ReasonForOurHope

Monday, June 3, 2024

New Evangelizers Post: Jesus and the Rich Man Part 1

                                                                     


 


I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  

Mark 10:17-31 tells the story of the Rich Man and Christ’s teaching on wealth. The story begins with the transitional phrase, “As He was setting out on a journey…” (Mk 10:17). This acts as a separating phrase that distinguishes this passage from the one that came before it. In the chosen passage, we see two conversations take place. The first is between Christ and the Rich Man (Mk 10:17-22), and the second is between Christ and His disciples about wealth (Mark 10:23-30). Both of these conversations are held together because the second conversation is a direct response to the events of the first. Together they form a complete story about Jesus and His teachings on wealth. The structure of the passage is that of three parts with a conclusion: “Jesus and the rich man,” (Mark 10-17-22) “Jesus and the disciples,” (Mark 10:23-27) “Jesus and Peter,” (Mark 10:28-30), and the conclusion (Mark 10:31)

As Jesus is setting out on His journey, “a man ran up, knelt down before him and asked Him ‘Good Teacher, what must I do to inherit eternal life?’” (Mk 10:17). The only other place in Mark where people “run” up to greet Jesus is when an amazed crowd runs up to Him (Mk 9:15). This verb may be used to show the effect that Jesus had on the people of his day. The only other time in Mark’s Gospel that someone kneels before Jesus is the leper (Mk 1:40). In both passages, it shows great reverance fr the Lord. We can therefore see that at the beginning of the story, the rich man comes to Jesus with an intense sincerity of heart. He is truly looking for the answer to his question. This is contrasted to Jesus’ enemies who would often ask him questions to trap him (Mk 11:27-33; 12:13-27).

Although sometimes this story is known as “The Rich Young Man,” there is no reference to the man’s age in Mark’s Gospel. It is only in the parallel story in Matthew that we are told that He is a young man, and that is a detail that is only given towards the end of his conversation with Christ. (Mt 19:20) Luke gives us the detail that the rich man is a “ruler” (Lk 18:18). However, it is clear from all three Gospels that he is wealthy because he has “many possessions”. This rich man uses the specific verb “inherit” regarding eternal life. This is similar to apocryphal writings like 1 Enoch 40:9, “who is in charge of the repentance to hope of those who inherit everlasting life.” There is also Sibylline Oracles lines 46-47 that state, “But those that honor the true eternal God inherit life.” With this background, the “question of the man who runs up to Jesus presupposes expectations of this kind.” The phrase “eternal life” was one that was common as an understanding of what would occur in the Messianic Era. This would imply that the man sees Jesus as the Messiah.

Jesus’ response is, “‘Why do you call me good? No one is good but God alone.’” (Mk 10:18). Jesus is reminding the man that God is the source of all goodness and that any goodness that we have in this world is from God alone. This is not a repudiation of His own divinity, as if by saying this, that it is wrong to call Him good because Christ is not God. The Church Father Origen references this passage and states that Jesus “is not of a different goodness… because He proceeds from no other source but from that primal goodness…”

Christ then points the man to the Scriptures. Jesus then proceeds to paraphrase the commandments. “‘You shall not kill; you shall not commit adultery; you shall not steal; you shall not bear false witness; you shall not defraud; honor your father and your mother.’” (Mk 10:19) It should be noted that these are not all of the commandments, nor are they in the order in which they are traditionally listed. Of note is “you shall not defraud.” This is perhaps a paraphrasing of the commandments against coveting. It may also be a reference to the words of the Prophet Malachi 3:5: I will draw near to you for judgment, and I will be swift to bear witness against sorcerers, adulterers, and perjurers, those who deprive a laborer of wages, oppress a widow or an orphan, or turn aside a resident alien,without fearing me, says the LORD of hosts.

This injunction against defrauding is followed by the command to honor your parents. It is possible that these two commandments are placed together because of an earlier statement by Christ regarding the duty of children towards their parents:

For Moses said, ‘Honor your father and your mother,’ and ‘Whoever curses father or mother shall die.’ Yet you say, ‘If a person says to father or mother, “Any support you might have had from me is qorban”’ (meaning, dedicated to God),you allow him to do nothing more for his father or mother. You nullify the word of God in favor of your tradition that you have handed on. And you do many such things.” (Mk 7:10-13)

Here, Jesus criticizes the Pharisees for allowing children to essentially “defraud” their parents with a loophole: if they declare that they will give their support to God instead of their parents, then they no longer are obligated to financially support their parents. Jesus sees this as “nullify[ing] the Word of God.” It is, in a sense, defrauding one’s parents of their rightful due. This may be why the command to honor your parents comes after the injunction against defrauding in Mark 10.

From a textual critical view, there are some ancient manuscripts that do not have this reference to defrauding in this passage. It is possible that this is influenced by the fact that in the parallel versions of the story in Matthew 19 and Luke 18, this reference to defrauding is also omitted. It is suggested that the fact that the other synoptic Gospels omit it, then this influenced some scribes to also omit it from Mark.

You can read the whole article here.




Friday, May 31, 2024

Catholic Skyalker: 12-Year Anniversary

   


(5/31/24: Feast of the Visitation)
Once again, this milestone snuck up on me.

Over the course of 12 years I've made over 2,670 posts to this blog.  I'm sure there are many who would call this an immense waste of time.  But I have found a great sense of satisfaction from my writings here.  

I hope I have been insightful, witty, and interesting.  If I have failed in this department, I do apologize.  I do write with you, Dear Reader, in mind.  You take the time to read this blog when you could be doing anything else, so I want to honor that sacrifice of time that you make by giving you something worthwhile to read.  


