ReasonForOurHope

Wednesday, September 30, 2015

New Evangelizers Post: The Pope and Practical Politics

I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  

It is no secret that we live in very politically polarized times.  And perhaps you are like me in that not only am I devoutly Catholic, but I also have very strong political convictions.

But as Catholics, what do we do when we find our political convictions challenged by our Holy Father?  Do we abandon our politics for our faith?  Or do we ignore our faith for our politics?  Or is there some other way out of this dilemma?

Pope Francis has recently visited the United States.  And no matter what he says, his words are analyzed in the media through the lens of politics.  That is not to say that the Pope does not make political statements.  It is only to highlight that we must be careful about what secondary sources tell us about this Pope, as he is one of the most often misunderstood and misquoted in my recollection.

Regardless, Francis says many things that raise the ire of the political right and the political left.  How are we to respond?

Here are a few things to keep in mind:

It must be remembered that the pope only speaks infallibly on the topic of faith and morals.  And even on these topics, infallibility only applies when he specifically and officially invokes that power.  If the pope secretly confided to someone that he didn’t believe the Resurrection was real, this would not violate papal infallibility.  If the pope declared that 2 + 2 = 5, this would also not be infallible because that is a matter of mathematics, not faith or morals.
Politics, while often dealing with topics of religion and morality, is not covered by infallibility per se.  It is possible for the pope to be wrong on political policy.  Pope Pius the XI entered into a concordant with the European fascists, which he later regretted.  So when a sitting pope makes statements of a political nature, those political points are not backed by infallibility.

But be careful here!

At this point, many would use this as an opportunity to simply dismiss the pope whenever he challenges their politics.  “Well, he’s talking about politics so it isn’t infallible.  Now I don’t have to listen.”

That is, to my mind, the absolutely incorrect attitude.

You can read the entire article here.

Sunday, September 27, 2015

Sunday Best: TV Dramas of All Time #17 - Angel




The more emotionally disturbed sister-show of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel is on this list not only because of some great writing and acting.  It is here because of its great ability to affect emotion.

Of course the problem is that emotion is depression and sadness.

Angel is based around the title character played by David Boreanaz, a vampire with a soul.  In the Buffy-verse, when you get turned into a vampire, your soul goes into the afterlife and a demon animates our body, but has all of your memories.  But with Angel he is cursed to have his soul reunited with his body and he remembers all of the horrible things he has done and can never achieve true happiness.

Cheery, am I right?

But even in the midst of this, creators Joss Whedon and David Greenwalt managed to build strong emotional ties to the characters who would often laugh their way through the pain, even as they dragged you through a long day's journey into night.

As a Catholic, I obviously take issues with these themes.  But I can appreciate this show not only as an expression of atheistic despair (which should in turn teach me more compassion), but also in how the creators struggle against that despair.  As I've written before on this blog, Whedon is an atheist who intellectually accepts the idea of meaninglessness in life.  But in his art he strives for something more, even though he cannot understand why.  In his world every human life is ultimately tragic, but he wants there to be more.  That is why I think there is a sliver of hope for redemption.

The stories of the show were also grand and epic sci-fi.  The show explored demons within and without in its examination of the human condition.

And there was some great action too.

TV THRESHOLD
"Hero"
(1x09)
SPOILER ALERT
The series begins with three regular cast members: Angel, Cordelia (Charisma Carpenter), and Doyle (the late Glenn Quinn).  Cordelia was the spoiled rich girl who came out to LA to make it as an actress but struggled.  Doyle was a half-demon who would have visions to guide Angel to his next quest.  This particular episode centered around trying to get Angel to embrace his full hero destiny.  But in the end, Doyle ended up sacrificing his life to save a group of innocents.  Perhaps it happened before, but I never saw a show kill off one of its main characters less than half-way through its first season.  It was shocking to say the least.  And it set the tone of danger and sadness for the rest of the show.

JUMP THE SHARK
"Home"
(4.x22)
At the end of an epic story arc, Angel and his crew are offered to take over control of the main bad guy's business: Wolfram and Hart.  This is an evil demonic law firm.  This is a bad idea.  You know it is a bad idea.  This will not end well.  And yet the characters inexplicably accept because that is what the 5th season was about.  This episodes sets up the worst and most tedious season of the show.

