ReasonForOurHope

Thursday, June 8, 2023

Film Review: Spider-Man - Across the Spider-Verse

 


Sexuality/Nudity Acceptable

Violence Acceptable
Vulgarity Acceptable

Anti-Catholic Philosophy Acceptable

Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse was a movie that hit my by surprise.  In the comics, Miles Morales is incredibly lame and his stories are horribly unexciting.  So when they made a movie about him, I was less than enthusiastic.  However, I was blown away by the bold, exciting, and powerful film that they made and because of that I was very excited to see the sequel.

Based on my conversations with others who have seen it and the reaction online, I think my take will be contrary to the majority opinion:

Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse is not that good.

Don't get me wrong, it is not a bad movie.  In fact, it has some truly amazing parts.  

But sequels to successful films usually end up in one of three places:

a. playing it safe and being too repetitive (e.g. Iron Man 2)

b. getting full of itself and going overboard with creative freedom and budget (The Matrix sequels)

c. taking everything good in the first, but bringing to a whole new level (The Empire Strikes Back).

Across the Spider-Verse wants to be like Empire, but it ends up more like The Matrix sequels.

The story begins about a year after Into the Spider-Verse.  We begin with a LONG prologue with Spider-Gwen (Hailee Steinfeld), stuck in her universe and at odds with her police captain father (Shea Whigham).  During a fight, she encounters other Spider Heroes like Miguel O'Hara (Oscar Isaac) and Jessica Drew (Issa Rae), who invite her to a multiversal Spider-Team.  Meanwhile, Miles (Shameik Moore) is still stuck in his universe, where is father Jefferson (Brian Tyree Henry) and his mother Rio (Luna Lauren Velez) are trying plan for his future while he spends most of his time secretly fighting crime.  This tension provides much of the character drama.  Miles tangles with a seemingly incompetent villain named "The Spot" (Jason Schwartzman), whose power and danger grow throughout the film.  Eventually Miles finds his way into a multiverse-hopping adventure that will test his courage and his moral code.

The best part of this movie is once again how they handle Miles.  He is not Peter Parker and that is fine.  Miles' experience resonates on a universal level with the coming-of-age stories and sense of alienation from family that occurs in adolescents.  He has wit and charm, but he is complicated.  And I love the fact that he is written like a teenager.  Granted he is an heroic teenager, but there are some maturities that only come with age that Miles lacks.  Instead of this making the character more annoying, it instead makes us all relate to that time in our lives when we were in his shoes.

But the movie has a stylistic problem and a structure problem.

Into the Spider-Verse had such a bold and original visual dynamic that it felt like it was going to pop off of the screen, even without 3D.  The problem with this movie is that they crank that up to 11.  There are times when the movie needs a moment to breath and let the tone settle.  But it feels like directors Joaquim Dos Santos, Kemp Powers, and Justin K. Thompson had a philosophy that they should never uses a simple shot when a complex one can be used.  Backgrounds are constantly shifting and change, the camera often never settles down.  As a result, the moments that should visually blow your mind get lost in a cacophony of over-stimulation.  As I mentioned in my review of Fast X, the action scenes go on WAY too long and slowly sour into tedium.  Overall, it feels less like a dedication to beauty than it feels like the film makers showing off.

But the bigger problem is structural.  It is very difficult to explain without spoilers so be warned:

SPOILERS FOR THE MOVIE'S PLOT WILL BE DISCUSSED BELOW

The central conflict of the movie is a fascinating one.  

According to Miguel, there are "canon events" in the lives of every Spider-Hero across the multiverse.  For example, all of them have a relative who dies and teaches them a lesson of heroism.  But these canon events also involve the death of a police captain, usually Gwen Stacy's father.  But in Miles' universe, his father is about to become captain and is thus destined to die.  If he does not, then there is a risk that the entire universe will collapse.  Miguel says that he took the place of a dead Miguel O'Hara in another universe.  But because he changed things too much, that universe was destroyed.

The Spider-Heroes accept this.  That is, except for Miles.  

Miles refuses to stand by and let his father die, even if it means risking the universe.  This leads to some high-stakes drama and action.

So where is the structural problem?

