ReasonForOurHope

Tuesday, June 9, 2020

Wednesday Comics: The Rise and Fall of Tom King


Let me say this at the outset: Tom King is a better writer than I will ever be.

I write this article with the understanding that he is someone of superior skill.  My critique here is not based on his ability, but his choices.  And from this point of view, I write from a place of sadness as I see the deterioration of someone with the potential to be one of the truly great comic book writers.

The first thing I remember reading from King was his run on Grayson in the days following Forever Evil.  I remember the stories vaguely, but nothing really stood out.  But then King took over Batman in the DC Rebirth era.  His first issue stood out to me as Batman was trying to safely guide a crashing plan into the river, knowing he was going to die.  In his last moments, he was communicating with Alfred his final goodbyes.  It was an issue that was action-packed, while at the same time being intensely emotional.  While I enjoyed this issue, King had yet to jump out at me as an writer of note.

But then he wrote Batman/ Elmer Fudd.  I almost passed up this issue, but my comic book guy recommended it.  It is difficult to stress how much I was blown away by this book.  As I wrote in an earlier post:

Nothing about this book should work.

This should be a ridiculous one-off that would soon be thrown onto the rubbish bin of memory.

And yet this is the best one-shot I have read all year.

The book almost dares you hate it.  As soon as you open the book, the title of the story uses Fudd's speech impediment and is titles, "Pway for Me."  And the first page is an interior, dramatic, noir monologue completely done in Fudd's voice.  And in one page you go from scoffing at the stupdity of the premise to in awe that the monologue has sucked you in to the story.

And it is a dark story of murder and revenge while at the same time being filled with joyous cameos.  Writer Tom King deserves the most amazing credit for embracing the ridiculousness of the pairing and turning that weakness into the book's biggest strength.  The degree of difficulty alone in what this book has accomplished is one of the reasons why King has cemented himself already in his short career as one of the greats.

This made me sit up and pay attention more to his work on Batman.  He was developing a rich inner life to the character while complimenting it with exciting action.  His re-introduction of Bane was fantastic, as he brought gravity and dread upon the entire story by his mere presence.  I know that some people complained about his focus on the interpersonal relationships, but those early stories were so enjoyable for me.  The "Double Date" issues were insightful and funny.  The Annual #2, which summarized the love story between Batman and Catwoman was touching, tender, and tragic.

At the same time, he launched his boldest experiment yet: Mr. Miracle.  You could see that King was taking a page from greats like Alan Moore, Frank Miller, Neil Gaiman, and James Robinson by taking a little-used character and taking them in a bold direction with the freedom that comes with writing a non-A-List hero.  And those first few issues broke through the noise.  Comic shops sold out of them and caused some genuine buzz.  King's book was so funky, like being trapped in a dream where you get this sense of some overarching unseen logic holding the chaos of the story together.  This experimental style seemed to fuse well with the type of story King was telling.  By the half-way point in the series I wrote:

I think this book cast a spell on me.  

The reason why I say this is because we are about half way through the series and I still have no idea what is going on.  Normally, I would have given up on a book like this the way I have on tons of Alan Moore and Grant Morrison works.  

But there is something compelling about this book for reasons I cannot explain.  The book feels like being trapped in a nightmare.  To use a quote from the movie Titanic, "there's truth but no logic."  

Even when the plot is confusing, I cannot help but be emotionally connected to the events of the story.  

For those who don't know, Mr. Miracle is the son of High Father of New Genesis.  When he was a baby, he was exchanged with Orion, son of Darkseid, as part of a peace treaty.  As a result, Mr. Miracle, aka Scott Free, grew up in hell until he was able to escape to Earth to become the world's greatest escape artist.  

The series begins with Scott's failed suicide attempt and goes immediately into a war with Darkseid.

Nothing is as it seems and as compelling as the book is, you cannot help but feel like you want to escape the madness too.  Maybe that's the point.

I will have a better assessment of the book when all is said and done, but I cannot think of another book like on the stands now.

It was at this point in 2017 that I told my comic book guy to pull any comics written by Tom King.  I gave him my Catholic Skywalker Award for best comic writer and his stories also won several of my awards.

But then came "The War of Jokes and Riddles."

King had set up a book with a fantastic concept: the overly analytic Riddler went to war with the chaos-minded Joker with villains on either side tearing up Gotham with Batman in the middle.  The idea was so exciting and the first issue set up one heck of a tale.  But right away things began to go wrong.

First of all, King made the story a flashback, so there were no real stakes going forward for any of the main characters.  Second, he focused on side characters like Kite-Man that felt more like distractions than anything.  But the main problem was that at last King was beginning to show his fatal flaw.

