ReasonForOurHope

Showing posts with label Film Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Film Review. Show all posts

Friday, November 13, 2026

Film Review: You Can See Everything

 

Sexuality/Nudity Offensive

Violence No objection

Vulgarity Mature

Anti-Catholic Philosophy Mature

If there is one thing I would impress upon people who watch documentaries it would be that documentaries are not news reports.  Because these types of films are meant to capture moments of real life and not employ actors, we tend to talk about these movies as if they capture the truth free of narrative.

But the truth about many documentaries is that they tell stories in the same way that most movies do.  They have a story that they are trying to tell.  Instead of using a pre-planned script, the story is shaped in the editing.  The angles, the cuts and the music are there to tell you how to feel and shape your image of the subjects.

If you keep this in mind then I think You Can See Everything is and incredibly interesting movie.

Elizabeth Holmes is the tech entrepeneur who founded Theranos, a company that claimed it could diagnose diseases with a single drop of blood.  She was convicted of fraud and sentenced to prison.  In the weeks before she had to surrender herself, she and her husband Billy Evans invited documentarian Nathan Fielder to film them.  They opened up their lives to him to the point where Nathan moved into their rental home up until she went to prison.  In this part of the movie, Holmes comes off as incredibly odd.  Everything we see in her body language, tone of voice, and choice of words feels controlled and artificial.  Fielder and co-director Lance Oppenheim do an incredible job of dynamic angles and they make powerful use of extreme close-ups.  The latter saturate the movie so that you feel almost oppressed by how closely you are looking into the subject's eyes.  Throughout this section of the film, Holmes is presented like an enigma, a puzzle that Fielder is trying to solve.  They stare each other down like two poker players, with Fielder trying to find Holmes' tell.  And all the while it seems like these two are drawn closer and closer.

If this is all the movie was, then I would chalk it up to a slightly interesting curiosity.  But that is only the first half.

After Holmes goes to jail, Fielder brings the cut of his footage to actress Amanda Seyfried, who won awards for her portrayal of Holmes in the miniseries The Dropout.  After presenting the footage to her, Fielder asks Seyfried to reprise her role as Holmes for a series of re-enactments.  This is where the movie becomes truly fascinating.  Fielder writes scenes based on his recollections of interactions with Holmes and Evans.  He then directs these re-enactments with Seyfried and other actors in the same way he has been directing the documentary.  In these moments the line between the real and the fabricated begin to blur.  What makes this all the more interesting is that this blurring is part of the fascination with Holmes herself.  Fielder can't seem to figure out what is real and what is a performance.

And all of these portrayals put Evans in a terrible light.  The scenes with Evans himself do not flatter him, but the re-enactments try to cement him as a manipulative villain.  But the movie doesn't take the easy way out and cast the others as heroes.  Fielder is constantly shot in a way that makes him appear like an intrusive creep than a crusading hero.  Seyfried herself has moments where she comes off as incredibly unlikeable in her interactions with Evans.  Everyone on screen feels a little worse for the wear.

What I like about this are the questions that this raises about the medium of documentary film-making.  Should there be a narrative?  And once there is, is this the truth or just one point of view?  And because it is a documentary, is that fair?  Is it okay to use re-enactments or should they be left out because the audience did not get a chance to see the events for themselves?  Is anything we ever see on screen in a documentary "real?"  

Regardless of how manipulative or not you find Fielder, I could not deny his ability to draw you in.  I felt like Homer Simpson when Mr. Burns was staring at him and Homer thought, "Mmm... Look at his eyes. He's trying to hypnotize me."  As I kept feeling sucked in, I kept having to tell myself that Fielder is trying to hypnotize me into going with his narrative.  And his story is compelling.  I wanted to follow his theories until they resolved.

The sad thing is that rather than revealing more humanity, this movie feels like it is a commentary on the general dishonesty of people in society.  It feels like a dark, rather than an uplifting message.  This is not a criticism of the film's power, only a comment on how it will make you feel.  It is actually a much darker film than people think.  It tries to be shocking and raw.  There is one scene where without warning Fielder presents full-frontal male nudity.  There is no reason to do this other than to be a provocateur.

But this film is very effective at provoking.  As a Catholic, I'm not sure I agree with what is being implied about the human condition.  But Fielder so effectively presents his material that I could not stop talking about this movie days later.




Thursday, October 29, 2026

Film Review: Street Fighter (2026)

 


Sexuality/Nudity Mature

Violence Mature

Vulgarity Acceptable

Anti-Catholic Philosophy Mature

Why are video games so difficult to adapt into movies?  


It seems like it should be an easy thing to do.  Granted, some movies and shows lend themselves

to a clear narrative like The Last of Us.

But so many of these games have such clear, distinct, and vivid characters with strong motivations and arcs.  


And yet, I would imagine most of us could name more  bad video game adaptations than good ones.  


I was thinking of this when I was watching the most recent adaptation of Street Fighter.


The movie centers around Ken (Noah Centineo) who has a love/hate relationship with his best friend Ryu (

Andrew Koji).  Ryu wins a great tournament by unleashing some evil energy, but then leaves the fighting scene. 

Ken devolves into an MTV party celebrity.  The dictator M. Bison (David Dastmalchian) arranges a tournament

to lure Ryu out of hiding.  Ken takes up the invitation to come out of Ryu’s shadow.  Meanwhile Chun-Li

(Callina Liang) is undercover trying to take Bison down from the inside.  


When I was directing theater, one of the best insights into the process I read was that casting is 90% of the job. 

I found that part of the process the most stressful, because it turns out that this principle is true.  I knew if I cast

the right people, the production would be great.  But if I miscast anyone, it would drag down the entire show. 

And Street Fighter s a mixed bag in this area.  Koji is excellent as Ryu, the brooding, pessimistic hero who is

trying to turn from his violent ways.  Liang is also excellent as Chun-Li, projecting strength and femininity. 

