides in his shell.  

I cannot wait for this new season.

Thoughts?