Its in that the story makes you side with Miles too much.  He clearly has made the "right" choice, even though it is not that easy.  Part of the problem is how they portray Miguel.  He is clearly the bad guy.  He hulks over the other Spider-Heroes and carries with him an aspect of malevolence.  You cannot really appreciate his position.

I don't like Monday-Morning-Quarterbacking someone else's story, but the movie makes a big mistake in focusing so much on Gwen in the first 20 minutes on Gwen.  First of all, it is a mistake to think that she is as big of a draw as Miles is.  She is a fantastic supporting character, but she is not the lead.  If they were going to do a prologue, they should have done it with Miguel in the story he described about losing that universe.  If the film makers got you to carry about Miguel's new family and then make you feel their loss right at the beginning, then you would understand Miguel completely.  It would also force you to confront your feelings about Miles.

The movie also has a big problem in that it doesn't have an ending.  Back to the Future 2 and Matrix Reloaded also end abruptly with little resolution.  But there was clear preparation for the fact that these movies were made with another sequel prepared.  Across the Spider-Verse does not prepare you for this.  Thus it ends too abruptly, without enough resolution to make for an emotionally satisfying payoff.  Perhaps it will work out in the third movie, but because I did not know that going in to this film, it feels like the rug is pulled out from under you.

And I'm not sure why we have to wait until the third movie.  At 2 hours and 20 minutes, this movie feels horribly padded.  It feels like they could have easily lost an hour.  Yet even with this extra time, some things still feel too abrupt.  For example, Miles shares a few seconds of conversation with Spider-Byte (Amandla Stenberg) and a few scenes later we are to believe that she would suddenly turn against everyone else to help him.  But as I mentioned above, the film makers are clearly reveling in their newfound freedom.  And some of their choices are odd.  For example, Jessica Jones is fighting as a pregnant superhero.  This is incredibly unsettling, especially in scenes when Miguel must tangle with her.  Who thought this was a good idea?  And Spot is a horrible let-down of a villain from the mountainous Kingpin from the previous film.

Thematically, I love the themes of family, belonging, love, and sacrifice.  These work best especially when they are put in conflict with each other.  Online there have been people insisting that Gwen is trans.  There really isn't any evidence of this in the film.  She has a "Protect Trans Kids" flag in her room.  But the film makers also took it upon themselves to fill the movie with tons of not-so-subtle political messaging.  It doesn't make the movie bad, but it keeps breaking the spell that it is trying to cast on you.  Once you introduce real-world politics 

Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse is not a bad movie, despite these flaws.  Instead, it simply fails to live up to the hope and promise of the first film.  It loses itself in its own style and structure.  I am hopeful that it can find itself again in the next movie.




Tuesday, June 6, 2023

Film Review: Fast X

 


Sexuality/Nudity Mature

Violence Acceptable
Vulgarity Mature

Anti-Catholic Philosophy Acceptable


Not counting Hobbs and Shaw, this is the first Fast and Furious movie that I have seen in the theater.  I caught the original on DVD twenty years ago, but I had not kept up with the franchise really.  Then a few years ago my wife and I did a marathon of the films.  The overall impression is that these movies are just fun.

And now we are here at the tenth part of the Fast Saga: Fast X.

The story takes place a few years after F9: The Fast Saga.  Dom (Vin Diesel) is trying to live the quiet life with his wife Letty (Michelle Rodriguez) and son Little Brian (Leo Abelo Perry).  But then Cipher (Charlize Theron), the criminal mastermind who murdered Little Brian's mother, shows up injured asking for Dom's help.  It turns out that Dante (Jason Momoa), the son of the main bad guy from Fast 5 is back for revenge again Dom and his crew.  This takes them to confrontation in Rome with Roman (Tyrse Gibson), Tej (Ludacris), Ramsey (Nathalie Emmanuel), and Han (Sung Kang).  As a result, our heroes are hunted by Dante and also the shadowy government organization that they work for, now led by Aimes (Alan Ritchson).  But the daughter of Mr. Nobody, Tess (Brie Larson) tries to secretly help the group, which also includes Shaw (Jason Statham), Mia (Jordana Brewster), Jakob (John Cena), and the newly introduced Isabel (Daniela Melchior).

If that sounds like an unwieldy cast of characters with a labyrinth plot worthy of a telenovela, then you would be correct.

