ReasonForOurHope

Tuesday, December 30, 2025

Catholic Skywalker Awards: Best in Movies 2025

 


With 2025 coming to a close, it is time for us to choose what the best entertainment of the year was.  And just as the Academy Awards have their "Oscars", so too the Catholic Skywalker Awards have their "Kal-El's"









 I have gone through as many movies as possible this year. This year I have seen only about 47 movies to come out this year.  There are some (like Is This Thing On?) that I did not get a chance to view before the end of the year.  Also, of the movies I've seen, I will only be counting theatrical movies.  For the last few years I have included streaming-only films as well because COVID limited our choices.  But now that everything is open and has been open for a while, I will no longer be including those streaming movies for award consideration.  

So of the movies  I've seen this year, here are the winners:

(My appreciation and judgment of a film should not be taken as a recommendation. Choosing to watch any of these films is the reader's responsibility)



BEST PICTURE

Superman


 



From my review:

Writer/Director James Gunn throws you into the deep end at the very start of the movie.  He completely skips the entire origin story.  In fact, he skips what would normally be the first act of a movie.  We are told that three weeks earlier Superman (David Corenswet) stopped a war between two nations and that three hours earlier one of those nations sent a metahuman to Metropolis who beat Superman so badly that he had to retreat.  The movie begins with that shot from the teaser of Superman crashing into Antarctica to get to the Fortress of Solitude.  There are no flashbacks to get you caught up, instead the movie pushes forward at breakneck speed.  In the Fortress, we encounter a looped message from Superman's Kryptonian parents Jor-El and Lara who tell him that he is to do good for the Earth.  But the rest of the message has been corrupted and has never been heard.  But this message established Superman's whole mission of being a hero.

The story centers around Lex Luthor (Nicholas Hoult) and his obsession to take Superman down.  During these exploits, Superman is sometimes assisted by "The Justice Gang," consisting of Guy Gardner "Green Lantern" (Nathan Fillion), Mr. Terrific (Edi Gathegi), and Hawkgirl (Isabela Merced).  As Luthor's plans continue to unfold Superman's life begins to fall apart all the while Lois Lane (Rachel Brosnahan) and Jimmy Olsen (Skyler Gisondo) work behind the scenes to help him.

I don't want to give away too much of the plot, because watching it unfold is part of the fun.

Why did I love this movie so much?

Part of it is that it feels like the comic books I read come to life.  Moreso than most superhero films, is able to translate that feeling of reading good comic books.  Most of the time these either go too goofy and campy or they go too "realistic."  This movie is bright and colorful with imaginative spectacle while at the same time having clear, distinct, and interesting characters along with a strong dramatic through-line.

Perhaps my feelings are colored by the fact that Gunn nails the essence of the comic characters.  Superman is the ultimate aspirational hero.  He embodies goodness.  I can tell you when I went from liking to loving the movie is when in a moment of frustration Superman yells, "Good Gosh!"  His refusal to take God's name in vain won me over.

But the other characters are also interpreted very well.  Guy Gardner is a jerk who you love and that is how is portrayed.  He is frustratingly dismissive and arrogant, but you just can't help but love him because of this as he knocks people down with a giant green middle finger.  Gunn also perfectly translated Mr. Terrific to the big screen.  He is a genius who is always the smartest guy in the room who and it frustrates him so much to have to slow down and explain everything.  I love how Mr. Terrific's biggest problem with Luthor doesn't seem to be his evil, but his shoddy science.  In the James Gunniest scene in the film, we also get to see Terrific take down an entire group of bad guys while an obscure pop song plays in the background.  Luthor is played with an energetic evil.  Lois is portrayed as smart and strong without having to take Superman down a notch.

A note here about the dog, Krypto. I was skeptical about his incorporation into the movie as too campy.  But Gunn makes it work.  While Krypto is often present to help Superman get out of a jam, he is almost as unruly and destructive as some of the villains.  The best way I can describe him is chaotic good: when he shows up he could just as easily make things worse as better.  The movie captures that love you have for an unruly dog that doesn't understand how you could be upset when he loves you so much.