WORST EPISODE
"A Hole in the World"
(5x15)
As I said, my Catholic sensibilities are a little frayed by the underlying despair of a show like this.  But this where it was pushed into overdrive.  This episode is not bad because of the acting (it is fantastic) or the skill of the writing (it is superb), but in the ugliness of the themes.  If you ever want to end an episode and feel the darkness of existence, watch this episode.

BEST EPISODE
"Five by Five" and "Sanctuary"
(1x18-19)

Faith, one of the main villains from Buffy the Vampire Slayer, comes to Angel.  And she is just as violent as ever.  When she comes across her former Watcher Wesley (Alexis Denisof), she proceeds to torture him.  But all of this builds to a head with the final moments of the first of the two part episode.  Every time I see it, it still gives me chills.  Even in all of this darkness there is the tiniest light.



OVERALL

Angel my be too dark for some people, and I respect that.  A special shout out needs to be made to Denisof who took his character from a one-note comic punchline to the show's emotional whipping boy, to being the heart of the entire series.  Watching his transformation over the course of 5 years was amazing.  

But the for skill in making this show alone, it deserves its place on this list.

Saturday, September 26, 2015

Film Review: Black Mass



Have you ever finished a story and said to yourself, "That was pretty good.  But it could have been great if only they had done x, y, or z?"

That is the feeling I had when I left Black Mass.

This movie assembled one of the most impressive ensemble casts I have seen in a good long while.  And all the time I was watching it, I kept thinking that the movie never really utilized them.  It's like having a top of the line super computer and using only to check your twitter feed.

Black Mass is the true story of James "Whitey" Bulger played by one of our greatest living film actors Johnny Depp.  Depp brings terror and charisma to this monstrous mobster.  But the real central character is John Connolly (Joel Edgerton), an FBI man from Whitey's neighborhood.  When the mandate comes down that the FBI needs to take out the Italian mob, Connolly proposes an alliance with Whitey's Winter Hill Gang to help take them out.  And of course, this deal with the devil begins to spiral out of control.

What follows is a serviceable, but uninspired story.  I do not have any inside information, but I get the feeling that the movie was supposed to be about Connolly, but once Depp signed on they centered it mostly on Whitey.  This was a mistake.  Don't get me wrong, Depp is fantastic.  But like The Silence of the Lambs (and it should be noted how Hannibal Lector-like Depp looks in this film), a little can go a long way.  From the very beginning you get the strong sense that there is something bent about Connolly.  If the movie had started off with him much more of a straight arrow who got twisted by his own designs, that would much more compelling.

The story also suffers from the problem that most bio-pics have: putting in details that don't service a straightforward plot.  Early in the movie there is a storyline about Whitey's sick child.  This is used to explain Whitey being as evil as he is.  The problem is that you didn't need that storyline because you already bought that Whitey was a psychopath.  Ultimately this and other vignettes feel like unnecessary tangents.

As a Catholic, I found that this movie does what the best mob movies do: they show the ugliness of evil.  I know that some people emulate the characters in The Godfather, but Coppola clearly meant to show how making evil choices destroys your soul.  Many of the characters in the movie don't have much soul to begin with, but what little they had is exchanged for what ultimately feels like dust.

What does work incredibly well, as I said, are the performances.  Depp should get another Oscar nomination.  He truly looks ghoulish and he exudes menace.  There is one particularly harrowing scene where is he "checking on the health" of Connolly's wife (Julianne Nicholson) that is so filled with threatening subtext that it is difficult to breathe while watching it.  Benedict Cumberbatch plays Whitey's straight-laced brother, and he nails the apathetic evil of turning a blind eye.  There are also fantastic performances by Dakota Johnson, Kevin Bacon, Peter Sarsgaard, Jesse Plemmons, David Harbour, and Juno Temple.

But these great actors or horribly integrated into the story.  Johnson disappears a third of the way through the movie with no explanation.  Sarsgaard seems to come out of nowhere to be a complication. Temple is in one quick shot in the first act and we are expected to remember her significance for a tense, emotional scene in the third.  Plot points and characters are not Jenga pieces that should be placed wherever possible to keep the story straight.  They must grow organically from the beginning so that they are an integrated whole.  Instead, the characters mash ups make Black Mass feel like a Frankenstein's monster where director Scott Cooper tried to take the best parts from other movies and awkwardly sew them together.

I will also say this about the movie, it is fascinating.  It never draws you in to truly care about the characters, but it does keep your interest by taking you behind the curtain of a world that is rarely scene.  I mean, who knew there was such an underworld in the sport of Jai-alai?