One of the biggest strengths of the series is that has built up a large cast of interesting characters.  The problem now is that there are too many.  Even at two and a half hours, it doesn't feel like anyone gets enough screen time.  The plot also is fractured to the point where a lot of the storylines seems to spin their wheels (no pun intended).  The script desperately tries to give everyone something do to, but then it has the audacity to add new characters we are supposed to care about on top of that.  To paraphrase Jim Gaffigan, it's like you're drowning and then someone hands you a baby.  It's just too much.  The movie even adds cameos by Hellen Mirren, Rita Morena, and other surprises guests.

The other big detriment is that the movie has a weak second act.  This is largely due to the problems mentioned above.  The first act and the third act are the strongest with the best action sequences.  As I mentioned in my review for John Wick Chapter 4, action directors are really padding their sequences.  But at some point in time, you begin to get a diminishing return on your thrills.  There were a lot of points in the second act when I kept waiting for the action scene to end so that the story could move forward.  But those scenes seemed very indulgent.

That is a shame, because the action in the first act was almost Mission: Impossible level.  The third act action devolves into pure over-the-top silliness, but it strangely had me invested enough to be locked in.  Director Louis Leterrier understands this world and what he is supposed to do.  It feels like if he was able to tighten things up a bit, the movie would flow better.

If you've seen the previous Fast and Furious then there will be no surprise in the returning performances.  We see a bit more fear in Diesel's eyes, but beyond that, everyone still maintains the same character space.  Momoa's performance is... odd.  In the first act, he comes off with a crazy charisma and an almost demonic sense of craftiness and menace.  But then in the second act, its as if the director wanted him to play against type.  His Dante begins to act strangely feminine in a way that was more confusing than it was dangerous.  Larson does an decent job, but she seems out of place with these action heavyweights.  Ritchson cuts a fine imposing figure and he gets the job done, but he doesn't leave a big impression.  Melchior has potential, but she isn't given enough to shine.

Despite all of this, I found myself generally enjoying most of the show.  Partially this is because Fast X is better than the previous two films.  The level of silliness in those two is tamped down just slightly for this one.  Of course we do have a giant, flaming neutron bomb that defies the laws for friction and inertia.  But after you spend so much time with these characters, there is comfort in that familiarity.  And this is becoming a rarer trait as long-lived characters in other stories become twisted by new writers who desperately want to make them "relevant."

People make fun of the constant reference to "family," in these movies, but that what gives the movies their strength and staying power.  We care about them and they care about each other.  And because we care about them, we don't care that it's impossible for a 1970 Dodge Charger to take out two helicopters.

Sometimes a movie doesn't try to be more than it is and it embraces all that it is with enthusiasm and affection.  And that is what you get with Fast X.




Monday, June 5, 2023

Film Flash: Spider-Man - Across the Spider-verse

 


15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon) 



Some good character work and thrills, but too long and indulgent, without a real ending



Sunday, June 4, 2023

Sunday Best: Top 20 Movie Trilogies Part 1 (#20-#11)

 The Trilogy.

This seems to be the benchmark of movie franchises.  Yes, a successful series can go way beyond three films (I'm looking at you Fast and Furious), but it seems to me that the goal and the hope of a sequalized story is to get to at least a trilogy.

And throughout movie history, there have been dozens of trilogies.  But I thought it would be fun to look at the top 20.  Originally I was only going to do the top 10, but I found that I was leaving way too many stories off of my list.  

How do I decide what is a good trilogy?

First of all, there has to be a level of quality maintained throughout the trilogy.  Even if the first movie is excellent, if the two sequels that follow are terrible then it does not qualify as a great trilogy (eg. The Hangover, The Pirates of the Caribbean).  To be sure, most of the time there is going to be a drop in quality by the third film.

Also, the movies had to be sequentially three parts without skipping.  This gets tricky when doing interconnected universes like the MCU, but if the main series has a trilogy it qualifies.  For example, the above mentioned Fast and Furious franchise could qualify if you held that parts 5, 6, and 7 are a trilogy.  However, looking at the Avengers films, you have a weaker entry in part 2 of the four.  As a result, you could not form a trilogy from this series without including that weaker entry.

