ReasonForOurHope

Friday, November 13, 2026

Film Review: You Can See Everything

 

Sexuality/Nudity Offensive

Violence No objection

Vulgarity Mature

Anti-Catholic Philosophy Mature

If there is one thing I would impress upon people who watch documentaries it would be that documentaries are not news reports.  Because these types of films are meant to capture moments of real life and not employ actors, we tend to talk about these movies as if they capture the truth free of narrative.

But the truth about many documentaries is that they tell stories in the same way that most movies do.  They have a story that they are trying to tell.  Instead of using a pre-planned script, the story is shaped in the editing.  The angles, the cuts and the music are there to tell you how to feel and shape your image of the subjects.

If you keep this in mind then I think You Can See Everything is and incredibly interesting movie.

Elizabeth Holmes is the tech entrepeneur who founded Theranos, a company that claimed it could diagnose diseases with a single drop of blood.  She was convicted of fraud and sentenced to prison.  In the weeks before she had to surrender herself, she and her husband Billy Evans invited documentarian Nathan Fielder to film them.  They opened up their lives to him to the point where Nathan moved into their rental home up until she went to prison.  In this part of the movie, Holmes comes off as incredibly odd.  Everything we see in her body language, tone of voice, and choice of words feels controlled and artificial.  Fielder and co-director Lance Oppenheim do an incredible job of dynamic angles and they make powerful use of extreme close-ups.  The latter saturate the movie so that you feel almost oppressed by how closely you are looking into the subject's eyes.  Throughout this section of the film, Holmes is presented like an enigma, a puzzle that Fielder is trying to solve.  They stare each other down like two poker players, with Fielder trying to find Holmes' tell.  And all the while it seems like these two are drawn closer and closer.

If this is all the movie was, then I would chalk it up to a slightly interesting curiosity.  But that is only the first half.

After Holmes goes to jail, Fielder brings the cut of his footage to actress Amanda Seyfried, who won awards for her portrayal of Holmes in the miniseries The Dropout.  After presenting the footage to her, Fielder asks Seyfried to reprise her role as Holmes for a series of re-enactments.  This is where the movie becomes truly fascinating.  Fielder writes scenes based on his recollections of interactions with Holmes and Evans.  He then directs these re-enactments with Seyfried and other actors in the same way he has been directing the documentary.  In these moments the line between the real and the fabricated begin to blur.  What makes this all the more interesting is that this blurring is part of the fascination with Holmes herself.  Fielder can't seem to figure out what is real and what is a performance.

And all of these portrayals put Evans in a terrible light.  The scenes with Evans himself do not flatter him, but the re-enactments try to cement him as a manipulative villain.  But the movie doesn't take the easy way out and cast the others as heroes.  Fielder is constantly shot in a way that makes him appear like an intrusive creep than a crusading hero.  Seyfried herself has moments where she comes off as incredibly unlikeable in her interactions with Evans.  Everyone on screen feels a little worse for the wear.

What I like about this are the questions that this raises about the medium of documentary film-making.  Should there be a narrative?  And once there is, is this the truth or just one point of view?  And because it is a documentary, is that fair?  Is it okay to use re-enactments or should they be left out because the audience did not get a chance to see the events for themselves?  Is anything we ever see on screen in a documentary "real?"  

Regardless of how manipulative or not you find Fielder, I could not deny his ability to draw you in.  I felt like Homer Simpson when Mr. Burns was staring at him and Homer thought, "Mmm... Look at his eyes. He's trying to hypnotize me."  As I kept feeling sucked in, I kept having to tell myself that Fielder is trying to hypnotize me into going with his narrative.  And his story is compelling.  I wanted to follow his theories until they resolved.

The sad thing is that rather than revealing more humanity, this movie feels like it is a commentary on the general dishonesty of people in society.  It feels like a dark, rather than an uplifting message.  This is not a criticism of the film's power, only a comment on how it will make you feel.  It is actually a much darker film than people think.  It tries to be shocking and raw.  There is one scene where without warning Fielder presents full-frontal male nudity.  There is no reason to do this other than to be a provocateur.