...

Thematically the movie works incredibly well.  This Superman is a young man who is still trying to find who he is.  He has the simple trust of a Kansas farm boy and he sees the world in those very simple terms.  There is a scene towards the beginning where Lois interviews Superman.  The scene actually goes on for a long time and should grind the movie to a halt, but instead I found it fascinating as Lois pushed Superman to reflect on his actions.  Lois questions everyone and everything as a good skeptical reporter should do.  Superman trusts his moral compass because he feels the responsibility to protect the innocent.  Neither are necessarily wrong, but the conflict leads to some great character sparks.  

In one of the movie's most touching scenes, Pa Kent (Pruitt Taylor Vince) has a heart to heart with Clark about the role of parents and children and identity.  It is a simple moment but profound in its simplicity.  And it is the simple, country decency of Pa and Ma Kent (Neva Howell) that form the invisible backbone of the movie.

The performances are generally excellent. Corenswet steps into the role perfectly.  His Superman is not the legendary icon that Christopher Reeves was.  Nor is he the angsty and brooding Henry Cavill.  There is an innocence to Corenswet's performance that is different than in most interpretations of the character on screen.  I heard a reviewer say that he plays him like a large boy and his dog trying to do his best in a complicated world.  Brosnahan is a fantastic Lois.  I completely buy her chemistry with Corenswet along with their conflicts.  Her strength and intelligence is always present but always in a feminine and not masculine way.  Hoult's Luthor is a step above Jessie Eisenberg's.  He talks fast and thinks fast and is so casually cruel about life that he is the perfect foil to the life-loving Superman.  Fillion plays Guy Gardner to perfect.  But a real standout is Gathegi as Mr. Terrific.  On the page, this character could come off as robotic, because he is at times rather cold.  But instead of cold, Gathegi makes him cool.  He has a swagger and a confidence that make you want to be like him.  And the Kents play there part with an honest country simplicity.  Ma keeps calling Pa a "mush" because he is overly emotional, but it comes off with less of a criticism but more of a tender teasing.  These two aren't secretly sophisticated sages.  They are just a plain man and his wife who seem to embody hard work, love, and family.  

...

But above all, in 2025 particularly, I left the theater feeling good.  I was shocked how few theatrical movies this year were capable of doing that.  





RUNNERS UP
Fantastic Four: First Steps
David
Song Sung Blue
Wicked: For Good


BEST DIRECTOR
James Gunn- Superman

Original photo by Erik Drost






James Gunn is a very hit and miss director for me.  I loved Guardians of the Galaxy and loathed The Suicide Squad.  He is a very Jekyll and Hyde director, indulging in both his aspirational and deviant tendencies.  Fortunately for Superman, he was more akin to the Guardians than The Squad.

As I wrote in my review for the movie:

"Gunn definitely brought his A-game when directing this movie.  Even now some of his visuals are sticking with me.  He knows how to make Superman look iconic (as when he is rising out of a destroyed building) or romantic (as when he flying in air while kissing Lois) or vulnerable (as when he is beaten up in the fetal position in the ice of Antarctica).  This is a fun movie to watch.  He wisely incorporates the John Williams score that Zack Snyder avoided so much.  But Gunn uses it to maximum effect for both thrills and inspiration."

I was also shocked at how well he was able to keep you engaged in the non-superheroics.  The long interview scene with Clark and Lois is just as interesting and fascinating as any other part of the movie and it did not require tights and CGI.  He showed that he understood that unless we cared about the characters as people, no amount of spectacle would draw us in.