Bottom line: if you want to see great performances and don't mind that they are presented in a mediocre film, then Black Mass is for you.

3 out of 5 stars.

Wednesday, September 23, 2015

Muppets Review: The End of the Rainbow Connection



My fondest memories of the Muppets are actually not from their movies or live-action shows.  I was wondrously in love with the Saturday Morning TV cartoon: The Muppet Babies.

That cartoon was a different take on the Muppets, making them younger and even more innocent.  And in their innocence they reveled in the power of their imagination and embraced the joy of life like children.  This did not take anything away from the original Muppets, it instead enhanced and highlighted what was so good about them.

And who could forget the magic of "Rainbow Connection?"  Who but the Muppets could deliver a song of pure optimism in a touching banjo ballad of tangible hope?  The song is about not giving in to the cynics who say that dreams about love and beauty are empty illusions.  If you really believe, you can achieve your dreams.  That's what the Muppets stood for.

All of that is over now.

The Muppets have been officially ruined.

This was in the cards for a little while.  The rebooted Muppet movie from a few years ago had a lot of the trappings of the classic, optimistic old show but there was just a slight touch of cynicism that is poisonous to something like this.  The sequel, Muppets Most Wanted, employed some of the most cynical humorists around like Tina Fey and Ricky Gervais.

Now the Muppets have fully embraced the cynicism and so have lost all of their joy.

There is nothing joyous about this show.  Are there some funny jokes?  Yes.  But they lack any kind of heart or warmth.

In this first episode alone we had jokes about:

-unmarried pregnancy
-drug use
-hook ups
-gay bears
-bigoted parents
-Animal's several women

They've turned the Muppets into the cast from 30 Rock.  And that is NOT a good thing.

It's not that the jokes were incredibly offensive per se.  It's that they don't belong with the Muppets.

All of the affection that you have for the characters is completely lost.  These are Muppets that have been destroyed and deformed to reflect modern Hollywood's own disgusting image.  The Muppets are now defeated, self-loathing cynics who are emotionally broken and use humor as an outlet of their frustration and rage.

But the Muppets are supposed to be about joy and above all love.  The Muppets loved each other despite being misfits and weirdos.  And they loved life with an infectious love.  As a kid you would dream about spending time with them because of the affection and love they shared with each other.  And that dream always reminded you why you loved them Muppets.  You loved that dream.

But now the dream is over.  This is not a show about love.  This is not even a show for those who dare to dream of something better.

Somehow they lost it, that Rainbow Connection.

The lovers.

The dreamers.

And me.


Trailer Time: The Young Messiah


This either going to be very good or very bad.

It is an intriguing idea: what was the child Jesus like?

It is a non-Scriptural exploration that could be done horribly.

But I am encouraged by the use of Scripture in the trailer and the score sounds beautiful.

Thoughts?

Monday, September 21, 2015

Thoughts on Emmy's 2015

I did not get a chance to live Tweet the Emmy's this year, but to be honest my heart wasn't in it anyway.

This was one of the lowest rated Emmy's in a while.

I don't fault Andy Sandberg, who was goofy but affable most of the time.

The problem came from audiences not caring about most of these shows.

As I pointed out when the nominations came out, there is a huge disparity between what most people are watching and what is being nominated.  So for me, I didn't have much of a dog in the fight.

Mostly the night was disappointments in terms of who I wanted to win.

-Once again, Mayim Bialick was snubbed for her great work on The Big Bang Theory

-As much as I love Peter Dinklage, Jonathan Banks deserved the Emmy, hands down.

-Olive Kitteridge sounds like the most depressing and awful piece of crap that I would never want to watch.  That isn't to say that it isn't good.  But there is nothing about this story that compels me to see it despite the fact that it won so many awards.

-Amy Poehler was robbed.

-Viola Davis is a great actress who should have won an Oscar for The Help.  I'm glad she won an Emmy, but her show is awful.

-It is one thing for the creator of Transparent to celebrate her gender-fluid father.  But to then forcibly transgender the Creator by calling Him "the goddess?"  I couldn't tell if this was actual spiritual ignorance or a sophomoric attempt to get a rise out of middle America.

-The Emmys will continue to be low rated so long as they snub actual hits for things that are not.