But this film is very effective at provoking.  As a Catholic, I'm not sure I agree with what is being implied about the human condition.  But Fielder so effectively presents his material that I could not stop talking about this movie days later.




Friday, November 6, 2026

Film Flash: Gozilla Minus Zero

 

Film poster showing a gigantic brownish cloud featuring a bright yellow light at the top left and blue beaming light at the middle right, with the film’s logo, the letter G like its predecessor, alongside the number "0.0" in the middle, and the release date at the bottom.


15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)


A worthy follow-up to the best Godzilla movie.  Thoughtful, emotional, and powerful.


Monday, November 2, 2026

New Evangelizers Post: It's Okay to Mourn

                                              


I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  
Today is the Feast of All Souls.

On this day we remember those who have gone before us in death, especially the poor souls in Purgatory. This Feast follows the Feast of All Saints to remind us of the hope that we have in our Heavenly homeland.

But this day can be very complicated, especially if we remember those we love who have died. And the older I get, the longer that list becomes. Remembering them and remembering how much I miss them is not at all a pleasant experience. I miss my grandfather’s smile. I miss how my friend and I would argue about comic books. I miss my mother’s laugh. But now those things are absent from this world.

In many ways, it feels like I am still mourning.

Don’t get me wrong, time has brought its own measure of healing to all of these losses. But they are still losses and I feel them as such.

St. Paul writes in 1 Thessalonians 4:13 “We do not want you to be unaware, brothers, about those who have fallen asleep, so that you may not grieve like the rest, who have no hope.” And indeed I have encountered those with amazing faith who greet the death of a loved one with complete trust in the Lord. These saintly people rejoice in their loved one’s entrance into Paradise and live in the hope of being reunited. This is an excellent witness and one that all of us should strive to emulate.

But for those of us who are not as saintly, it can be much more challenging. CS Lewis read this verse from St. Paul after the death of his beloved wife Joy and wrote “It astonishes me, the way we are invited to apply to ourselves words so obviously addressed to our betters. What St. Paul says can comfort only those who love God better than the dead, and the dead better than themselves. If a mother is mourning not for what she has lost but for what her dead child has lost, it is a comfort to believe that the child has not lost the end for which it was created. And it is a comfort to believe that she herself, in losing her chief or only natural happiness, has not lost a greater thing, that she may still hope to 'glorify God and enjoy Him forever.' “

What Lewis is getting at is that the saintly ones are focused on the loved one. But for the rest of us, we are also grieving for our own loss. St. Augustine found himself in this dilemma when a friend of his died and he was heartbroken. He wrote “Miserable I was, and miserable is every soul fettered by the friendship of perishable things — he is torn to pieces when he loses them, and then is sensible of the misery which he had before ever he lost them.” (Confessions IV.6)

Lewis commented on this section in The Four Loves when he wrote “Of course this is excellent sense. Don’t put your goods in a leaky vessel…I think that this passage in the Confessions is less a part of St. Augustine’s Christendom than a hangover from the high-minded Pagan philosophies in which he grew up. It is closer to Stoic ‘apathy’ or neo-Platonic mysticism than to charity. We follow One who wept over Jerusalem and at the grave of Lazarus, and, loving all, yet had one disciple whom, in a special sense, he ‘loved’…There is no escape along the lines St. Augustine suggests. Nor along any other lines. There is no safe investment. To love at all is to be vulnerable. Love anything, and your heart will certainly be wrung and possibly be broken.”


In other words, loving others means that we are vulnerable to pain and loss. It is true that we should strive to live the words of St. Paul and focus on the happiness of those who have gone before us. That is why today especially it is a wonderful act of charity to pray for the souls in Purgatory, so that their purgation may come to a swift end and they may finally know eternal rest.


But the pain we feel now, the pain we still feel after many years is a sign of the love that we still have. The loss that we’ve experienced leaves scars on our hearts. A priest once said to me that people think scars are ugly, but they are not. Scars are beautiful. They are beautiful because they show us where we were wounded and have been healed. The grief we still feel is not a sign that we have not healed, but that we are healed or healing.
You can read the whole article here.