RUNNERS UP
James Chu - Wicked: For Good
Joseph Koskinski - F1: The Movie
Craig Brewer - Song Sung Blue
Christopher McQuarrie - Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning




BEST ACTOR
Dwayne Johnson - The Smashing Machine





From my review: 

"The thing that sticks out the most about this movie are the performances.  This is hands-down Dwayne Johnson's best performance.  The makeup job on him is so good that he is sometimes unrecognizable.  In his career, Johnson has leaned heavily on his natural charisma and it has gotten him far.  But here, he has to let go of most of those tricks and builds a subtle, complex character.  His Mark Kerr is absolutely fascinating.  He is a savage in the ring.  But when he is in public he is so measured and gentle.  You can feel the realism of the performance, where Mark's size would scare people so he has to go out of his way to put people at ease.  But when his temper flares, its terrifying.  He is not an oversimplified gentle giant.  Instead, he is a shaken soda can with the cap ready to explode."




RUNNERS UP
Hugh Jackman - Song Sung Blue
Timothee Chalamet - Marty Supreme
Jack Quad - Novocaine
Brendan Fraser - Rental Family



BEST ACTRESS
Kate Hudson - Song Sung Blue





What I appreciated most about Hudson's performance in this movie was how realistic it felt.  Some my find her accent a little thick, but to me it felt very natural to someone native to that area.  Hudson plays someone who, in many ways, is an ordinary working-class woman.  But in that ordinariness, she reflects so much of our own lived experience.  She has very modest life-goals, but still has the desire to shine as someone special.  And in her ordinariness, she is not a simplistic saint.  Hudson shows us all her flaws, petty desires, and other foibles alongside her basic decency.  And when the story takes a turn, Hudson reveals even more depth as a woman who loses herself and tries to find the strength to find herself again.  All the while, she shows off her wonderful singing talent so that you can see her charisma shine through.

RUNNERS UP
Vanessa Kirby - Fantastic Four: First Steps
Emily Blunt - The Smashing Machine
Cynthia Erivo - Wicked: For Good
Elizabeth Olson - Eternity



BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR
Mark Hamill - The Life of Chuck




I actually think is one of Hamill's best on-screen performances.  His character plays the grandfather of the main character, who is a young dreamer.  Hamill's accountant grandfather tries to steer young Chuck away from an artistic

life with music and into a practical and stable life of accounting.  What could have been a stereotypical wet-blanket of a character instead has surprising depth.  He gives a beautiful speech about how noble it is to be an accountant and magical math is.  Credit is due here to the writer, but Hamill is the one who makes that speech come alive with a sense of gentle, generous wisdom.  All the while you see as his character carries a dark secret that he tries to shield away from his young grandson.  While I did not like the movie, this performance was excellent.


RUNNERS UP
Calumn Turner - Eternity
Nicholas Hout - Superman
Mason Thames - Regretting You
Joseph Quinn - Fantastic Four: First Steps



BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Mia Sara - The Life of Chuck
 


Mis Sara still has all the charisma she had in Ferris Bueller's Day Off without behaving like she did when portraying a teenager.  She plays her part as Chuck's grandmother with life and energy to directly foil her fuddy-duddy husband without ever coming off as a henpecking girlboss.  Her affection and chemistry with Hamill is excellent as her performance does not dominate his, but gives it balance.  She encourages Chuck's creativity with spirit and energy and comes off as the fun grandma that many of us had.  Because of her, you understand Chuck's deep emotional connection to music because it essential to Sara's performance.

RUNNERS UP
Kerry Condon - F1: The Movie
Mari Yamamoto - Rental Family
Karen Gillen - The Life of Chuck
Ella Anderson - Song Sung Blue





BEST SCREENPLAY
Hikari and Stephen Blahut– Rental Family





Rental Family is such an interesting movie because it challenges you with its premise: selling emotional catharsis with performance.  In the film, a company hires actors to play parts to live out moments for emotional fulfillment for clients in Japan.  For example, they act as mourners for someone who pretends to be having a funeral so that he can hear people say good things about him before he dies.  But the company also sells lies.  The main story revolves around Brendan Fraser's character lying to a little girl pretending to be her American father.  