Sunday, September 20, 2015

Sunday Best: Top 10 Johnny Depp Performances

After watching Black Mass, I began reflecting on Johnny Depp's amazing body of work.

So here is a list of Depp's 10 best performances.

Now these are not necessarily an assessment of the quality of the movie itself.  You can have a great performance in a bad to mediocre movie (as is the case of Jennifer Lawrence in Winter's Bone).

These are examples of Depp's mastery of his craft.

10.  Mort Rainey in Secret Window

Secret Window is a simply horror story, so we think.  Depp plays the put-upon author who has a deranged stalker.  It seems like one of the least nuanced performances.  But as the movie begins to unfold and the truth begins to unravel, you realize that Depp has pulled the wool over your eyes.  If you go back and re-watch, there are so many different clues he gives you in his performance.

9.  Gilbert Grape in What's Eating Gilbert Grape

Depp usually layers his characters with all kinds of mannerisms, voices, and other acting accoutrements.  But this performance as a young man with too much responsibility and not enough maturity is very simple and direct in the best possible way.  He is not transformed into someone else.  He is simply Depp being the most emotional Depp there is.

8.  Sam in Benny and Joon.

For the physicality alone, Depp deserves amazing praise.  He captures the pure genius of the old silent masters like Keaton and Chaplin.  But on top of that, he used those skills to convey his character less with words but with inscrutable looks and gestures.  And he is really funny in this.


7.  James "Whitey" Bulger in Black Mass

Depp is completely believable and terrifying as Bulger, a man who would kill you without hesitation if you crossed him.  The makeup helps, but there is a coldness to his look that is almost monstrous.  And he carries himself with such calculated evil and it is unnerving.


6.  James Barry in Finding Neverland

This is Depp's most understated emotional performances.  As someone who is known for going big or going home, Depp holds back so much in this movie so that every tiny expression of heart is powerful and cathartic.  It is like there is a volcano of child-like wonder and passion bubbling under a cast--iron facade.  Great acting. (clip below is from the end of the movie.  DO NOT WATCH if you haven't seen it)

5.  Donnie Brasco in Donnie Brasco

What a great performance of conflicting loyalty and emotions.  It is fascinating to watch Depp as his character gets lost in identity and cannot find his way out.  Each choice he makes is another turn in an invisible labyrinth and you are on the edge of your seat to see if he can find his way out or be destroyed.  And the challenge he has is staggering to play a person who is playing a liar but playing it convincingly.

4.  Don Juan DeMarco in Don Juan Demarco

The pure charm and spectacular charisma is hard to match in this film.  In the opening scene, a woman looks at him and laughs, but by the end of the scene she is completely seduced.  And that is the exerpeince Depp has on the audience.  His supreme confidence in every word he says, despite being delusional, pulls you in and convinces you.

3.  Ed Wood in Ed Wood

I think many people remember the goofy look of excitement that Depp gave Ed Wood in this movie.  But that is simply the result of the unbridled enthusiasm he infused in the character.  You can understand why Wood kept making movies: it wasn't because he was good at it, but because he loved it.  And behind that smile there was an innocent emotional core that was wounded and broken.  But it is, to my mind, his funniest performance.

2.  Captain Jack Sparrow in Pirates of the Caribbean series

This performance, like Tom Hanks' Forrest Gump, is so often imitated that I think we forget how absolutely innovative it is.  Like Heath Ledger's turn as the Joker, Depp makes an amazing amount of acting choices that no other actor would.  His walk, his talk, his cadence… there are so many things that are unique only to someone like Depp.  And throughout all of that, he still brings the most basic swashbuckling heroics to life.  This was his first Oscar nomination and well deserved.  This performances shouldn't work, but it does because he pops from the screen like nothing we've seen.

1.  Edward Scissorhands in Edward Scissorhands.

I just rewatched this movie and I was lost in Depp's performance.  In some ways he is the most human and emotional of all the characters and yet he gives him the physicality of a machine that is trying to imitate humans.  Watch how he walks and carries himself.  You can often feel the clockwork gears grinding away inside.  Every look is potent with feeling and meaning.  You can watch as he seethes with rage or burns with love or agonizes in pain like no other.  And every utterance of his voice, in that simple high and soft cadence, carries with it an emotional punch.  Is there a sadder response in film history to the request "hold me" than his despairing words, "I can't."  This movie would not have worked at all without Depp making something strange into something heart-warming and beautiful.