Sunday, November 1, 2026

All Saints Day 2026

 






  The saints have been great friends to me throughout my life.  Today, we are reminded that our destiny is not of this world but of the next.  Failure, humiliation, loss, and suffering in this life are nothing compared to the glories that await the blessed.

It is so much easier to say it than to believe.

That is why we need the saints.  We need the concrete examples of holiness in this fallen world to help us remember that this world is not our home.

So today, I would like to share with you the litany of saints that my wife and I pray every day.  I am leaving out those who are not canonized or in the process.  There are many whose intercession I seek, like my mom and my grandparents, trusting that the love we still share will be strengthened through prayer.  But here are the saints that we turn to each day.

Immaculate Heart of Mary, pray for us.

St. Joseph, pray for us.

St. Gerard Majella, pray for us.

St. Padre Pio, pray for us.

Servant of God Lucia de Jesus Rosa dos Santos, pray for us.

Sts. Jacinta and Francesco Marto, pray for us.

Sts. Anne and Joachim, pray for us.

Sts. Elizabeth, Zechariah, and John the Baptist, pray for us.

Abraham, Sarah, Hannah and Rachel of the Old Testament, pray for us.

St. Gianna, pray for us.

Pope St. John Paul the Great, pray for us.

St. Teresa of Calcutta, pray for us.

St. Teresa of the Little Flower, pray for us.

St. Teresa of Avila, pray for us.

St. Catherine of Sienna, pray for us.

Bl. Miguel Pro, pray for us.

St. Carlo Acuits, pray for us.

St. Pierre Giorgio Frassati, pray for us.

Bl. Nicholas Steno, pray for us.

Bl. Michael McGivney, pray for us.

St. Theresa Benedicta of the Cross, pray for us.

St. Maxamillian Kolbe, pray for us.

St. Thomas Aquinas, pray for us.

St. Augustine, pray for us.

St. Maria Goretti, pray for us.

St. Joan of Arc, pray for us.

St. Francis of Assisi, pray for us.

St. Clare of Assisi, pray for us.

St. Anthony of Padua, pray for us.

St. Ignatius of Loyola, pray for us.

St. Dominic, pray for us.

St. Benedict, pray for us.

St. Philip Neri, pray for us.

St. Bartholomew, pray for us.

St. Andrew, pray for us.

St. Philip, pray for us.

St. Peter, pray for us.

St. John, pray for us.

St. James the Greater, pray for us.

St. James the Lesser, pray for us.

St. Jude Thaddeus, pray for us.

St. Simon, pray for us.

St. Matthew, pray for us.

St. Matthias, pray for us.

St. Mary Magdalene, pray for us.

St. Patrick, pray for us.

St. Peregrine, pray for us.

St. Paul, pray for us.

St. Stephen, pray for us.

Sts. Cosmos and Damian, pray for us.

St. William of Rochester, pray for us.

St. Faustina Kowalska, pray for us.

St. Raphael, pray for us.

St. Gabriel, pray for us.

St. Michael, pray for us.

All holy saints and angels, pray for us.




Thursday, October 29, 2026

Film Review: Street Fighter (2026)

 


Sexuality/Nudity Mature

Violence Mature

Vulgarity Acceptable

Anti-Catholic Philosophy Mature

Why are video games so difficult to adapt into movies?  


It seems like it should be an easy thing to do.  Granted, some movies and shows lend themselves

to a clear narrative like The Last of Us.

But so many of these games have such clear, distinct, and vivid characters with strong motivations and arcs.  


And yet, I would imagine most of us could name more  bad video game adaptations than good ones.  


I was thinking of this when I was watching the most recent adaptation of Street Fighter.


The movie centers around Ken (Noah Centineo) who has a love/hate relationship with his best friend Ryu (

Andrew Koji).  Ryu wins a great tournament by unleashing some evil energy, but then leaves the fighting scene. 

Ken devolves into an MTV party celebrity.  The dictator M. Bison (David Dastmalchian) arranges a tournament

to lure Ryu out of hiding.  Ken takes up the invitation to come out of Ryu’s shadow.  Meanwhile Chun-Li

(Callina Liang) is undercover trying to take Bison down from the inside.  


