ReasonForOurHope

Saturday, December 30, 2023

Catholic Skywalker Awards - Best in TELEVISION 2023

    With 2023 coming to a close, it is time for us to choose what the best entertainment of the year was.  And just as the Academy Awards have their "Oscars", so too the Catholic Skywalker Awards have their "Kal-El's"




To reiterate:  the reasons for choosing a Superman statue as it's award, and not something from Star Wars are 3-fold:

1.  The Catholic Skywalker Awards will cover movies, television, and comic books.  Superman is an icon for all three.
2.  The pose he has here, revealing his inner hero, is symbolic of the revelation of truth and beauty that we should find in all good art.
3.  It's a statue I actually own, so I can use this photo on my blog.





(My appreciation and judgment of a TV show should not be taken as a recommendation. Choosing to watch any of these films is the reader's responsibility)

And now we here at Catholic Skywalker would like to celebrate the best in Television this year.

There are a lot of wonderful (so I'm told) programs out there that, unfortunately, time has not permitted me to see such as  Blue Eyed Samurai.


Shows we watch:

DRAMACOMEDYREALITY
Will Trent
The Last of Us
One Piece
The Chosen
Poker Face
Loki
The Rookie
The Flash
Lucky Hank
Picard
Superman and Lois
The Walking Dead: Dead City
The Fall of the House of Usher
The Irrational
Secret Invasion
Ahsoka
Night Court
That '90s Show
Frasier
Shrinking
Ted Lasso
Only Murders in the Building
Goldbergs
Animal Control
Simpsons
Dancing with the Stars
Suvivor
The Amazing Race
Welcome to Wrexham
The Maked Singer
Floor is Lava



DISCLAIMER:

More so than in years past, it has been difficult to find television shows that are not morally compromised.  This is not a new problem.  Television throughout the years has portrayed and promoted lifestyles that are contrary to the Gospel.  Shows like Cheers, Night Court, Friends, The Big Bang Theory, etc have characters living in immoral ways without addressing that context.  This is especially true of the comedies.  In drama, you can deal with the complexities of human sin in a more ambiguous way than in the modern comedy.

That does not mean that just because a show has good morals that it is therefore a good piece of art.  But a show with bad morals makes the show less artistically excellent.  In fact, there are many people who will not engage with any of these shows because of their content.  I am someone who does engage with the content.  Particularly in the area of the sitcom, my choice of the best of the year is not something that excuses the content.  It is a statement of the shows excellence in comparison to the other shows in the category.  And as I said, almost every show has something that is morally compromising.  Therefore, keep that in mind when I am awarding the shows.

Best Drama:
Picard





From my review:

Love.


That is what sets this season of Picard apart from nearly anything else Star Trek has produced in the last 25 years.  

Don't get me wrong, there have been some good things in the last few decades.  I greatly enjoyed JJ Abrams Star Trek reboot.  But much of what has been produced lately has been sub-par.  In particular, the first two seasons of Picard were dreadful.  Star Trek seemed determined to give Jean-Luc Picard the Last Jedi treatment.  

You can imagine my total delight and surprise when Star Trek Picard Season 3 made one of the best seasons of TV I've seen in awhile.

And again, it all comes down to love.

Terry Matalas took over the reigns as showrunner.  And you can tell with every frame of film that he loves Star Trek.  He doesn't just love The Next Generation, but he loves all of Star Trek.  This is apparent from the very first shot of the season to the end credits.  And he understands that Star Trek is not simply about the operatic space adventure.  Star Trek is about the characters.  This is what has been missing from so much of recent Trek, including Picard.  In the last two seasons, Jean-Luc has behaved in ways unrecognizable to someone who is familiar with Next Generation.  But now it feels like we got him back...


There are tons of Easter eggs for Trek fans to find.  This could lead a person to accuse the show of fan service.  I'm not against fan service at all.  I think that people who produce a beloved TV show should do what they can to please the fans.  I only object when fan service is a replacement for good storytelling.  Matalas does both.  

He sets the plot up by drawing on threads from not only Next Generation, but also Deep Space Nine and Voyager, as well as the movies.  It is clear that Matalas made this movie with fans of the entire franchise in mind.  This gives the show the advantage of feeling familiar and new at the same time.