Vidyut Jammwal embodied the character of Dhalsim in the little screen time that he had, showing off his amazing

physicality.  And Hirooki Goto had one of the best turns in the movie as E. Honda where he portrayed him with

humor and honor.  


But the rest of the casting brings down the movie.  Dastmalchian is horribly miscast as M. Bison.  In the original

live-action film, Raoul Julia was literally dying and frail, but he projected supreme power.  Dastmalchian is a fine

actor, but he never projects the menace necessary for the character.  Centineo also cannot carry the movie on his

shoulders.  Something about his Ken felt very artificial.  Perhaps that was part of the character choice, but it then

doesn’t translate to the sincerity necessary for the character.  


The movie doesn’t know what it wants to be.  It is ostensibly a fighting tournament movie, but most of the most

important fights are outside of the tournament.  And even the important tournament fights are overlooked.  Vega

(Orville Peck) and Guille (Cody Rhodes) have a fight that we NEVER see, but it is only mentioned in the aftermath. 

I have no idea why you would skip something like this, except for budget reasons.


And they must have had budget problems.  The prologue to the movie is animated and it is not short.  And the

flashbacks are also all animated.  It’s like they ran out of money to film these scenes but realized they were needed

for character background.


But the real problem is that the movie cannot fully commit to itself.  When I saw the trailer, I was interested because

it reminded me of Netflix’s adaptation of One Piece.  On that show, the production design is insanely over-the-top and cartoonish, where you will have characters who

hide machine guns in their powdered wigs and they fight with swords in their mouths.  But on that show, the

characters fully commit to the reality of this world so that no matter how flamboyant they are, I believe their

motivations and the stakes involved.  Street Fighter wants to have the look of One Piece but feels embarrassed by it.  Comedians Andrew Schulz and Eric Andre feature prominently, always pointing out the silliness of the events of the film.  Comic relief can help with a strange premise the way Wolverine did in the

first X-Men movie, but the humor seemed to be more at the expense of the film.  The humor also boarders on perverse

sometimes, portraying most of the side characters are creepy weirdos. But the real problem is that the humor

destroys any drama.


You can see this particularly in the final scene of the movie, which I found utterly baffling.  The penultimate scene

sets up a chase where our heroes have to chase after the villains and our disaster will occur.  The final scene finds

them sitting by a country road hitch-hiking.  The entire scene felt like something out of a sketch comedy show with

no sense of immediacy, danger, or importance.  


The entire movie feels like a big bright balloon that slowly deflates so that all you’re left with is the empty husk

of something that once bounced with life.




Wednesday, September 30, 2026

Summer/Fall Mini-Review Roundup 2026

 Hello, Dear Reader.

The beginning of the academic year is usually an incredibly busy time for me, but moreso this year than any year previously.  Not only am I spending more time in the early days of the classes that I teach, but my Diaconate Formation classes have been eating up a great deal of my time along with my parish assignment.  Many nights I am not home until after 9pm.  I am not complaining, but I am trying to explain why my blogging has slowed down to 1-2 posts per week.

As a result, I have fallen behind on my film reviews.  In fact, looking back I have seven film flashes this year without reviews attached (I also have 3 streaming movie reviews that I will be adding)

Previously, in order to catch up I did a mini-review roundup for all of the movies that I had been missing.  With apologies, Dear Reader, I will do the same now.

Enjoy!


Solo Mio

I am a big fan of Kevin James and gives his full commitment to this movie about an American school teacher jilted at the altar while in Rome who decides to experience his non-refundable honeymoon package.  The supporting cast including familiar faces like Allyson Hannigan and Jontahan Roumie is endearing and charming.  The movie doesn't have as many big laughs as I would like, but it earns enough good will so that you will be smiling through most of it.

Star rating 3.5 of 5.png


Power Ballad

Paul Rudd plays Rick, an American ex-pat living in Ireland who is making a living with a wedding band.  At one wedding he happens to meet Danny (Nick Jonas), an ex-boyband member who is trying to make a serious solo career.  The two get intoxicated and Rick plays Danny one of his songs, "How to Write a Song Without You."  When Danny goes home, he passes the song off as his own and it becomes a gigantic hit.  Rick becomes obsessed with proving to everyone that the song is his, even if he has no proof.

The movie starts enjoyable, but then takes a bit of a darker turn as Rick becomes more obsessed.  This causes a gigantic strain on his wife and teenage daughter in a way that is unpleasent to watch.  However, to my surprise, the movie turned on its head with one line.  When Rick finally confronts Danny, he says that he knows Danny couldn't have written it. When Danny asks him why he says, "Because you think it's a love song!"  What follows is an interesting character turn that moves the film to a much more satisfying conclusion than I was expecting.



Minions and Monsters

A portrait view shows a Minion being absorbed by orange goo that fills the entire frame. The head-on perspective of the Minion shows his scared expression as everywhere but his front side is soaked up. Many big red eyeballs from the gooy organism look straight at the Minion. At the top of the view, the words "ILLUMINATION'S minions & monsters" are displayed. The letter "O" in "monsters" is replaced with the distinct shape of a minimalist Cthulhu-like monster head. Further text below the logo reads "Only In Theatres July 1".

I have never been a big fan of the Minions series.  I don't have anything against it, but it always seemed like disposable fun nonsense, which is fine.  The same could be said about this one, but what I liked about it was that it was a real love letter to old Hollywood.  I teach a little bit of the history of film and I loved all the homages throughout to Buster Keaton, Charlie Chaplain, and the like.  I also like the humorous incorporation of a Lovecraftian villain.  Someone asked me about the supposed satanic imagery.  There is one scene with an evil wizard that could be interpreted that way, but I saw it more like an evil Gandalf.