With this in mind, here are the top movie trilogies #20-#11

#20 The Chronicles of Narnia

The Narnia Movies - NarniaWeb | Netflix's Narnia Movies

The Lion the Witch, and the Wardrobe, Prince Caspian, The Voyage of the Dawn Treader

I think the first film in this series is truly magical and stands up to any of the great children's book adaptations that have ever been done.  The second one was also of outstanding quality, but unfortunately was squeezed out by the premieres of both Iron Man and Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull.  The final one did not live up to the first two, but there was enough magic left in the story to leave a strong impression with me.  I own all three of these movies and recommend them to any family to watch.


#19 Ghostbusters

Ghostbusters trilogy posters by jayzx100-Frozen on DeviantArt

Ghostbusters, Ghostbusters 2, Ghostbusters: Afterlife

This one barely makes it on the list as a trilogy because of soft reboot of Afterlife.  The first one stands alone as a cinematic and comedic masterpiece.  I am one of the few people that will defend the sequel as a worthy follow-up with some great moments.  Afterlife lacks the true comedic power of the first, but there is enough nostalgia, catharsis, and good will to help this franchise earn its place on this list.


#18 John Wick

LetsCinema on Twitter: "best ever action trilogy? #JohnWick4  https://t.co/oM4gNVago9" / Twitter

John Wick, John Wick: Chapter 2, John Wick: Chapter 3 - Parabellum

The first entry felt like it should have been a simple stand-alone feature.  But once this movie exploded on home video (has any other movie recently done this?) the sequels were enevitable.  Like many others on this list, the movies that came after never reach the heights of the first.  But each movie delivers exactly what it advertises: high-octane, fun ultra-violence.


#17 Captain America

BLURAYANGEL 🦇 on Twitter: "Captain America has the best MCU trilogy  https://t.co/Xa2HarKCZ0" / Twitter

Captain America, Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Captain America: Civil War

One of the things I love about this trilogy is how it was allowed to evolve in its style.  The first one felt like a throwback to a more innocent style of storytelling, like The Rocketeer.  But there is such a strong stylistic change in the second film that does not dishonor the first, but the difference enhances the story.  You feel how Steven is in a world that is so alien and so familiar.  But because we saw him come from that world, we understand how he can stand like a rock of virtue in a world that seems only to be filled with shifting morality.  And this strength of character is really put to the test in the final film that questions if Steve needs to remain true or if he needs to evolve.  All the while, the films give great action.


#16 Spider-Man Home Trilogy

The MCU Spider-Man Trilogy posters. They're all awful! : r/marvelstudios

Spider-Man: Homecoming, Spider-Man: Far From Home, Spider-Man: No Way Home

This series did something that I love to see happen in a trilogy: the movies get better.  Homecoming is a fun introduction to Peter's world with a great nemesis in Michael Keaton's Vulture.  Far From Home was like an exciting road trip.  Both of these movies felt like superhero films infused with some John Hughes DNA.  But the third one truly knocked it out of the park.  Two years ago, No Way Home won my Best Picture award.  Besides the multiverse-sized scope of the film along with all the cathartic moments, the movie did something remarkable in the way it took Tom Holland and showed us how he grew from a boy into a man.


#15  Guardians of the Galaxy

MCU - The Direct on Twitter: "The official teaser posters of the  #GuardiansOfTheGalaxy trilogy Here's what to know about Vol. 3's villain:  https://t.co/ZVaXpUr607 https://t.co/sMWjJ9OpNo" / Twitter

Guardians of the Galaxy, Vol. 2, Vol. 3

Like John Wick, the first one is lightning in a bottle.  And while the second volume does not have quite the same magic, the third film ended in a way that brings such satisfaction and closure to the character arcs and relationships that it places the entire series in a good light.


#14 The Naked Gun

the naked gun trilogy – Reel News Daily

The Naked Gun, The Naked Gun 2 and 1/2: The Smell of Fear, The Naked Gun 33 and 1/3: The Final Insult.

Yes, there are some truly childish and vulgar parts to this series.  And yes, it is clear by the third one that the series was running out of comedic energy and ideas.  But the sheer volume of amazing jokes that STILL make me laugh as if their were brand-new is something that makes this comedy trilogy truly phenomenal.  