To explain, you have to understand that standard super-hero fare reads like an action movie.  That is not to say that it does not have strong dramatic elements to or that it lacks depth.  But like an action movie, the story builds to a conflict, usually some kind of fight.  Now, imagine watching a movie like Avengers: Infinity War and just as Thanos showed up on Titan to fight Iron Man and the other heroes there, Tony Stark began a voice over saying, "And so we fought and lost and he took the time stone," while we saw a quick 1-minute montage of the fight.

That is what started happening in King's writing.  A gigantic confrontation was about to take place and instead of letting it play out, Batman would narrate a vague description with a collage of the action.  It was so odd and it really took the wind out of the sails of the story.  It was almost like King got bored of his own story and wanted to fast forward to the parts he liked.  And that is when I discovered his main problem as a writer:

Tom King does not write for plot.

For King, he is much more interested in theme and character when it comes to his stories.  He wants to convey a certain big idea or a strong emotion.  I am someone who thinks that stories, especially comic book stories, should be thematically rich.  But they need a strong plot.  Plot is like the skeleton that holds up the body and the theme is heart.  A plot without a theme is like a well-formed dead body.  But a theme without a plot is a formless blob.  In a similar way, character needs plot.  Having characters sitting around talking about their feelings rarely works (though there are notable exceptions).  To paraphrase Aristotle, plot is character.  But character without plot is not a story.  

I think King became the victim of his own success.  Many like me praised is power as a writer.  But he appears to have bought into his own hype.  Instead of forming tight narratives and letting the characters and  theme develop through that, his style began to tilt to a much more experimental style that eschewed traditional story-telling methods.  The problem is that King was unable to sustain a good story in this new method.

I am going to give examples of this in his work to illustrate.  

SPOILERS BELOW FOR BATMAN, HEROES IN CRISIS, and MR. MIRACLE.

Mr. Miracle's second half fell victim to King's descent.  The plot became more and more difficult to follow, with issues following each other with little to no connection to the previous events.  The worst came about with his treatment of Darkseid.  Throughout the book, King established the overarching evil, almost a disembodied malevolent omnipotence.  And then, in a move of Rian Johnson level of expectations-subversion, King makes a joke out of Darkseid.  Not only does the joke fall flat, but it makes a mockery of the entire story up until this point.  The series ends with an empty ambiguity that leaves the reader completely unsatisfied intellectually or emotionally.

Batman began to fall deeper and deeper into this plotless hole.  After the shaggy dog story of Batman and Catwoman's wedding, the series became an indulgent exercise in the main character navel gazing.  There was a glimmer of hope after Dick Grayson was shot in the head and Thomas Wayne returned to the picture.  But for months, King indulged his weird side with dream-sequence stories that brought the series to a grinding halt.  But even after the story picked up again nothing made sense.

Bane took over Gotham and put the villains in charge of the police force.  It was something that felt like a lame retread of "No Man's Land."  With a little bit of work, King could have come up with something to sell the reader on these strange circumstances.  But he didn't seem to care.  This was King's Gotham and we were just visiting.  But the place where he went from diminishing star to fallen star was what happened with Alfred.

Batman abandoned Gotham.  The heroes were warned not to return.  Robin (Damian Wayne) sneaks in but is caught.  Then, with a page focusing on Robin tied up and the action occuring off camera, we are treated to a giant image of Band snapping Alfred's neck.  This character is much more than Batman's butler.  He is the surrogate father to Bruce and in a sense is a fatherly figure to the entire Bat-family.  His death allowed for no emotional build-up and was disgustingly presented for shock value.  And then what happened in the series?

Batman lounged on a beach with Catwoman for two issues.

Here is one of the clearest examples of King's inattention to plot killing his storytelling abilities.  How in the world can I give a crap about the whiny love-life of Batman when his surrogate father was just murdered?  King belongs to that breed of modern comic book writers who do not understand the emotional connection that long-time readers have with the characters.  They are not simply Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Nightwing, Batgirl, Stargirl, etc.  They are Clark, Bruce, Diana, Dick, Babs, and Courtney.  We actually care about them.  They are not mere pawns.  They do not belong to the writer.  The writer is the caretaker of these characters and must treat them as such.  Again, think about this: one single panel was used to deal with Alfred's death followed by several issues going over Bat/Cat relationship angst.  The entire time I was reading those issues, I felt a sense of anger and betrayl.  Alfred was cast aside like old tissue so he could indulge wallow in relationship melodrama.