Young Washington

The first act of this film feels like a made-for-TV movie.  They do a lot of heavy-handed dialogue moments where they do set-up and pay-off only minutes apart.  But once you get past the first act, the movie really picks up.  The performances are very good and you get a strong sense of Washington's character, both in his ambition and his determination.  You feel all of his horrible mistakes that he makes along the way, which is why you root for him when he steps up and tries to make up for them.



Voicemails For Isabelle (Netflix)

Zoey Deutch plays Jill,  a struggling chef in San Francisco who copes with life by leaving voicemails to her dead sister on her old number.  She does not realize that the number has been reassigned to a young real estate agent in Austin, TX named Wes, who unwittingly falls in love with her through her messages.  Wes decides to enter into her life and start a relationship with her, all the while struggling with the secret of how he knows her.

This is traditional rom-com stuff and the movie handles it decently.  But there are too many b-stories that really don't go anywhere and the movie lacks a lot of heart and charm.  It is unnecessarily sexual in ways that you find in Netflix productions that only serve to distract from the story.



The Dink (AppleTV+)

The movie is trying to be Happy Gilmore for pickleball and it only works sporadically.  Jake Johnson is funny as the lead, but his character is so unlikeable that he never really pulls you in.  He has great chemistry with Mary Steenburgen as his pickleball partner, but for some reason the movie kills off any growth in their relationship.  You also have a funny turn by Ed Harris as Dustin's father, but other than that, there isn't much to write home about here.




Mayday (AppleTV+)

This is one that I wish was in the theater.  Ryan Reynolds plays a Navy pilot who gets shot down behind Soviet lines in the 1980's.  He is found in the wilderness by a former KGB agent played by Kenneth Branagh, who is willing to help him if he can defect.  The two then go on a comedic and action-packed ride through Cold War Russia.

The movie was incredibly charming.  Directors John Francis Daley and Jonathan Goldstein, who also made the criminally underated Game Night as well as the most recent Dungeons and Dragons, know who to film an action set piece and they know how to use the camera for laughs.  I laughed more in the movie than most comedies in the theater.  The directors have the confidence to know when to just let a visual gag sit without having to do an MCU-style quip.  There is one sequence in particularl when Reynolds and Branagh are hiding in a closet that is particularly memorable.  Reynolds and Branagh have great chemistry and I cannot believe how believably Branagh plays an action hero.  The movie occasionally cannot help itself to make some kind of ham-fisted social commentary, but that is the only part of the movie that feels flat





Coyote vs. Acme

In a portrait view, a photorealistic hill is seen at a side angle from afar. Wile E. Coyote stands on the cliff, appearing as a 2D illustration who is casting a shadow and is affected by the lighting. He pushes a giant photorealistic fuse bomb three times as big as himself up the cliff. At the top of the cliff, the Roadrunner stands, who also appears in 2D. A logo in the bottom right reads "COYOTE VERSUS ACME" in a bold, blocky, red font. The hole of the second instance of the letter "O" is in the shape of Wile E.'s silhouette in a frenzied pose, as if he ran through the letter. Additional information about the film appears in smaller words in the view. The poster parodies the Greek myth of Sisyphus, involving a man condemned to push a boulder up a hill for eternity.

This is a very clever movie.  It stays true to the spirit of the Coyote and Roadrunner characters in a way that was pleasently unexpected.  The use of Foghorn Leghorn as the villanous corporate shill was a very insightful choice.  It isn't as smart as Who Framed Roger Rabbit or even Chip 'N Dale Rescue Rangers.  The human elements are the least interesting part, except for John Cena who seems very at home in the Looney Tunes Universe.




By Any Means

This movie could have been a lot better.  Set in 1966, it focuses on FBI agent Wayne Strider (Yaha Abdul-Mateen II) who is investigating a murder led by the KKK, but Strider is hampered because of all the racism he encounters in his investigation, even from local law enforcement.  So his boss partners him with Greg Scarpa (Mark Wahlberg), a sociopathic mafia hitman to break their way into this underworld.

The movie does a great job at showing us Strider's struggles, both interior and exterior.  And unlike most movies of this nature, he and Scarpa don't form a kind a unlikely friendship where they learn from each other.  Scarpa is a violent monster who has been set loose on even worse monsters.  That was an interesting take.  However, the main problem with the movie is that just when Strider starts really enter into challenging moral territory where his character is stretched, the movie just ends.  It feels like there is no strong resolution to the good set up.  So you will leave the theater a bit unsatisfied.




Runner

This is a simple, straightforward buddy-action film that feels like a lot of the mid-budget movies you would get in the 80s and 90s.  Alan Ritchson plays a recovering alcoholic courior with a military background who ends up escorting Owen Wilson who is transporitng a liver to a dying girl in a hospital.  But a very powerful drug cartel is out to get organ with the clock ticking on the liver's viability and the little girl's life.

The action sequences are very compentantly shot and actually very enjoyable.  Ritchson and Wilson have surprisingly good chemistry.  The only time that the movie loses steam is when the character stop pushing their forward momentum for some comedic dialogue or some heartfelt backstory.  These moments take the wind out of the sails, which is a shame because if they were able to keep up the intensity consistently, it would rank a notch above.


Tuesday, September 8, 2026

Film Review: The End of Oak Street

 The poster shows a logo in a foggy background, while four people encounter an Allosaurus

Sexuality/Nudity Mature

Violence Mature

Vulgarity Acceptable

Anti-Catholic Philosophy Mature

This movie has all the elements that should make it a fun, summer blockbuster.  But in this case the movie is less than the sum of its parts.