Normally, I would reject this premise out of hand as a horrible set up of deception.  But to the credit of the writers, they draw us in to the complexity of the situation.  First, they point out that there is a big stigma around mental health counseling in Japanese culture, so what they do is the equivalent of therapy.  Second, the story plays out the complications and consequences of telling lies in a way that confronts its own premise head on.  What I loved about the writing was that it invited me as an audience member to look at the situation and use my own judgment regarding the character's actions.  It allowed me to see both sides of the situation without putting its thumb on the scales.  And even when I decided who I felt, there was enough depth for me to have complicated feelings about it.  Depth of this kind is rare in movies and I greatly enjoyed it here.



RUNNERS UP
The Naked Gun
Novocaine
KPop Demon Hunters
Fantastic Four: First Steps


BEST MAKEUP
Wicked: For Good


As with the previous Wicked film, the makeup was excellent.  It seems obvious, but the green skin on Elphaba feels so natural to the character that you never once question it.  As as some of the transformations occur throughout the movie, you can feel the textures of the characters in the makeup.

RUNNERS-UP
Superman
Fantastic Four: First Steps
Predator: Badlands
Captain America: Brave New World


BEST SPECIAL EFFECTS


Superman

 




Not only are the special effects excellent, but James Gunn knows how to use them.  He knows how to make Superman look iconic, but he also knows how to have fun with the effects, as when Guy Gardner destroys tanks with the middle finger.  

RUNNERS-UP
Fantastic Four: First Steps
How To Train Your Dragon
Tron: Ares
Thunderbolts

BEST SCORE
John Powell and Stephen Schwartz - Wicked: For Good





There was a lot of good music this year, but you cannot beat the score for one of the great Broadway musicals of all time.

RUNNERS-UP
Superman
David
Fantastic Four: First Steps
How to Train Your Dragon






BEST COSTUMES
Wicked: For Good


 






As I wrote last year when the Wicked won this award: These were some of the most inventive and creative costumes of the year.  Everything in Oz feels like it has a touchstone in the real world, but it hyper-stylized from the overly-feminine wardrobe of Galinda or the unique frames of Elphaba's eyeglasses.  The entire costume plot transports you to a whole new world.

RUNNERS-UP
Superman
Fantastic Four: First Steps
Tron: Ares
Song Sung Blue

BEST SONG
"Follow the Light" - David







I was surprised by the fact that this award did not go to something from Wicked: For Good, but "Follow the Light" is not only a banger of a song, but the movie uses it to maximum effect both in its introduction and its reprise that it is staying with me and inspiring me.



Below are the list of all the films of 2025 that I have seen, ranked in order of excellence (movies highlighted in blue originated on streaming:

Superman
Fantastic Four: First Steps
David
Wicked: For Good
Song Sung Blue
Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning
How to Train Your Dragon
F1
Novocaine
The Naked Gun
John Candy: I Like Me
KPop Demon Hunters
Rental Family
Fackham Hall
Nonnas
Thunderbolts
Tron: Ares
The Smashing Machine
Nobody 2
From the World of John Wick: Ballerina
Predator: Badlands
Anaconda
Captain America: Brave New World
The Accountant 2
Karate Kid: Legends
Regretting You
Playdate
Guns Up
Avatar: Fire and Ash
The Gorge
Thursday Murder Club
Jurassic World: Rebirth
Weapons
Sinners
Merv
Love Hurts
Happy Gilmore 2
Spinal Tap II: The End Continues
Springsteen: Deliver Me From Nowhere
The Running Man
Roofman
The Life of Chuck
Wake Up, Dead Man
Eternity
Marty Supreme
Snow White
A Minecraft Movie

So that is my list and the conclusion of this year's Catholic Skywalker Awards.  

Thoughts?































No comments:

Post a Comment