It was at this point I emotionally dropped out of the story.  I think a lot of people did as well as King planned 100 issue story was cut short to 75 by DC.  He had pulled in a lot of readers like me early, but began to hemorrhage them as he became more full of himself.  

The finale of his run did not improve things.  The final issue was classic Tom King in that the plot did not matter.  The final issue is set up as the clash between Thomas and Bruce.  But within a page, the fight is peppered with flash-forwards which tell us that the fight doesn't matter.  Its result is a foregone conclusion.  King didn't care about the fight.  Again, he wanted to skip ahead to the stuff he liked.

But his worst offense was Heroes in Crisis.

I give him a little bit of leeway because some of the story's worst plot points were mandated by Dan DiDio.  But even the execution was excruciating.  As I wrote in an earlier post, Heroes in Crisis #8 is the worst comic book I have ever read.  I won't repeat the whole thing, but it involved King using a nonsensical plot point in order to ruin one of the greatest DC characters of all time.  As I wrote:  

The story ruins a character loved by fans.
The story is based on motivations that make no sense.
The story requires an emotional crisis that the confessions cannot provide.
The story invents potentially fatal problem for all speedsters going forward.
The story uses time travel in the least effective way imaginable.
The story fails at all of its goals: logical and emotional.
The story makes me less likely to buy the next issue.
The story makes me less likely to buy more DC comics.
The story makes me less likely to buy anything by Tom King.


And in another post I wrote about the entire Heroes in Crisis fiasco:

The issue has writer Tom King trying to bring his story to an emotional conclusion.

The only thing that is conclusively proven is that Tom King does not understand super hero comics. 

It is abundantly clear that when he sees these iconic characters, he sees them as a heap of psychological problems.  He does not see the whole person, just their issues.  He thinks because he can find some mild or severe psychological problem in a character then he has discovered the core defining characteristic of their personality.  King does not understand that we are more than our traumas.  Batman's life has been shaped by his trauma, but he is more than his pain.  Heroes in Crisis took Wally West, stripped away all that was relevant to his personality and his heroism and defined him by his loss. 

What was really disgusting was Booster Gold telling Wally that he would work with him to help smooth over his crimes when he says, "Bros before Heroes."

That is the antithesis of heroism.  It says that dealing with emotional trauma trumps what is morally right.  This is an ethically insane thing to believe and it is particularly noxious because it foists it on someone who is supposed to be a hero.  Heroes are the ones who go above and beyond.  Heroes are the ones who take on the burdens that no one should ask of them, but no one else can.  That is the Wally West we all know.  Anyone who has read Geoff Johns' "Blitz" storyline would find the Wally West in Heroes in Crisis unrecognizable.  And the transformation is not earned, not by a long shot.  I have heard rumors that King was mandated to do this to Wally by DC Editorial.  It makes no difference.  He should have said no.

The entire affair is capped off by Harley Quinn kneeing Wally in the crotch for... reasons?  Seeing that scene felt like the entire mini-series summed up in one panel. 

On top of all of its problems with theme and plot, it is a horribly written comic.  King does not seem to understand that comics are a visual medium.  Page after page is flooded with dialogue that almost pushes out the images, not that it matters much since all of them are mostly just standing around an open field for 20 pages. 

I write all of this not to condemn Tom King.  I hope for his literary redemption.

As I said at the beginning, King is an immense talent and still has potential to be one of the greats.  You can see glimpses of this greatness in his Superman: Up in the Sky.  But he keeps indulging in his own perceived elevation above the traditional comic book form.  Ironically, it is when he works within the traditional plot-centric structure, his writing truly soars.

As in history, it is not uncommon for a king to rise and fall.

But there is still hope for this King to rise again.

TRAILER TIME: Bill and Ted Face the Music Teaser





I know that I'm supposed to say that this is just playing on my Gen X nostalgia and that this is a cyncial reboot for easy cash. 



And while the first film is very much of its time, I still remember that Bill and Ted's Bogus Journey is a terrible, terrible film.



But I when I saw this teaser, I couldn't help myself... I started giggling.



Bill and Ted are two good-natured dummies who bring people together with their (sort of) musical talent, but mostly by their open and good nature.  And while the years are evident on Alex Winter and Keanu Reeves, I still bought them as the lovable doofuses from San Dimas.  I also think its a testament to Reeves that looking at him I see none of his now iconic John Wick.



I also love that silly Death has joined them again. 



This movie could be more Bogus Journey than Excellent Adventure, but I'll be there opening night.



Thoughts?