As showrunner, Matalas was able to weave in plot points in very creative ways.  He is able to drop important story elements without you even realizing that they will be important later.  It isn't until there is a reveal that you go, "Of course!"

Visually, the show looks fantastic.  You can tell that they used all the advancements in computer graphics to give us a spectacle.  But beyond that, the show is incredibly well-shot, knowing how to frame the characters, when to give us a sense of intimacy or grandeur.

But, of course, the best part of the show are the characters.  Matalas understands that for many of us, the characters we grew up with on Next Generation are not simply imaginary people on TV.  They are our friends.  If that sounds too over-the-top, then let's just say that we have emotional attachment to them in a way that is beyond reason.  We care about them and what happens to them.  We know when they behave in a way that is true and false.

Watching these classic characters bounce off of each other again is a pure joy.  Picard and Riker have a strong friendship, but it does not stop them from butting heads.  Each of them has had experiences that has broken them a bit inside.  But when they are on the same page, they appear unstoppable.  Stewart's and Frakes' chemistry has never been better.  In fact, the fact that they are older makes them appear more as equals, without ever losing that original dynamic completely.  



Runners-up
-The Chosen
-Superman and Lois
-Poker Face
-One Piece







Best Comedy
Fraiser



I am as surprised as you are that the reboot of a show that has been off the air for around 2 decades is the best comedy of the year.  What amazes me even more is that this show has done nothing innovative in terms of its style.  Instead, Frasier feels exactly like the original show.

And that is why it works.

The premise is that Frasier Crane (Kelsey Grammar), has retired from a popular TV talk show and has returned to Boston to reconnect with his firefighter son Freddy (Jack Cutmore-Scott).  The show is shot like a traditional four-camera sitcom with a live audience.  The writing is as predictable and tropy as any sitcom to come before.  And yet it works!

It works because they are not trying to do something new and subversive.  Instead, they are trying to remind us why we loved the original so much.  Because of that, the only thing that they seem to care about are the jokes.  They don't care about making some kind social statement.  Instead, everything is geared towards getting chuckles.  

There are actually some real moments of poignancy and insight.  But even these are done at the service of the overall comedic tone.   

Frasier does the most important thing a TV comedy can do: it makes you laugh.



Runners-up
Only Murders in the Building
The Simpsons
Ted Lasso
Jury Duty


Best Actor in a Drama
Patrick Stewart - Picard




Patrick Stewart is not as young as he was when Star Trek: The Next Generation first aired.  Even though he already looked older on that show, he carried with him a powerful physicality that presented itself in moments of crisis or romance.

It is to Stewart's credit that he does not try to play Picard the way he did before.  His Jean-Luc is a man who is looking towards the final chapters of his life.  But he still is able to carry the day with his commanding presence, not by being young and strong, but by presenting himself as someone with the strength of wisdom and character.  That isn't to say that he plays Picard as flawless.  In fact, those flaws make his performance so interesting.  But he stands in the breach as someone who carries the weight and power of the world on his shoulders.

His chemistry with his original team is so potent that they don't need to use words.  As I wrote in my review about a pivotal scene between himself and Gates McFadden:   "There is a scene in an early episode where the two of them lock eyes and have a serious conversation without saying a word.  To be clear, there is no science-fiction-type telepathy going on.  Instead, you have two seasoned actors expressing their deep truths to each other non-verbally.  The impact of that one moment touched me deeply."

Stewart could not have asked for a better finale for Jean-Luc Picard.
 

Runners-up
Bruce Greenwood - The Fall of the House of Usher
Pedro Pascal - The Last of Us
Tom Hiddleston - Loki
Jonathan Roumie - The Chosen




Best Actress in a Drama
Natasha Lyonne - Poker Face




One of the biggest shocks in TV this year was how good Lyonne was in Poker Face.  On the show, she is a human lie detector who goes on the lamb from a mob boss.  Like a weird hybrid of Columbo and The Incredible Hulk, Lyonne's character travels the country and every week gets involved in a new murder mystery.  The set up the show is incredibly enjoyable.  But Lyonne's performance is what really sells it.  She is a no-nonsense underachiever with a heart of gold.  Her power is also her curse.  She wants to just float through life and not get involved, but the lies that she detects keep drawing her deeper into webs of mysteries.  Lyonne herself not only shows incredible charm, but emotional depth as well.  There was an episode in a skiing lodge where she was facing certain death where I could not help being gripped by her performance.  She brought her A-Game to this show and I cannot wait to see more if it.