When I was directing theater, one of the best insights into the process I read was that casting is 90% of the job. 

I found that part of the process the most stressful, because it turns out that this principle is true.  I knew if I cast

the right people, the production would be great.  But if I miscast anyone, it would drag down the entire show. 

And Street Fighter s a mixed bag in this area.  Koji is excellent as Ryu, the brooding, pessimistic hero who is

trying to turn from his violent ways.  Liang is also excellent as Chun-Li, projecting strength and femininity. 

Vidyut Jammwal embodied the character of Dhalsim in the little screen time that he had, showing off his amazing

physicality.  And Hirooki Goto had one of the best turns in the movie as E. Honda where he portrayed him with

humor and honor.  


But the rest of the casting brings down the movie.  Dastmalchian is horribly miscast as M. Bison.  In the original

live-action film, Raoul Julia was literally dying and frail, but he projected supreme power.  Dastmalchian is a fine

actor, but he never projects the menace necessary for the character.  Centineo also cannot carry the movie on his

shoulders.  Something about his Ken felt very artificial.  Perhaps that was part of the character choice, but it then

doesn’t translate to the sincerity necessary for the character.  


The movie doesn’t know what it wants to be.  It is ostensibly a fighting tournament movie, but most of the most

important fights are outside of the tournament.  And even the important tournament fights are overlooked.  Vega

(Orville Peck) and Guille (Cody Rhodes) have a fight that we NEVER see, but it is only mentioned in the aftermath. 

I have no idea why you would skip something like this, except for budget reasons.


And they must have had budget problems.  The prologue to the movie is animated and it is not short.  And the

flashbacks are also all animated.  It’s like they ran out of money to film these scenes but realized they were needed

for character background.


But the real problem is that the movie cannot fully commit to itself.  When I saw the trailer, I was interested because

it reminded me of Netflix’s adaptation of One Piece.  On that show, the production design is insanely over-the-top and cartoonish, where you will have characters who

hide machine guns in their powdered wigs and they fight with swords in their mouths.  But on that show, the

characters fully commit to the reality of this world so that no matter how flamboyant they are, I believe their

motivations and the stakes involved.  Street Fighter wants to have the look of One Piece but feels embarrassed by it.  Comedians Andrew Schulz and Eric Andre feature prominently, always pointing out the silliness of the events of the film.  Comic relief can help with a strange premise the way Wolverine did in the

first X-Men movie, but the humor seemed to be more at the expense of the film.  The humor also boarders on perverse

sometimes, portraying most of the side characters are creepy weirdos. But the real problem is that the humor

destroys any drama.


You can see this particularly in the final scene of the movie, which I found utterly baffling.  The penultimate scene

sets up a chase where our heroes have to chase after the villains and our disaster will occur.  The final scene finds

them sitting by a country road hitch-hiking.  The entire scene felt like something out of a sketch comedy show with

no sense of immediacy, danger, or importance.  


The entire movie feels like a big bright balloon that slowly deflates so that all you’re left with is the empty husk

of something that once bounced with life.




Sunday, October 25, 2026

Film Flash: You Can See Everything

 


15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)

The most interesting film this year that is sure to inspire debate in the viewers


Monday, October 19, 2026

New Evangelizers Post: The Sacrifice of the Mass

                                             


I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  
Some people express confusion about the Mass when we say that it is a sacrifice. They ask “If this was the case, then wouldn’t we be sacrificing Jesus over and over?” It is a good question, and I am glad to address it here.

To be clear, the Council of Trent in Chapter VIII on its decrees on the Eucharist stated that the Eucharist is a true and real sacrifice (Canon 1) and that it is a “propitiatory” sacrifice, meaning that it brings reconciliation to God (Canon 2).

I am a philosopher by training. I like to always refer to the Father of Philosophy: Socrates. And whenever Socrates struggled with a problem, he would always go back to defining our terms. What is it we are actually talking about? In this case, I think we need to define the word “sacrifice.”