The End of Oak Street takes place in a suburban community in 1982.  It centers around the Platt family.  Denise (Anne Hathaway) is an aspiring novelist who is ready to leave her husband and children at the drop of a hat.  Greg (Ewan McGregor), is an amiable guy who is delivering pizzas to make ends meet.  The teenage daughter Audrey (Maisy Stella) is incredibly smart with big dreams of college.  And finally Brian (Christian Convery) is a typical, not-that-bright junior-high kid who has a crush on the new transfer student Jeannette (Jordan Alexa Davis).  The cracks in the family are subtle at first but then become more pronounced under stress.  And this stress occurs when the entire neighborhood gets mysteriously transported several hundred million years into the past where they must not survive surrounded by prehistoric life.

I will say that the movie does pack within it some genuine thrills.  Oak Street makes the dinosaurs genuinely scary and a real threat.  The Jurassic series tends to make them more and more cartoonish, but this movie uses them as monsters who inflict gruesome deaths on the residents of Oak Street.  The design on the dinosaurs is also much different than what we've seen in the past, comporting to what modern paleontologists think they looked like, feathers and all.  Some of the action sequences move with real energy and thrills, with very decent camera work besides.  Speaking of the camera work, writer/director David Robert Mitchell seems very enamored of use deep focus shots so that it becomes part of this movie's signature style.  The special effects are as good as anything else out there right now.  The early scenes where the family begins to realize their threat have some moments of fun, escapist entertainment.  The performances are all decent from the main cast, where none of them break the spell.

But even with all of these pieces parts in place, the movie never becomes more than these disparate elements.  It apes the feel of 1980's movies, particularly that of Spielberg, but it cannot create the same sense of wonder awe.  Go back and watch something that is supposed to be a straightforward monster movie like Jaws and Spielberg fills you with that wonder and awe even as they are looking over Ben Gardner's broken boat.  Oak Street has a lot of spectacle, but it never feels weighty enough to dig deep into your heart.

But the real place the movie fails is the writing.  This is a shame because with just a little tweaking of the script, the movie could go from mediocre to very good.  The main problem is that the movie places Denise at the center of the movie as its main hero and she is incredibly unlikeable.  We are meant to sympathize with her domestic dissatisfaction where she already has a bag packed to leave, but can't bring herself to do it when she looks at her children.  The movie never gives you a rational reason for her to be this upset.  Before the movie begins, Greg lost his job and began delivering pizzas to make ends meet.  In one scene he parks in the driveway and begins to take the pizza delivery sign off of his car.  When his son asks why he does it since he needs to put it back on again in the morning, Greg says, "It embarrasses your mother."  Denise gives no support or sympathy to her husband who is clearly scrapping to provide even though he feels like a failure.  They don't give her enough of a reason to resent him.  At one point we see him secretly take a drink from a hidden bottle, which might hint at an alcohol issue.  But even though this would ground her resentment of him, the movie dismisses it completely.  

Greg is a decent guy, but he is fairly ineffectual.  He is kind even to his annoying neighbors, even when Denise is strident.  He tries to be optimistic for the kids while Denise thinks pessimism is the best way to prepare their children for potential disaster.  The movie wants you to side with Denise on this, but she really offers no better alternatives.  

The children also make incredibly stupid decisions.  Audrey sneaks into the garage and turns on the car so she can listen to "Valerie" by Steve Winwood (this is the first hint that she has same-sex attractions).  Not only is she playing music that could attract dinosaurs, she is doing it with the car's headlights turned on, wasting precious battery power.  I kept shouting in my head, "TURN OFF THE HEADLIGHTS!"  Brian is also very foolish.  One night he sees his dog outside runs out with his bow and arrow and tries to catch him.  Aubrey sees him and instead of getting her parents, she also runs after him.  Everything bad that happens to this family in the rest of the movie is because of that boy's stupidity.

Speaking his bow and arrow, we see him walking the neighborhood with it at the beginning of the film.  We think we are getting a set-up/payoff here, but there is none.  When he sees his crush, he goes to shoot the dinosaur attacking her, but fails miserably.  Instead Aubrey saves her with her knife skills, thus starting an attraction between them both.  So I guess the point was to subvert expectations, but this trope got old back in 2017.

There are also moments that are so contrived that they make no sense.  In one scene, a gigantic snake comes in through a second-story window and slowly makes his way downstairs and sneaks up on Denise.  In doing so, the snake passes up three potential victims.  There is no reason for this to be done except to create artificial tension.  Besides this, the scene provides nothing to the plot.  It could be completely removed from the film and it would make no difference to the story in any way.

And while the movie highlights the marital problems, it does show how marriage can be a blessing in times of crisis.  There is one touching scene where Denise and Greg are huddled-down in danger and you can see their bond grow closer because they need each other.  There is also an incredibly odd and off-putting scene where the two share a laugh while watching two giant dinosaurs mate along the side of a house.  I suppose that is something positive to take in terms of the value of marriage, but it seems buried underneath everything else.

The real problem with the writing, though, is the ending.  I will not spoil it here, though I may have to write an entirely separate post about it.  But the characters make a decision that, on the surface, seems to hit all of the correct emotional notes.  But the moment you start to think about it with any real application of morality, the implications get more and more morally confused to the point where you wonder whether the decision may actually have been evil.  Because it deals with time travel, there is a lot of intentional ambiguity, but instead of giving you the proper catharsis, it instead leaves a bad taste in your mouth.

What is so frustrating about The End of Oak Street is that it has all of the ingredients of an incredibly fun sci-fi family film.  But it fell apart at the writing stage, which is the stage where most of the flaws are most easily fixed.  Instead, we got this creative-concept film hampered by unlikeable and unintelligent characters.  Perhaps if we could go back in time, we could fix those problems and therefore we would hope that this wouldn't be the end of Oak Street.