Runners-up
Mary McDonnell - The Fall of the House of Usher
Elizabeth Tulloch - Superman and Lois
Juno Temple - Fargo
Clemence Poesy - The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon





Best Supporting Actor, Drama
Jonathan Frakes - Picard




This is hands-down the best performance of Frakes as William Riker.

Like Picard, Riker is past his prime and is out in open space seeking adventure.  But when the layers are peeled back, we see a man on the run from his pain and his past.  When faced with certain death, Frakes shows us how broken Riker is by his embrace of oblivion.  This is not the same Riker from the original show, but it is a consistent evolution based on what he has suffered.  And Frakes knows this character so well that he can play that darkness without a false note.  Part of the show's journey is Riker trying to find light in the darkness.  Frakes us takes us through the depths all the while retaining his natural charm and charisma.  


Runners-up
Shahar Isaac -  The Chosen
Mark Hammil - The Fall of the House of Usher
Ke Huy Kwan - Loki
Todd Stashwick - Picard

 



Best Supporting Actress, Drama
Carla Gugino - The Fall of the House of Usher





This was one of the best performances I have seen on TV in years.  Gugino not only plays a kind of Devil character, but she also inhabits lots of different personality types in her manifestations.  Her transformations were so good that there were times I needed to do a double-take to be sure that it was the same actress playing her.  This shows not only incredibly chameleon-like transformative acting powers, but Gugino was also able to give layers and depth to a part that could come across as one-note superficial.  This is best exemplified in a scene where her character has to fulfill a part of a bargain that she does not want to do.  It is a tragic scene that makes you actually feel badly for her even as she does something wicked.  That takes incredible talent and that is what we see in this performance.

Runners-up
Lara Silva -  The Chosen
Emily Rudd - One Piece
Jerry Ryan - Picard
Gates McFadden - Picard


Best Actor, Comedy
Kelsey Grammar - Frasier






The key this revival show's success is Grammar.  Some of the supporting cast is not quite operating at his level.  But it doesn't matter. Grammar is able to carry the entire show on his shoulders.  He knows how to deliver his lines like a pro, knowing the exact inflection to elicit the most laughs.  And he knows when words are not needed.  This is exemplified in the best scene of the season.  Frasier is thinking about quitting his job at Harvard.  His son Freddie hears this and begins to repeat all of the things Frasier said to Freddie when he dropped out of Harvard.  The bit lasts about a minute, but the funniest part is watching Grammar sit there and take the verbal beating.  He is both annoyed, impressed, befuddled, and humiliated in the funniest possible way.  Grammar made me laugh that entire minute without saying a word.  That is a great comedic actor at work.

Runners-up
John Laroquette - Night Court
Martin Short - Only Murders in the Building
Jason Sudeikis - Ted Lasso
Steve Martin - Only Murders in the Building

Best Actress, Comedy
Hannah Waddingham - Ted Lasso






Waddingham has made a complete transformation in her character from Ted Lasso.  She went from vindictive ex-wife to fierce friend.  Over the course of the series we saw how her heart slowly opened to friendship and romance and to herself.  Watching her lose that grip was incredibly compelling.  You could see the fear in her eyes at the prospect of becoming what she was before, but finding the strength to continue to go on.  She has done a star-making turn here and I look forward to her work in the future.


Runners-up
Juno Temple - Ted Lasso
Selena Gomez - Only Murders in the Building
Christa Miller - Shrinking
Edy Modica - Jury Duty



Best Supporting Actor, Comedy
James Marsden - Jury Duty




This show was such a surprise for me.  Part reality show, part sitcom, Marsden plays a satirical version of himself as a pampered celebrity who is forced into jury duty.  It is easy enough to lampoon yourself, but Marsden had to sell it as a reality to the main participant in the show.  He had to make sure to not go too far while at the same time being absurd enough for the maximum comedic effect.  This not only shows his precision as an actor but his comedic instincts.  I think it is one of his best performances.