Pope Benedict XVI wrote a book before he was pope called The Spirit of the Liturgy. He addresses our common understanding of sacrifice as “something to do with destruction.” (pg. 41) We often think of sacrifice as giving something up, like our Lenten sacrifices of candy or social media. These are indulgences that hurt to lay aside. Sometimes we think of sacrifice in terms of life. Many ancient religions would kill an animal or even a human being as an act of sacrifice to their gods. But that is not the real meaning of “sacrifice.” Pope Benedict XVI understands the heart of sacrifice is union with God. What God wants is not some external gift: He wants me.

Even thinking about our Lenten sacrifices, what good does it do to give up candy or social media, if it does not draw us closer to God? Because that is the entire point of those sacrifices: to be brought more and more into union with God by letting go of the things that keep us away. It is the same with the sacrifice of the Mass. The sacrifice of Jesus is meant to bring us into union with Him. Pope Benedict writes, “Belonging to God has nothing to do with destruction… [i]t means emerging from the state of separation… of existing only for oneself in oneself.” (pg 42) In other words, the sacrifice of Jesus draws us out of our selfish separation from God and into union with Him through Jesus.

Christ on the Cross is an act of true sacrifice because it is an act of true love. Love is a gift of the self that God wants. Pope Benedict writes, “Such sacrifice has nothing to do with destruction. It is an act of new creation, the restoration of creation to its true identity.” (pg 48) In other words, this view of sacrifice is not about death or killing. Therefore we are not “re-killing” Jesus at the Mass. This view of sacrifice is about transforming us, which is something that should happen at the Mass.

Pope Benedict makes the distinction between two types of sacrifices: representation and replacement. In representation, there is something of the one who sacrifices in the gift. Pope Benedict points to Abraham sacrificing the ram or the Passover sacrifice of Exodus (pg. 52-53). There is something of the one who sacrifices in the offering. But with the replacement image, the sacrifice is done in place of the giver, literally a scapegoat. Someone else pays so that I do not have to. This is why God, in the Old Testament, kept rejecting Israel’s sacrifices: because they were more like economic transactions than tokens of love. If you take out the trash at home so you can guilt your wife into doing the dishes, your sacrifice is not done out of love, but rather it is a transaction. But if you take the trash out seeking nothing in return, and only do it because you love your wife and want to be closer to her. This is the representational sacrifice. This is the sacrifice of Christ at the Mass. 

You can read the whole article here.




Sunday, October 18, 2026

Film Flash: Street Fighter (2026)

 

15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)


Movie that's dumb and fun but gets less fun and more dumb as it goes.

Wednesday, October 14, 2026

Trailer Time: Narnia- The Magician's Nephew

 

Click here for the YouTube link to the trailer.


I have been trying to write about the news regarding the new Narnia movies from Netflix.  Every time I have tried, too many thoughts and feelings kept bubbling up.  I had too many things I wanted to say so that my paragraphs would crash together like a cacophony of chaos.  


Part of the reason I had such trouble is because it is difficult to level any kind of criticism against a movie without seeing any of it.  All the news reports have been troubling, but how can I have any sense of the movie’s quality until some of it is shown.


But now that the first teaser has been released, I have thoughts.

The teaser starts off in a way that made me incredibly hopeful.  The feel for the world and its child-like sense of wonder is apparent.  Even the fantastical Wood Between the Worlds looks sufficiently spectacular.

But, then when they get to Charon, it all falls off the rails.  The look, sound, and feel developed into something like a psychedelic trip.  

Here is the frustrating thing about all of this: the teaser shows that director Greta Gerwig has the skill to make an adaptation in the spirit of CS Lewis.  

Instead, she chooses not to.

I always remember Peter Jackson stating in an interview that the filmmakers behind The Lord of the Rings were very careful not to put any of their own cultural baggage and instead wanted to do their best at presenting Tolkien’s themes.  They did make changes to the story in adapting it, but all of it was in service to Tolkien.

The Magician’s Nephew feels like it is in service to Greta Gerwig.  She has spoken about her love of pop music and its effect on her.  She seems to be interpreting Lewis through this lens.