Monday, June 8, 2020

New Evangelizers Post: Racism, Protesting, and the Catholic Church


I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  

Since the killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis, there has been a great deal of upheaval in this country. A great deal of outrage has been expressed about racial inequality and police brutality. In addition to this, there have been violent riots in many of America’s cities, causing even more strife in our country. Taking a sample from self-identified Catholics on social media, even within our Church, there seems to be a great divide on how one should react.

The purpose of this article is not to lay out a specific program of action. I will leave it to you, dear reader, to work that out within your conscience. However, in order to help guide the conscience, I will lay out what we as Catholics believe regarding racism and protesting. This should help to act as a framework, within which you may make your decisions on how best to respond to the current crisis.

Regarding racism, the US Catholic Bishops released a pastoral letter about racism in 1979. While that was many years ago, the principle still holds. Many things were said, but it was stated that racism is a fact and it is a sin.

That people are discriminated against because of their race is a sad fact in the world today. We should define racism as “acting upon a racial prejudice.” In order for an act (and this could include how someone speaks) to be racist, it must be motivated by a racial prejudice.

I have encountered people who say that everyone harbors some kind of racial prejudice and that therefore there exists an institutional racism. I have also encountered others who would claim that they have no racial prejudice in them. These people would claim that they treat everyone the same regardless of their race. You will have to do your own self-examination to determine where you fall on this spectrum.

I am not someone who automatically assumes that my interior motivations are pure and virtuous. Sometimes our own prejudices can be hidden from the surface of our thoughts. How often have we been confronted by our own attitude towards another person (regardless of race) that we were not aware of before? Self-reflection while examining your conscience is a healthy moral exercise.

At the same time, it is not necessary to assume racial prejudice in myself or others. To say that racism is a fact is not to say that everyone is racist. Nor is it to say that someone, because of their race, harbors racial prejudice in their heart. In any case, an honest examination of our hearts and souls under the light of the Holy Spirit is always a good thing.

That racism is a sin is clear from the Catechism of the Catholic Church. Quoting Gaudium et Spes, the Catechism states, “Every form of social or cultural discrimination in fundamental personal rights on the grounds of sex, race, color, social conditions, language, or religion must be curbed and eradicated as incompatible with God’s design.” (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1935)

We are all made in the image of God and have equal dignity in His eyes. To treat human beings less than this is an affront to God’s creation.

Christ Himself broke down racial barriers. Samaritans were separated from the Jews by many cultural prejudices. And yet, Jesus spoke freely with a Samaritan woman (John 4), He healed Samaritans (Luke 10, Luke 17), and even one of His most famous parables was about a Good Samaritan (Luke 10). St. Paul said that in God’s eyes, we have equal dignity, no matter our ethnicity (Galatians 3:28).

As Christians, we must stand up to racism in all of its forms, both in our lives and in society at large. That is because we must stand up to all sin in this world, as Christ called us to be His body.

Some have taken to the streets in the form of protesting. It should be noted we do have a duty to obey our civil authorities. “It is the duty of citizens to contribute along with the civil authorities to the good of society in a spirit of truth, justice, solidarity, and freedom. The love and service of one’s country follow from the duty of gratitude and belong to the order of charity. Submission to legitimate authorities and service of the common good require citizens to fulfill their roles in the life of the political community.” (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2239)

St. Peter also wrote “Submit yourselves for the Lord’s sake to every human authority: whether to the emperor, as the supreme authority, or to governors, who are sent by him to punish those who do wrong and to commend those who do right. For it is God’s will that by doing good you should silence the ignorant talk of foolish people. Live as free people, but do not use your freedom as a cover-up for evil; live as God’s slaves. Show proper respect to everyone, love the family of believers, fear God, honor the emperor. (1 Peter 2:13-17) This means that because we live under the civil laws of our society, we must obey them when they are just. If possible, it is better to live in peace with a harmonious society.

But the problem is that this may not always be possible. If the laws are unjust, we have an obligation to not follow them, as did the ancient martyrs who refused to worship the emperor. “The citizen is obliged in conscience not to follow the directives of civil authorities when they are contrary to the demands of the moral order, to the fundamental rights of persons or the teachings of the Gospel.” (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2242)

We have the right to peaceably assemble under the Constitution. If someone so chooses to take part in protests, so long as it does not support things which are contrary to the Catholic faith, they are free and have the right to do so. However, as we have seen, many of these protests have devolved into looting and violence.

The Catechism states “Armed resistance to oppression by political authority is not legitimate, unless all the following conditions are met: 1) there is certain, grave, and prolonged violation of fundamental rights; 2) all other means of redress have been exhausted; 3) such resistance will not provoke worse disorders; 4) there is well-founded hope of success; and 5) it is impossible reasonably to foresee any better solution.” (2243).