Much has happened in the last 12 years.  Since beginning this blog:
-my mother and both of my remaining grandparents passed away (God rest their souls)
-my father-in-law  and mother-in-law passed away (God rest their souls)
-my wife and I weathered some rough employment situations
-I broke my back and have surgery 4 times.
-I became a godfather
-I was asked to write for NewEvangelizers.Com
-I've produced 9 more movies
-I've written, directed, and produced two plays and one musical.
-I'm just got a second Master's Degree
-I finished my first year of Diaconate Formation (I will find out later if the Church has discerned whether I should return)

This last one has taken up a good deal of my time this past year, the result of this is that I have written less here this year than in years past.  I hope to be able to find the proper balance to keep writing, if that is God's will.

And there may be new possibilities on the horizon.

All of this occurring during the tumultuous times we've lived through like COVID.

Through it all, I tried to write here regularly.  And now after ten years, I've produced:

-357 Film Reviews
-125 Essays
-273 New Evangelizers Articles
-12 Years of the Best and Worst of Movies, TV, and Comics.


Together we raised money for charity.  We've prayed together.  And hopefully we also laughed together.

Thank you again, Dear Reader, for taking this journey with me.  I pray that we will continue to walk this path of faith, film, and philosophy for many years to come.

God Bless You All!
Catholic Skywalker - 2024

Thursday, May 30, 2024

Film Review: The Fall Guy

 








Sexuality/Nudity Mature

Violence Mature

Vulgarity Mature

Anti-Catholic Philosophy Acceptable

This movie should work better than it does.  

The Fall Guy revolves around Colt Seavers (Ryan Gosling), an affable stunt man who has no ego as he takes abuse from the man he stunts for, Tom Ryder (Aaron Taylor-Johnson), because he loves his job and is in love with the camera operator Jody Moreno (Emily Blunt).  However, an accident derails his career and relationship.  But years later, Tom's producer Gail Meyer (Hannah Waddingham) lures Colt out of retirement to work on Jody's new movie and to help locate a missing Tom Ryder.  What follows is a charming, action-packed, fun adventure.  

But it never fully clicks.

First of all I have to say that this movie has some great leads.  Gosling and Blunt have great chemistry.  Here you have two actors who are working at the top of their level in a summer popcorn movie giving everything that an action/comedy performance needs.  Both of them are incredibly likeable and this helps carry the entire movie.

On top of that director David Leitch once again shows he knows how to shoot action.  Watching his previous work in films like Bullet Train and Nobody, you know that Leitch is going to give everything he can to make sure you have a visceral, high-octane experience.  I found myself getting lost in all the creative set-pieces and I kept looking forward to the next sequence the movie would offer, knowing that it would be fun to watch.  For this, Leitch and the movie earn more respect than it might otherwise deserve.

Ultimately, the movie is a love-letter to stunt-people.  This film takes you behind the scenes and shows you all the ways in which human beings put their saftey and their lives on the line so that the audience can maximize their enjoyment of the movie.  Seeing this movie will give anyone a newfound appreciation of these unsung heroes of the silver screen.

So with all of these things going for it, why does this movie never reach its potential?

The main reason is the script.

Writers Glen A. Larson and Drew Pearce have written a screenplay that they think is very clever.  But it is never as clever as they think it is.

First of all, they pack the movie with a lot of meta-humor.  The characters spend lots of time talking about movie contrivances regarding the film they are shooting.  But these also apply to the movie we are watching.  Sometimes this works out well, as in a split-screen dialogue scene between Gosling and Blunt.  But other times it feels like they are beating you over the head with the analog between the two so that the horse is still being beaten long after it is dead.

Second, the script does not know how to pace.  The first twenty minutes or so hum along very nicely.  But when Colt begins working on Jody's set, she decides to hash out their relationship problems in front of the entire cast and crew through a megaphone.  Not only is this incredibly off-putting, but the script makes the mistake a lot of comedies do: it plays out the joke too long, hoping it will get funnier.  But it doesn't.  There are several times in the movie when everything seems to slow down for a comedy scene (like Colt getting high and seeing unicorns or his multiple attempts to get a key for a hotel room) that isn't all that funny and bogs down the run time.

Finally, the movie doesn't know how to create stakes.  What starts as a simple matter of hi-jinks eventually turns into a matter of life and death.  But instead of feeling greater intensity, we feel less.  Towards the end of the 2nd act, Colt is fleeing for his life on a speedboat.  As he does so, he calls up Jody.  Does he explain that he is being chased by killers for reasons that could affect her life as well?  No.  Instead, he goes on a monologue about why their relationship ended.  The scene is meant to be an emotinal catharsis.  Instead it told me that Colt (and the movie itself) don't take the threat facing him seriously.  And at that point, neither did I.

The movie does a good job pointing out how fame and narcisism can completely warp a person's character.  Colt and Jody's relationship also show how the masculine and the feminine compliment each other and they are not in competition against each other.  The movie also wants to say something about the transcendent nature of storytelling.  This would be a more powerful message if Jody's movie did not look utterly ridiculous.  

Despite its flaws, I enjoyed my time watching The Fall Guy.  I can see myself going back and rewatching some of those fun action scenes.  

But I will probably not sit through the whole movie again.

 


Tuesday, May 28, 2024

Film Flash: Furiosa

 undefined


15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)


As good as Fury Road, focused on world-building and epic revenge (a bit too long)

Film Flash: IF

 

Poster featuring various creatures including a girl and man walking across a street.

15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)


Heartfelt, touching film about the power of love, memory, and imagination.  Reminiscent of peak PIXAR

Star rating 4 of 5.png

Film Flash: Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes

 

undefined

15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)


Best Apes movie since Dawn, though the middle act drags a bit.

Star rating 3.5 of 5.png

Film Flash: The Garfield Movie

 

15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)


Mediocre, even for a big Garfield fan like me.  Otherwise, you won't like it.