Monday, August 3, 2026

Film Review: Spider-Man - Brand New Day

 

Sexuality/Nudity Acceptable

Violence Acceptable

Vulgarity Acceptable

Anti-Catholic Philosophy Acceptable

It has been 10 years since we first encountered Tom Holland's Spider-Man in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.  Over the years we have watched him grow up from a "Spider-Boy" into the Spider-Man.  And this movie builds on all of that good will and familiarity to give us one of the most enjoyable Spider-Man movies.

Spider-Man: Brand New Day takes place after the events of Spider-Man: No Way Home.  To save the multiverse, everyone forgot who Peter Parker (Holland) was.  This includes his love MJ (Zendaya) and his best friend Ned (Jacob Batalon).  Over the course of about five years, Peter avoids his loneliness by throwing himself into crime-fighting.  As a result he is externally loved by the people, but inside his emptiness is eating him up.  But then Peter finds himself fighting a mysterious enemy who has to power to mentally posses innocent people.  This antagonist is attacking a government organization called "Damage Control" led by Bill Metzger (Tramell Tillman), whose job it is to clean up post-superpower destruction.  The antagonist draws deeply into Peter's life just as he begins going through some complicated and violent mutations.  To help with this, he seeks out the help of Bruce Banner (Mark Ruffalo), who has learned to suppress his Hulk mutation.  But the strain of trying to catch the antagonist and the pressure to protect those he loves may be overwhelming for him.

Now with this fantastical premise, it may sound out for me to say that I love how this story is more grounded.  What I mean by that is this is not a reality-shattering crisis like No Way Home, Avengers: Endgame, or even Thunderbolts.  People are in danger and lives are at stake, but it is localized to New York City.  Despite all of the super-powers involved, the movie does not lean on some existential threat for dramatic weight.  Instead, it has to be much more character driven: the movie pulls us in because we care about the characters.  I genuinely feel for Peter as he sits on the outside looking in.  There is a scene where he wanders into a party hosted by Ned and MJ where he has to pretend to be a stranger.  The "so-close-yet-so-far" feel of the scene breaks your heart.

These MCU Spider-Man movies have a new director in Destin Daniel Cretton.  And he is a very welcome shot in the arm to this series.  The best part of his previous MCU film, Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings," was the pratical fight choreography.  You can tell whenever possible he would have the actors do live stunt fights rather than use CGI characters.  There is a something more tangible and dynamic about this.  It gives a extra visceral punch and thrill to the scenes.  That isn't to say he doesn't use the special effects effectively.  Even the simple swinging scenes are enjoyable to watch.  Very early on in the film, I told my wife that we would have to come back and see it in 3D because his use of depth and height would be something to see.  The scenes with the Hulk are the most intense since probably Age of Ultron.  But Crettton brings visual personality and depth to even the quiet scenes.  This movie has better use of shadows and physical environments than any of the previous Spider-Man movies so that the movie feels more dramatically and emotionally grounded.  Even the effect of the mental possession is done primarily as an in-camera stunt rather than special effects.

The performances are some of the best of series.  Holland clearly still has a passion for this character.  He plays the part with such pathos and intensity, really letting us feel how Peter is almost trapped by his own goodness.  He's in a prison he would not break out of even if he could.  He lets you feel how Peter is buring the candle at both ends and his outbursts of rage are scary to see.  The movie also works so well because Holland has fantastic chemistry with the entire cast.

This is never more apparent than in his scenes with Jon Bernthal as Frank Castle/The Punisher.  Their good cop/bad cop repartee gives us some of the best lines of the entire film.  They foil off of each other perfectly where their disdain for each other is matched only by their unspoken affection.  Bernthal has been amazing as Frank in everything he's done and he sparks off of Holland in just the right way so that you can't wait for them to share the screen again.  Holland's chemistry with Zendaya on Batalon has not lost a beat and in fact is helped by this last decade of groundwork that has been laid.  Batalon is still affably nerdy and when there is something horribly comfortable and familiar when he geeks out with Holland.  And you can see the subtle grown in Zendaya from teen to young adult.  There is a little more self-possession and self-confidence.  Even Ruffalo, who I've felt has been phoning in his Banner performances for the past few years, brings subtle intensity.  This is probably his best MCU performance his debut in Avengers.  

I also have to mention Sadie Sink.  I won't say who she is playing until the spoiler section below, but her performance needs to ground much of the last half of the film.  She has to play someone who projects power and intimidation while also letting us in to see her vulnerability.  She showed that she was one of the best actresses on Stranger Things, but this shows that she has the potential to be a leading woman in a franchise.

The movie is long, but it never feels over-stuffed.  I never felt the length because I wanted to spend more time with these characters.  The story has enough enjoyable twists and turns without feeling like it is trying too hard to subvert expectations.  Instead, it simply won't let Peter get away with easy answers.  And his mistakes have consequences that he has to own up to.

Thematically, I love how this movie deals with very human struggles.  Ultimately, this movie is about human connection.  No matter how altruistic Peter is, he will lose himself and his humanity without some kind of community.  I'm reminded of the wisdom of Our Lord in that He creates His Church because He knows that humans cannot flourish unless they are in community.  I also like how the film tackles self-repression and change.  As Peter starts mutating, he works very hard to suppress his new powers.  When they start manifesting, he does everything he can to put them away and keep things the way they are.  But the movie tackles the truth that repression just makes the change stronger and will fracture us inside.  The goal is not to suppress our "darker side" but to integrate our shadow towards positive ends.  And the movie wrestles with the question of whether people are good or evil and whether they can be trusted.  This is where Peter's greatest super-power is on display: his compassion.  Because of who he is, Peter as the power no only to save lives, but to redeem hearts.