One of my biggest critiques is that Uncle Andrew and Jadis do not look sufficiently evil.  Andrew is the classic fool who thinks he is wise, but he also is someone who would be a dictator if he had any competence.  This Andrew looks more quirky than malevolent.  Jadis is the embodiment of the corrupted feminine.  Tilda Swinton was womanly in her intimidating power.

The Jadis in this teaser looks like she stepped out of The Fifth Element and has all the intimidating power of Ronald McDonald.

But the biggest thing that this teaser needed to do was get me to get on board with her version of Aslan.  If you are going to do such a radical experimentation on a beloved character, then show us why your vision should be supported.  But Aslan is barely in it and we get none of Meryl Streep’s performance.

In the book The Magician’s Nephew, Jadis is dissatisfied with her world of Charn, so she decides to destroy it.

I worry that this is what Gerwig is doing to Narnia.

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

TV Review: Lanterns Season One.

 I have to give it more time, but I think Lanterns might be the worst DC TV series ever made.


And I’ve seen Peacemaker.


There are so many problems with this show that it is difficult to know where to start.  I wrote in my review of the first episode that the darker tone could work if the story went to interesting and satisfying places.  


It did not.


As it got worse, a friend of mine asked, “Why are you still watching it?  Is it self-torture?”  I think it’s because at heart I am a Blue Lantern: I hold onto hope for as long as I can.


But hope for this show died along with Hal Jordan.


I cannot review why this how is so bad without spoilers so be warned:

SPOILERS FOR THE REMAINING REVIEW.


It is difficult to say anything about this show that hasn’t already been said, so if any of my ideas are parallel to what others are saying, my apologies.


The most obvious problem is that the show is morally abhorrent.  This should not surprise based on Peacemaker and the work of Tom King.  The “hero” of the story is John Stewart, who essentially becomes a villain.  In fact, everyone in this story is horrible.  The least horrible person is Hal Jordan, who you are supposed to hate.  Hal is presented as retrograde and out of touch.  But just like Archie Bunker, he is the only one who resonates with the audience.  This is in no small part due to Kyle Chandler’s fantastic performance.  But the show goes out of its way to tear Hal down so that it can build John up.


I wrote in my review for the movie Turning Red that the entire movie was written backwards from the punchline.  This means that instead of letting the natural and logical characters grow out of the story, everything is shoehorned into an essential message or point.  You find this at the end of the last episode where Hal’s hologram says to John, “My gut tells me you’re gonna be better at this job than I ever was.”


And there it is.


The whole point of the show was to tell (not SHOW) the audience that John is better than Hal.  


This is a problem because many people love Hal Jordan.  Hal Jordan means something to people.  To the writers, Hal Jordan is just a vehicle that can trauma dump and use as a stepping stone. Tom King did the same thing to Wally West in the comics in the single worst issue of any comic book I have ever read.  And now he has done the same thing to Hal.


To sum up the story:


A manhunter (a shapeshifting violent alien) was brought to Earth by the previous Green Lantern of Sector 2814, Abin Sur.  In mercy, Abin spared the manhunters life and the manhuner murdered him.  The manhunter set up in a small town called Rushville where she made the inhabitants follow her like a cult leader because she could cure all their diseases.  A fugitve named Kate Kane came to Rushville and was saved by the manhunter who made her sheriff and impregnated her with a manhunter baby.  When Hal finds out there are aliens in Rushville, he investigates and his trainee John comes with him.  They find out that the manhunter has a giant stockpile of weapons that work against Green Lanterns.  Meanwhile some other aliens want revenge on the manhunter for killing their planet.  Also, the Guardians of the Universe want John to take away Hal’s ring because he was trained by Sinestro.  Hal decides he can’t trust John and abandons him in a crashed car which later catches fire.  The manhunter (who in an earlier episode had sex with John) saves his life.  The manhunter begins killing the people of Rushville indiscriminately as Hal tries to save them.  When his ring runs out of charge, John tries to take the ring from him.  When the manhunter shows up, John assassinates her with a sniper rifle, takes the ring, but chooses not to be a Green Lantern.