"That's a pretty tall order, Nordberg.  You're going to have to give me a couple of days on that one."

"I've just been swimming in raw sewage.  I LOVE IT!"


#13 Harry Potter

Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince poster.jpgA girl and two boys run through a dark forest, pursued by something.A girl and two boys, standing outside a building with tall turrets

Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Parts 1 and 2

This is the clearest example of a trilogy in the Harry Potter franchise.  Half-Blood Prince sets up the main quest and draws the battle-lines.  Deathly Hallows Part 1 thrusts our heroes into their quest without the support of anyone else around them and it brings them to the breaking point.  Part 2 takes all of the story threads and pulls them together in a deeply emotional and satisfying conclusion.


#12 The Dark Knight Trilogy

The Dark Knight Trilogy Movie Poster Collection | Set of 3 | Batman | DC |  NEW | eBay

Batman Begins, The Dark Knight, The Dark Knight Rises

The first movie in this trilogy is often overshadowed by the sequel.  But Batman Begins is an excellent superhero origin story that gives us a new perspective into how Bruce became Batman.  Of course, The Dark Knight is a modern classic which looks so different from the first that you couldn't be blamed for thinking that they had a different director.  There are so many reasons that I will not get into here about what makes this movie so good.  Suffice to say that there is a reason why The Dark Knight is on the top of many people's lists for Best Superhero Film.  The final film has a few logic and continuity issues, but there are enough good things in it to keep this trilogy from sinking.  Anne Hathaway, Joseph Gordon-Leavitt, and Tom Hardy turn in fantastic performances.  And to this day, I get chills when Selina says to Bruce that he has already given the people of Gotham everything and he simply responds, "No, not everything.  Not yet."


#11 Back to the Future

Back to the Future': A Perfect Trilogy for Writerly Study - Script Magazine

Back to the Future 1, 2, and 3

The first movie was one of the highest-grossing films of its decade.  On paper, the story could have been just another generic sci-fi comedy.  And those were a dime-a-dozen in the 1980's.  But the fantastic performances by Michael J. Fox and Christopher Lloyd along with the inspired direction by Robert Zemeckis, created a cinematic classic.  The movie blends things together that shouldn't work (and quite frankly should be repulsive) and creates something fun and exciting.  Part II is a creative expansion of the original, but also feels a little disjoined, like three different movies rolled into one.  Part III is the weakest of the series.  By this point, the callbacks almost felt like parodies of the original.  But there was a enough good will to see the story through.  And I will admit that the train sequence is still incredibly exciting to watch.  


Stay tuned next week for the Top 10.

Thoughts?

Wednesday, May 31, 2023

Catholic Skywalker 11-Year Anniversary

  


(5/31/23: Feast of the Visitation)
Usually I anticipate this day, but this year it snuck up on me.  

Over the course of 11 years I've made over 2,500 posts to this blog.  I'm sure there are many who would call this an immense waste of time.  But I have found a great sense of satisfaction from my writings here.  

I hope I have been insightful, witty, and interesting.  If I have failed in this department, I do apologize.  I do write with you, Dear Reader, in mind.  You take the time to read this blog when you could be doing anything else, so I want to honor that sacrifice of time that you make by giving you something worthwhile to read.  


Much has happened in the last 11 years.  Since beginning this blog:
-my mother and both of my remaining grandparents passed away (God rest their souls)
-my father-in-law  and mother-in-law passed away (God rest their souls)
-my wife and I weathered some rough employment situations
-I broke my back and have surgery 4 times.
-I became a godfather
-I was asked to write for NewEvangelizers.Com
-I've produced 8 more movies
-I've written, directed, and produced two plays and one musical.
-I'm just got a second Master's Degree

And there may be new possibilities on the horizon.

All of this occurring during the tumultuous times we've lived through like COVID.

Through it all, I tried to write here regularly.  And now after ten years, I've produced:

-337 Film Reviews
-121 Essays
-252 New Evangelizers Articles
-11Years of the Best and Worst of Movies, TV, and Comics.


Together we raised money for charity.  We've prayed together.  And hopefully we also laughed together.

Thank you again, Dear Reader, for taking this journey with me.  I pray that we will continue to walk this path of faith, film, and philosophy for many years to come.