I do have a few critiques of the movie.  The first is that in every scene of Frank Castle in public, he should be swarmed by cops.  Frank is mass murderer who is wanted by the police, but the movie treats him like he is just another vigilante.  My other two critiques require spoilers so be warned:


SPOILERS AHEAD

The second critique is that one of the main bad guys is so obviously a bad guy that when the twist is revealed it has no satisfaction.  I don't know if it was because how this person was set up or the obviously aloof performance, but I remember thinking very clearly that they were not subtle enough in this person's introduction.

The third critique has to do with Sink's character.  We find out half-way through the film that she is Jean Grey who we can presume will be part of the upcoming MCU X-Men movies.  And while I think that this is actually an inspired and out-of-the-box choice for an antagonist, the movie may have accidentally burned their bridges with this character.  The movie wants you to movie from antagonism to sympathy for her and Sink does most of the heavily lifting here.  But the problem is that she crosses so many lines when she is the main villain.  Mind-possessing people is such a horrible violation, like Kilgrave (David Tennant) in the MCU Jessica Jones series.  And while it shown to be a scary power, it's moral consequence is mostly ignored.  But there is one particular moment where she possesses someone and lets him get hit by a car.  I hate to sound Comic Book Guy from The Simpsons, but I really hope they address this sometime in continuity and make clear that this guy lived, otherwise Jean is an outright murderer.  And she would worse than Frank Castle who only kills the guilty, she would be a murderer of innocents.

END SPOILERS

But above all, I left the movie moved and entertained.  The inner comic book geek in me thrilled at the strange cocktail of Marvel elements.  There is one moment where Spidey is dragging the Punisher away from the Hulk while Frank empties out his gun and screaming.  That shot brought me such simply delight that I turned to my wife and said, "I just got my money's worth from this movie."

Spider-Man: Brand New Day has everything that you could want in a Spider-Man film.  It has action, heart, and that special thing that makes Spider-Man stand out from all other heroes: no matter what specatcular adventure he is in, Peter Parker is and always will be one of us.

And after watching Brand New Day,  you won't be able to wait for the next adventure of Spider-Man.




Monday, July 20, 2026

Film Review: The Odyssey

  


Sexuality/Nudity Mature

Violence Mature

Vulgarity Mature

Anti-Catholic Philosophy Mature

Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey was assailed with controversy before it opened.  There was a lot of buzz about what this would ultimately be.  And if you read reviews, they are all over the place.  I've read some that say it is an absolute masterpiece.  I've read others that say that it is a travesty and desecration of Homer's original.  As with all art, you will bring your own subjective perspective to the judgment of this film.  All I can do is give you my honest assessment and analysis.

And I think this film is excellent.

It isn't perfect.  It has some flaws that are not deal-breakers, but they are real and act as spell-breakers to the enchantment of the story.

As with most Christopher Nolan films, the movie is told in a fragmented timeline.  Odysseus (Matt Damon), the king of Ithaca has been missing for many years, having not returned from the Trojan War.  Several suitors, including the noxious Antinous (Robert Pattinson), abuse the hospitality of Queen Penelope (Anne Hathaway) while waiting for her to choose a husband.  They plot to supplant her young son Telemachus (Tom Holland), who eventually seeks out Menelaus (Jon Bernthal) for news of his father.  Meanwhile, Odysseus is lost in a daze on an island with Calypso (Charlize Theron) who slowly revives his memory about the fall of Troy and the many trials he has endured in order to get home.

Nolan has brought to the screen a bold and epic vision that seeks to be as spectacular as it is deep.  Nolan also wrote the screenplay and has attempted to adapt this ancient classic for a modern audience.  His attempt to do this is a mixed bag and where the movie stumbles the most.

The biggest problem is the distraction caused by the modern style.  He made the choice for the cast to do American accents and to use modern American diction.  Telemachus says things like, "My dad is coming home."  When listening to the dialogue it is like hearing Mozart through an untuned instrument.  Perhaps this is an unfair critique, but it is similar to the feeling I get when hearing Shakespeare with an American accent.  I've only heard three American actors who speak Shakespearean lines without feeling off to me (Charlton Heston, Denzel Washington, and strangely Billy Crystal).  For everyone else, it is jarring and pushes me back to the real world rather than drawing me in.  It is the same with The Odyssey.  

What helped me with this was to think of this production like live theater.  There is an artificiality to live theater that the audience accepts.  We are not under the illusions that the sets are really towns and castles.  We invest our imagination into a theatrical production in a different way than when we suspend disbelief in a movie.  But if we use the theatrical imagination and apply it to this movie, it helps not only with the language but other incongruities.  A lot of people online made hay about Lupita Nyong'o being cast as Helen of Troy.  But I found Bernthal's Menelaus more distracting as he played him very much like a weary Frank Castle from modern New York than an ancient Greek monarch.  But when I embraced the movie in the way I was able to enjoy the movie more.  However, the irony was not lost on me regarding this.  Nolan goes out of his way to make everything feel as tangibly real as possible, filming on real location and using as little CGI as possible.  But in order to allow the spell to work, you have to create an artificiality in your mind that Nolan avoids everywhere else.

Another controversy is that it takes the original story and it focuses on more modern virtues and issues than are found in Homer's story.  At the heart of the movie, Odysseus deals with the guilt of his part in the destruction of Troy and is struggling between his desire to come home and his sense of unworthiness to do so.  This has nothing to do with the original.  As far as I remember, Homer's Odysseus feels no guilt about Troy.  In fact, he speaks plainly about how on the way home he and his men raided villages, killed all the innocent men, took the women, and plundered the supplies.  This is not presented with any guilt or angst.  It was just what Odysseus did.  

I have no real problem with Nolan changing this.  I would have trouble with engaging with a story Odysseus blithely leading a marauding band of mudering rapists along the coasts without any moral quandary.  To be sure, there are scenes where Odysseus and his crew plunder innocent villages, but even though it is done in the context of necessity, Nolan lets the immorality of this play out in the characters.  However there are a few times when this adaptation to modern sensibilities goes a little out of balance and it feels like he wants to make a commentary about social-political topics of today.