Runners-up
Nicholas Lyndhurst - Frasier
Kurtwood Smith - That '90's Show
David Brown - Jury Duty
Harrison Ford - Shrinking



Best Supporting Actress, Comedy
Meryl Streep - Only Murders in the Building




Everyone knows that Streep is a great actress.  But here, she both shrinks and shines.  She makes herself small as a woman who has working on the edges of the theater seen barely noticed for decades only to finally get a shot.  And when the emotional moments come, she hits them with all of her dramatic power.  At the same time she is able to keep up with the comedic might of both Steve Martin and Martin Short without skipping a beat.  I was not expecting to like her as much on this show, but she knocked it out of the park.

Runners-up
Vella Lovell - Animal Control
Debra Jo Rupp - That '90's Show
Susan Berger - Jury Duty
Jessica Williams - Shrinking





Stay tuned for the Catholic Skywalker Awards for Best Movies of 2023










Thursday, December 28, 2023

Film Flash: The Iron Claw

 

15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)

Well-acted tragedy about how a parent’s conditional love can destroy children



Star rating 3 of 5.png

Wednesday, December 27, 2023

Film Flash: Rebel Moon Part I - A Child of Fire

undefined

 15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)

 Seven Samurai in space. Your feelings about Zack Snyder's style will determine your enjoyment

Star rating 4 of 5.png

Film Flash: Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom

undefined

 15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)

Slightly better than the original Aquaman with excellent antagonists with interesting character arcs
Star rating 4 of 5.png

Film Flash: The Boys in the Boat


undefined

15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)

A wholesome, patriotic, sports film. Feels good like a satisfying meal at your grandparents’ house

Star rating 3.5 of 5.png

Tuesday, December 26, 2023

Catholic Skywalker Awards - Best in COMICS 2023

With 2023 coming to a close, it is time for us to choose what the best entertainment of the year was.  And just as the Academy Awards have their "Oscars, " so too the Catholic Skywalker Awards have their "Kal-El's"




Now, if you are new to this blog you may be wondering why a blog called Catholic Skywalker would choose a Superman statue as it's award, and not something from Star Wars.   The reasons are 3-fold:

1.  The Catholic Skywalker Awards will cover movies, television, and comic books.  Superman is an icon for all three.
2.  The pose he has here, revealing his inner hero, is symbolic of the revelation of truth and beauty that we should find in all good art.
3.  It's a statue I actually own, so I can use this photo on my blog.

Catholic Skywalker: Best in Comics:





Best Series
The Flash



For the third year in a row, The Flash is the best comic book series out there.  This is primarily to Jeremy Adams, who might be the best writer in comics right now.  As I wrote last year:

"Whenever I get my comics on Wednesday, if The Flash is out that day, it will be the very first comic I read when I get home.  

"One of the things that is immediately evident from the way Adams writes this book is that he has an incredible respect for the history of the Flash and he loves these characters.  It reminds me of when Geoff Johns took over the book soon after Mark Waid's legendary run.  Waid had taken Wally West from being an unlikeable wannabe to cementing him as his generations Flash.  Johns had big shoes to fill, but his clear love for this world and respect for the lore elevated him to writing one of the greatest runs on a character in comic book history."

Adams recently ended his run on the book with his epic "1-Minute War" storyline.  An alien race invades Earth while mainlining the speed-force.  In the space of one minute to everyone else, the entire Flash family has to band together to save the planet.  One of the great things about the story is that it was one that could only be done by the speedsters.  For that reason they are held up front and center but they are also completely isolated from any other help.  On top of this, Adams brought Barry Allen back to the fold as a central protagonist to the events.  All the while, the story maintained a strong emotional core so that we cared about the stakes.  It was a great send-off to Adams' run.