God Bless You All!
Catholic Skywalker - 2023

Tuesday, May 30, 2023

New Evangelizers Post: Why Not Become Fire?

                                              


 


I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  


I had my major conversion experience the summer after high school. As a result, I was a particularly zealous Catholic (though perhaps not the wisest) during my time at college. During those years, I made it a point to attend daily mass at noon. And of those hundreds of masses I attended, I am sad to say that I don’t remember most of the homilies given.

But one has always stuck with me.

The priest sat in a chair in the small chapel area and spoke in a soft, deliberate tone. He then told the story of Abba Joseph of Panephysis, an early Church Father and desert monk. One day, another monk named Abba Lot came to see him because Lot was struggling. The story goes thus:

Abba Lot went to see Abba Joseph and said: “Abba, as much as I am able I practice a small rule, a little fasting, some prayer and meditation, and remain quiet, and as much as possible I keep my thoughts clean. What else should I do?” Then the old man stood up and stretched out his hands toward heaven, and his fingers became like ten torches of flame. And he said: “Why not be turned into fire?”

The priest at mass told this story without fanfare or drama, yet I have never forgotten it. Something about it struck a chord with me. Here I was, running around as a young Catholic doing all of the things that I thought were necessary for a good Catholic to do: daily mass, daily rosary, adoration, confession, prayer groups, retreats, etc. And to be sure there those are all good things. But the question still hits me:

Why not become fire?

As I have gotten older, I have understood this question to be at the heart of the Christian life. Habit and routine, even of the spiritual and religious kind, make life easier. But they also have disadvantages. The first is that we can go on “auto-pilot” and lose that intentionality and intensity of the spontaneous. When you are in a conversation with someone and they give the prefunctory responses to your problems without really listening, we know that their hearts are not in it. It can be the same with us in our spiritual habits where we “rattle on the pagans do.” (Matt 6:7).

But the other problem is that we think that the activity is the end in itself. If we asked the average Catholic about what makes them a good Catholic, how many would say things like “I go to Church on Sunday, I went to Catholic school, I give to charity, etc.?” And all of those are good things. I think of my instinct to answer that question by laying out a laundrey list of the prayers I pray or the activities to which I give my time.

But these activiites are the means and not the end of the Christian life. What is important is what is at the heart. As CS Lewis wrote, “A perfect man would never act from a sense of duty; he’d always want the right thing more than the wrong one. Duty is only a substitute for love (of God and of other people) like a crutch which is a substitute for a leg. Most of us need the crutch at times; but of course it is idiotic to use the crutch when our own legs (our own loves, tastes, habits etc.) can do the journey on their own.” (Letters of CS Lewis, 18 July 1957)

The crutch is good, but the goal is the healthy leg. The activities are good, but they are there to help transform us into who we are supposed to be.

And we should be fire.

You can read the whole article here.




Monday, May 29, 2023

Memorial Day 2023

   




























(repost from 2019)

Today is the day that we honor those who fought and died for our country.  I doubt that I can add any deep, universal insight into the meaning of this day that has not already been given by those more eloquent.

I do have some friends who are cautious about the elevated status we give those in the armed forces.  They worry about the glorification of war or that it trains citizens to put too much trust in their government agents.  There are some arguments to be had there.  To be sure, while war may make soldiers into martyrs, it does not always turn soldiers into saints.

But in this moment I will not speak for them.  I will speak for myself and why this day is especially reverent for me.

Some answered the call to fight for our nation.
I did not.

Some left spouses and children to enter into violent conflict for their country.
I did not.

Some lost their innocence, their friends, or their health in the crucible of war.
I did not.

Some gave every last measure of devotion down to their lives for our country's freedom.
I did not.

I write this not as some kind of admission of guilt.  Being a soldier is not my calling.

But some did answer the call.  Some paid a price higher than I have had to pay.  I am in this present moment enjoying the fruits of their sacrifice.

Winning and preserving freedom is a bloody business.  I do not want to be in a blissful bubble where I treat my freedom too casually, not remembering that it was purchased at a price of blood.

Today as we rest from our labors, let us remember the fallen martyrs of our freedom.

Let us pray for them and for our country.