Having said all of this, Nolan has created a truly epic film.  By the end of the movie, you feel like you have gone on a journey.  Not enough films today feel that way.  He takes you to dangerous and enchanting landscapes, that are all the more dangerous because of their enchantments.  But more than anything, he takes you on Odysseus' journey of inner discover.  Each horrific encounter reveals something about his character, both good and bad, that moves him forward.  We see his wrath in the scene with the Cyclops (Bill Irwin), his greed to hear the siren song, and his defiance against the gods in the face of prophecy.  But we also see his courage, his cleverness, his guilt, and eventually his faith.  By the time he gets to the end of his journey, he has suffered much inwardly and outwardly that the resolution comes to a satisfying payoff.

At the thematic heart of the movie is something called "Zeus' Law."  It is basically the Judeo/Christian "Golden Rule" where you show hospitality to strangers.  The suitors abuse this hospitality by feasting off of Penelope's wealth for years.  Odysseus and his men abuse this when the raid villages in their journey.  But this main focus of this is Odysseus' Trojan Horse.  I will not get into all of the details, but Nolan is meditating on the social fabric/social contract of a society.  Once the foundational understanding of human relationships is lost, then nothing can hold.  As a theology teacher, one of my main focuses for the year is reminding my students that everyone is made in the image and likeness of God.  Holding to this principle sets the foundation of all human rights, our civil laws, and our interpersonal relationships.  In today's society, the further we move away from that principle the more we fall into darkness.  Nolan is making a similar point in The Odyssey.  Once we break what is sacred to the world, the world begins to fall apart.  

The movie also wrestles with big ideas like fate vs. free will, pragmatism vs. principle, control vs. faith.  One of my favorite lines in the movie is when Athena (Zendaya) asks Odysseus "When you see your men die, do see chance or consequence?"  This gets at the heart of the ancient Greek dilema of fate.  Odysseus defies the gods because they say that his men are doomed to die, so he does his best to save them.  But they don't listen and engage in the activity that incurs the wrath of the gods.  So is it the gods fault because they put them in the situation where they sinned or is it the consequence of their sinfulness.  The ancient Greeks did not have a strong understanding of free will, but we moderns do.  Part of the journey for Odysseus is coming to accept that his choices were his own and he cannot blame them on anyone else.  In accepting responsibility, he has to place himself under the gods as an act of faith.

In terms of the visuals, Nolan does such an amazing job.  As mentioned before, his desire to film at real, atmospheric locations brings a tangibility to the movie.  He takes you into the chaos of war, the grandeur of sailing, and the awe of nature.  His use of light and shadow are particularly powerful in the cave of the Cyclops.  The scene with Circe (Samantha Morton) is literally horrifying.  Most of Nolan's movies have an emotional stoicism, but here it fits harmoniously with the harsh life of Ancient Greece.  The entire sequence of the sacking of Troy is both exhilarating and devastating.  You feel the sweaty desperation of the ben hiding in the horse, the rising tide of violence in the blood, and then the horror at the devestation unleashed.

Damon is great as Odysseus.  He has to carry the weight of the film.  And his presence is felt even when he is not on screen.  He lets you feel the weight he carries without ever being too showy, but bears with appropriate restraint.  Hathaway matches this energy with her Penelope with her love mixed with resentment at his absence.  I've heard some people not like Holland's performance, but he played the roll of the callow youth who has to grow into a man.  As jarring as Berthnal's sensibility is, his performance and Nyong'o bring charisma and talent to the screen.  I loved John Leguizamo's irascible Eumaeus who struggles to hold onto hope as his world slips away from him.  Himesh Patel also does a good job as Eurylochus, the staunch sidekick who slowly loses faith in his leader.  The two performances that I did not enjoy were Pattinson and Eliot Page.  I've read a number of reviews that praised Pattinson for his smarmy, slimy performance.  But his performance has the same problem as Page's: they lack believability.  Neither disappear into their roles being intentionally mannered and artificial.

Since seeing the movie, not only have the visuals been sticking with me, but I have been thinking about it quite a bit.  It is rare that a movie is both this stunning and this provocative.  

But I would expect nothing less of an Odyssey from Christopher Nolan.



Thursday, July 2, 2026

Film Review: Toy Story 5

 Lilypad, a frog-like tablet, is centred in the poster in front of the toys, who look at her confusing and shocked.

Sexuality/Nudity No Objection

Violence No Objection

Vulgarity No Objection

Anti-Catholic Philosophy No Objection

Most people agree that Toy Story 3 was the perfect ending to the series and they are not wrong.  This latest entry in the series cannot top that fantastic conclusion. 

But it is better than Toy Story 4.

Toy Story 5 is once again centered on the toys living with Bonnie (Scarlett Spears).  Her main toy is Jessie (Joan Cusack) in the same way that Woody (Tom Hanks) was with Andy.  However, with more and more children becoming engrossed in technology, she has few playmates and friends.  So Bonnie's parents (Jay Hernandez and Lori Alan) buy here Lilypad (Greta Lee), a tablet so that she can connect with others her age.  But as she begins to fall down that rabbit hole, Lily conflicts with Jessie and the other toys.  Through a series of plot contrivances, Jessie gets separated from Bonnie and it is up to Woody and Buzz Lightyear (Tim Allen) to mount a rescue.

Oh, and there is an army of Buzz Lightyears that crash on a desert island trying to make their way to star command.