Hal Jordan goes to prison because of the death and destruction in Rushville.  When he gets out, he starts a romance with Kate Kane, who is still sheriff.  He moves back to Rushville where the people blame Hal for all of the destruction and try to kill him.  Kate’s teenage son saves Hal and Hal discovers that he is a manhunter who has broken Sinestro out of prison so that Sinestro could make him a power battery that could kill a Guardian.  When Hal tells Kate, he says that he wants to protect her and her son by leaving Rushville and laying low until they can find a place safe from the Guardians.


Her response to this is to shoot him in the head.


She then calls John Stewart who comes to investigate and discovers everything.  He digs up Hal’s corpse and takes his ring.  We also learn along the way that Hal’s father and grandfather committed suicide, so Hal is broken.  John finds Sinestro, tortures him and takes the power battery.  Kate’s son finds John and beats him up but then tells John to kill him so that he doesn’t turn evil.  John then finds Kate tells her he figured out she murdered Hal, but he doesn’t turn her in because “Hal wouldn’t want that.”  He then tells Guy Gardner to leave Earth and that he is the only lantern for the planet.  And top it off, he decides that the Green Lantern oath is stupid so he comes up with his own (which sounds a lot more like the Sinestro Corps oath).


And that’s Lanterns.


As you can see, John is pretty much evil.  He becomes an accessory after the fact to murder, steals Sinestro’s power battery and bullies away the actual Green Lantern of Earth because he can.  He assassinated the manhunter because he says, without evidence she wanted to die.  He tries to steal Hal’s ring while he is trying stop people from getting killed.


Going back to this point, the manhunter was the one indiscriminately murdering the people of Rushville, but Hal is the one who is blamed even though is the ONLY ONE trying to save them.  When he returns to the town they try to murder him, but that is all swept under the rug until he is actually murdered.


His murder also makes no sense.  If he was saying that he was going to expose Kate’s son to put him in danger, making some kind of threat, then there would be some logic.  But he was literally telling her his plan to save them.  But she was so upset at the idea of having to leave her stupid, violent community that she put a bullet in his brain.  This was not an accident, like the gun just went off.  She pulled it out of the holster, took off the safety, pointed it at his face, and pulled the trigger.  


And because we are not supposed to like Hal, she shouldn’t go to jail.


The writers think they are incredibly clever, but the plot holes are so numerous that the story cannot hold water.  It is even more infuriating because it is clear that the writers think that they are high-minded and sophisticated.  It’s like Prometheus where you had supposedly smart characters constantly doing stupid things.


Why would the murderer bring to town the one man who could figure out you are the killer?  If the manhunter did want to die, why did it go out of the way to use its husband as a decoy to save its own life?  If the Kerry’s son didn’t want Hal to know who saved him, why didn’t he just not show himself to Hal?  If the power ring can cross interstellar distances like nothing, why can’t it take out the handful of satellites that are killing the townsfolk?  Why can’t Sinestro forge a power ring if he can make a power battery, which is much harder to make?


Also, Sinestro is trapped on an island where you can’t swim across the water.  He complains about not being able to leave.  So to be clear, he can forge a lantern power battery, but he can’t cobble together a canoe?  I could go on and on, but this article is already too long.


All of this is so wasteful.  Hal Jordan and John Stewart are fantastic characters in the comics.  They don’t always agree or get along, but they are both heroes.  Nothing about Lanterns is heroic.  


I'm not saying that Hal and John are paragons of virtue in the comics. But the moral relativism that is spread throughout this entire series is so repellant to me as a Catholic. I could put up with the language issues, though to bizarre incorporation of nudity and sexuality is baffling. But above all, the show feels like an inversion of morals.


Going back to Hal, the writers definitely have John Walker Syndrome with him: they want you to hate him, but they are so morally out of touch that he is the only one who makes some kind of sense.  For me, the most outrageous scene was during the mass murder in Rushville, Hal looked completely out of his depths and overwhelmed.  Hal may be reckless, but they wrote him in this scene as incompetent.  He also left John to die in the wrecked car,which makes Hal an attempted murderer.


Honestly, the treatment of John isn't better. The writers mean to elevate him, but instead, his morally compromised view of the world is so bleak that none of the heroism of the comic book version of the character can be found.