You can read the whole article here.

Thursday, June 4, 2020

Lack of Updates - June 2020

Hello, Dear Reader,

I apologize for the lack of updates this past week.  We had a family health emergency that took up a great deal of our time.  Praise God, we got through the emergency and everyone involved seems to be improving.

On top of that, it is the end of the school year and I am in the process of finalizing grades, which has been taking up a good deal of time.  

And in addition to this, I am taking a Master's Class on St. Thomas Aquinas.  And anyone who has read the Angelic Doctor knows that he is not light reading.

So I am very sorry to be delayed in getting content up.  I'm hoping that sometime next week, we can get back to our normal schedule.

God bless!

Wednesday, May 27, 2020

Film Flash: Uncut Gems



15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)

Classic case of great acting / good directing used to tell a story not worth telling.

undefined

Film Flash: Midway (2019)





15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)

Good movie that could almost be great with better acting and a more connected story.

Monday, May 25, 2020

New Evangelizers Post: Die, Rise, and Go - The Process of Evangelization


I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  

In the liturgical year we are now reliving the first novena: the original nine days of prayer between Ascension Thursday and Pentecost Sunday. In that time, the disciples gathered in prayer and preparation for the day that they would burst forth into the world and spread the Good News. We are also called to spread that message. But in order to do that, we have to live out the three parts of the evangelist’s life: 

Die, Rise, and Go.

One of the main issues with trying to pass on the faith is that people try to jump to the third part of the process without spending enough time in the first two. I see this sometimes when parents try to instill the Catholic faith with little success. They bring their children to church and send them to a Catholic school, but the faith does not seem to take root. Part of the problem seems to be in the fact that taking them to Church and sending them to a Catholic school is the extent of their parental evangelization. They were brought up Catholic, so they are bringing up their kids Catholic. While the dynamic may be more complex than this, it is something that I have seen play out.

Christianity is not simply a set of theological precepts to which you subscribe, like a political philosophy. It is a lived out relationship with Christ. We need to live it before we can give it.

The first step is to die.

Before we can follow Christ, we have to die to our old selves. That is what the entire lenten journey has been about: putting away our past selves. In the Gospels, Jesus calls the disciples to repent. This involves the realization that I am not living the way Jesus wants me to live and I have to change. For those struggling with addiction, the first step to recovery is admitting that you have a problem. If you don’t admit your problem, then you cannot die to your addiction.

Most of us, if we are honest, probably think that we are doing okay. We may not be saints, but we are “good enough.” But we are not called to be “good enough.” In fact, if we were to do an honest assessment of our lives under the light of Christ, we could probably see how we have put ourselves before God and others. It is only when we recognize this that we can say that this old way of living must be put to death. This may involve uncomfortable changes in my life. I may have to give up more of my free time. I may have to break off certain relationships that are leading me away from God. Or I may need to swallow my pride and put the needs of other people first. But first and foremost, I have to die to anything that is keeping me from being the saint God is calling me to be. As stated earlier, Lent was the time to help us let go of our former way of life.

But that is not the complete process. In Christianity, death is only the beginning. There are some people who never get beyond the cross. What I mean by that is their focus is purely on dying to self and increasing penance for sin. While this can be part of the answer for some, it is not the whole formula. We do not die simply because we are bad and must extinguish that part of us. We die so that we can rise to new life.

So I ask myself: have I truly died to self?

Remember, Christianity is a transformation. God does not simply want people of repentance. He wants people who have found new life in Him. We are meant to be a new Creation. I think perhaps many of us have experienced the Catholic penance of dying to self. But I think fewer of us experience that amazing fulfillment of living a new life in Christ.

This risen life is not simply a different way of doing things. It is a whole new world. Some of us may have experienced this fire, where we feel His joy and His peace and then want to share it with the world. We want everyone to feel this, to experience this joy. And we cannot give people what we do not ourselves have.

I look to St. Paul who described it perfectly. Paul once persecuted the Church. But when he was struck blind by the light of Christ, he had to die to his old life. He had to abandon everything he knew to live a new life in Jesus. He wrote “For I have been crucified with Christ, and yet I live. And the life that I live now is not my own, but Christ lives in me. Inasmuch as I live in the flesh, I live in the faith in the Son of God who has loved me and given Himself up for me.” (Galatians 2:19-20). In this we see Paul describing how he has died to his old self and is now living a new life with Christ.

Do I live my life knowing that I am alive in Christ? Do I live knowing that I am loved beyond all words and that the God of the universe lives inside of me?

That is the only way the third part of the program can work: to go.

You can read the whole article here.