The first thing that you should know about this movie is that it is Jessie's movie.  Woody and Buzz are supporting characters to her character arc.  In the context of this point in the series, it makes sense.  Bonnie being a girl would naturally gravitate to Jessie as her main toy.  It is interesting that the writers/directors Andrew Stanton and McKenna Harris acknowledge that there are some natural differences between boys and girls reflected in the way they play.  Like Andy, Bonnie has heroes and villains and danger.  But unlike Andy, Bonnie's scenarios take place and weddings, balls, and honeymoons.  Also, Jessie would understand the feminine perspective of Bonnie's lonliness in a way that Woody and Buzz would not.  And in this way, the movie explores the lonilness of girls that I don't think it could with the original trilogy.

Another sad thing is that most of the original supporting characters are reduced to glorified cameos.  I know a number of the original voice actors have died, but it is still disappointing to not have them be a bigger part of the adventure.  We are introduced to some obsolete tech toys like Smarty Pants (Conan O'Brien), a toy that helps potty train kids.  And while they add some interesting dynamics, the others are missed.

The movie does two things very well.  The first is that it really gets the emotional beats right.  There is something very honest about Bonnie's pain and isolation.  I have seen this happen, where children who just want friends are too shy and isolated to feel like they fit in.  And often they either retreat further into themselves or they abandon who they are in order to fit in.  When Bonnie goes to a sleepover and proudly shows off Jessie, one of the girls asks in a tone dripping with disgust and judgment, "You still play with toys?"  And the look on Bonnie's face speaks volumes in a way that is crushing.  The emotional journey for Jessie is also powerful.  This movie helps resolve the trauma that we saw her endure when she was abandoned by her first owner, Emily.  Jessie has a kind of existential crisis regarding if her life has any meaning since she is doomed to be discarded at the end of her owner's childhood.

The second thing that the movie does really well is capture the change that technology, particularly screens, have brought to childhood.  The animation captures it like a spell is being cast on the children without being too over-the-top.  There is one moment towards the end where the toys run through a stranger's house but no on notices because everyone, including parents and children) are on some type of screen.  The constant dopamine hit creates a tangible addiction that you can see in Bonnie.  There is a fantastic scene shows Smarty Pants and the other tech toys the difference between being games and actually playing.  And that's what kids do: they vicariously give life to their toys.

The two big negatives that come through this tech are the killing of imagination and the problem of bullying.  Bonnie and another girl named Blaze (Mykal-Michelle Harris) have stronger imaginations because they are not constantly glued to the screen.  They are not passive receivers of entertainment.  They have to produce the entertainment to be lived out in their toys.  This may seem like a small thing, but playing with toys forces you to produce rather than receive; to make rather than consume.  Screens cause this imaginitave muscle to atrophy.  In regards to bullying, social media has made it unavoidable.  Before Bonnie gets Lilypad, she is isolated from others because she is missing out.  But once she is on social media, she is subject to mockery in a way that she is not expecting.  In one scene she is happily heading to a destination in the car when she sees girls in her social media group start dogpiling on her.  Her mom is completely baffled as to why Bonnie has had such a horrible mood swing, but it was because she was attacked out of nowhere by people who now have constant access to her via Lilypad.

But I have to give the movie credit in that it does not take a luddite view of technology.  While it heavily focuses on all of the dangers, Lily is not a villain the same way that Stinky Pete or Lotso were in previous films.  Lily genuinely wants what is best for Bonnie, and the movie is smart enough to realize that there is a place for technological advancements.  It just needs to be tempered with wisdom.  This wisdom is lacking in Bonnie's parents who simply unleash this world of tech onto Bonnie without any real guidance or supervision.  The message is clear: parents need to walk with their children regarding tech, not throw them into the deep end and let them drown.

The movie also also has some surprising things to say about natural law without meaning to.  In the Toy Story universe, toys are meant to be played with and to make a child happy.  For the most part, toys who reject this point of view are unhappy (again see Stinky Pete and Lotso).  The sadness in the toy comes from no longer playing with their child when they grow up.  But this joy cannot help but be present when real play occurs, as with Smarty Pants.  There is a wonderful scene where the army of Buzz Lightyears are marching through the woods and one of them is picked up by a family.  These Buzzes don't yet realize that they are toys and mount a rescue mission to rescue their fellow Buzz.  But later when they see their fellow Buzz being held and loved by a child, their eyes fill with awe and longing.  The "captured" Buzz sees them and smiles contendedly because he has found his happiness.

This captures so well the principles of natural law.  We are all made with an end or a purpose and our happiness consists in living in accord with that end.  This is true even if we are unaware of what our purpose is.  Smarty Pants and the Buzzes do not know what real play and childhood affection are.  But once they receive them, they are filled with happiness.  It is the same way with us human beings.  Even if we don't know God, we are made to be filled with the love of God and others.  When we find this, we find our happiness.

I was also pleasantly surprised that this movie showed traditional male/female romance as an important theme.  Buzz is in love with Jessie and wants to marry her.  Leaving aside the implications of how toys can make vows of fidelity, it presents this desire for lifelong married commitment as natural and beautiful.  This could be a reflection of how Bonnie plays with them, but it is refreshingly different from more recent Disney offerings.

And I should also say that the movie is a great deal of fun.  Message movies are usually not very good, so Stanton and McKenna understand that their first job is to make the movie fun.  While the story of the rogue Buzzes don't connect up to the main story for a while, they are some of the most enjoyable and entertaining sequences.  Watching Buzz and Woody bicker like old buddies has a familiar comfort to it, like (to paraphrase CS Lewis) putting on an old, comfortable pair of slippers.  The movie is also beautifully rendered with wonderful use of color and lighting.

This movie is a big improvement on Toy Story 4, which was a bit unfocused and didn't have a strong theme.  While the films in the original trilogy are still better, Toy Story 5 is a worth successor and worth your time.

Now if you will excuse me, I have to see my three favorite toys from my childhood who are sitting on a shelf in my family room and I am going to take a moment to recall all of the adventures we used to have when I was young.