The main problem from this show is that the writers don’t care about these characters.  They mean nothing to them.


But even if they had used completely original characters, the show would still be morally repugnant.  That’s what makes this so much worse.  It would be like someone beating you to death with your favorite childhood toy.  There is a deep-seated level of hatred for the DC heroes and their fans that I cannot fathom.  That hate the Green Lanterns, joking how “Green” is stupid so the show is just called Lanterns.  They tried to excuse it as a stupid joke, but it clearly wasn’t.  They disdain everything about the Green Lanterns and want to strip it away and reforge it in their own broken image, even rewriting the Green Lantern Oath.


It is supposed to be “In Brightest Day, in Blackest Night, no evil shall escape my sight…”


But in Lanterns, Day is NIght and evil is seen as right.


These lanterns cast only darkness instead of light.


Monday, October 5, 2026

New Evangelizers Post: Know Scripture, Know Christ

                                            


I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  

“Ignorance of Scripture is Ignorance of Christ.”

This might be the most famous quote from the saint whose feast we celebrated a few days ago: St. Jerome.  There are many legendary stories about him, his temper, his austerity… but one thing he is best known for is his dedication to Scripture.  He was one of the driving forces of the Latin Vulgate: the translation of the Bible into Latin.  Knowing that many people in the Christian community of the 4th century could not read things like ancient Hebrew, Jerome set out to make the Word of God more accessible to the people.  

That is why St. Jerome wrote in his commentary on Isaiah: “For if, according to the Apostle Paul, Christ is the power of God and the wisdom of God and the one who does not know the Scriptures does not know the power of God and his wisdom, [then] ignorance of the Scriptures is ignorance of Christ.”  But then just a few sentences later, he says “let no one think that I desire to summarize the subject of this book in a few words, when the Scripture at hand contains all the Lord’s mysteries.”  He said that ignorance of Scripture was ignorance of Christ, but that he did not intend to summarize the book.

This got me thinking about what he could have meant.  I’ve quoted St. Jerome for many years since I teach Scripture to high school students.  And year after year we go over many of the tools of Scriptural analysis: exegesis, the 2-source Theory, form criticism, and the like.  I give them a basic overview of the content of the Bible.  In this way, in coming into contact with the Word of God written in human language, they also encounter the Word of God who was in the beginning with God.

And here in formation, we continue to learn and overcome our ignorance.  But it is only recently that I think I started to understand what St. Jerome was really getting at.  If ignorance of Scripture is ignorance of Christ, then knowing Scripture is knowing Christ.  For many years, I thought this meant that the study of Scripture brings us closer to God.  And that is very true.  But I don’t think that is all St. Jerome meant.

What does it really mean to “know” Scripture?

I think of how when I entered diaconate formation, we became obliged to pray the liturgy of the hours every day.  My apologies to you who are holier than I, but when I started praying morning prayer and evening prayer, it felt more of a chore than anything.  I remember during my interviews before entering formation, I asked if we could do virtual classes from home instead of driving in when it got snowy.  I remember that the head of formation not only said no, but he said that it was important to come so that we could pray the liturgy of the hours together.  And I will tell you that I did not understand.  I was ignorant.

I fulfilled my obligation to pray the liturgy of the hours, to pray the psalms and canticles.  I began to memorize them from repetition, like the Magnificat or the Canticle of Zechariah.  But imperceptibly, something else was happening.

I remember I was driving down the street one day, feeling a little down.  And without realizing it, I started praying, “Oh God, you are my God.  For you I long.  My body pines for you like a dry weary land without water.”  Or I’d be taking out the garbage on a cold morning and I think, “Frost and chill, bless the Lord.”  Or I would be kneeling after mass and pray, “at the name of Jesus, every knee must bend in the heavens, on earth, and under the earth, and every tongue proclaim to the glory of God the Father, Jesus Christ is Lord.”

This felt different than just rote memorization.  I asked my spiritual director about this and he said that this is part of what should be happening.  The Scripture isn’t just something external to us that we read.  Instead, the Word of God is being woven into the very fabric of our lives.  

You can read the whole article here.