RUNNERS UP
Fantastic Four
Batman/Superman: World's Finest
Nightwing
Justice Society of America

Best Mini-Series
DCeased: War of the Undead Gods

DCeased: War Of The Undead Gods #8 review | Batman News

RUNNERS UP
Wolverine vs. Predator
Stargirl: The Lost Children
Junkyard Joe


Best One-Shot or Single Issue
Nightwing #105

Nightwing (2016-) #105 eBook : Taylor, Tom, Redondo, Bruno, Lucas, Adriano,  Redondo, Bruno, Redondo, Bruno, Lucas, Adriano: Kindle Store - Amazon.com
This was the most unique issue of a comic book series I have read since The Flash #776.  

The entire issue was drawn from the 1st person perspective of Nightwing himself.  This could have been a simple gimmick.  But what makes this issue so interesting and compelling is that for the briefest of moments, you actually feel a little like Nightwing.  You get to see what it looks like for him to swing through the towers of Bludhaven or to brawl in a close-quarters train car.  

In that sense, the issue was transportive.  Like all good escapist entertainment, I left my ordinary world and entered one that was extraordinary for a little while and I enjoyed every minute of it.

Best Artist
Gary Frank (Junkyard Joe, Geiger)
File:Gary Frank.jpg

Gary Frank is one of the best artists working in the industry today.  One of the testaments to his work is this past year's Junkyard Joe.  Writer Geoff Johns gave Frank the unenviable task of turning drawing the main hero as an expressionless robot with PTSD.  One of the talents of Frank is his ability to do a lot with facial expressions.  Johns robbed him of that with Junkyard Joe and Frank still delivered.

He was able to sell us on Joe's personality with his body language and his action.  He set up shots that were emotional and dynamic in a way that showed that Frank does not need to give you a character's facial expression to let us know what he is feeling or to make us feel something as well.  Amazing job.

RUNNERS UP
Bruno Redondo: Nightwing
Alan Robinson: New Fantastic Four
Mark Silvestri: Batman/Joker: Deadly Duo


Best Writer
Tom Taylor (Nightwing, DCeased: War of the Undead Gods, Dark Knights of Steel, Titans, Titans: Beast World)
File:Tom Taylor Brisbane 2017 33.jpg
photo by RazorboltBruce

I will be the first to say that I am not a fan of everything Tom Taylor writes.  But I would not let that fact get in the way of acknowledging the man's talent and the power of his writing.

I've already mentioned above how he was able to bring home the emotional hammer in DCeased and how he is able to new and innovative things with comic storytelling as he has in Nightwing.  I know some of the comics reviewers I admire who do not like his Nightwing run, but I think they overlook how fun it is.  He has taken elements from the previous runs of the character and woven them into an enjoyable narrative.  He has even taken the much maligned "Ric Grayson" era and morphed it into a very charming pirate adventure.  Yes, you have to suspend your disbelief quite a bit, but that only allows you to truly enjoy the fun.

I've also greatly enjoyed his work on the new Titans ongoing.  He starts with a bit of mystery that pushes the others to action.  One of the things that I like about what Taylor is doing is that he is writing all of the characters "in character."  They all don't sound the same.  Each has their own perspective and way of seeing the world.  Not only that, but they are not stupid.  Not all of them are geniuses on Nightwing's level, but they are not easily duped into the plot of the villain simply because the plot needs it to happen.

Between these three books, Tom Taylor has made my comic-reading of 2023 very enjoyable and I think that it would be the same for any reader.

RUNNERS UP
Jeremy Adams: The Flash, Green Lantern, Jay Garrick: Flash
Mark Waid: World's Finest: Batman/Superman, Batman vs. Robin, SHAZAM!
Geoff Johns: Junkyard Joe, Geiger, Justice Society of America, Stargirl: The Lost Children
Ryan North: Fantastic Four

Monday, December 25, 2023

Merry Christmas 2023

 


  



 



Merry Christmas!

I know that this world can be one filled with darkness and pain.  But today we celebrate the fact that our Lord entered into this world with His healing light.

There was a great struggle for the Holy Family to make it down to Bethlehem from Nazareth.  And even after the great Birth, they had to flee for their lives from the wicked king.  Jesus was born into tumult and violence.  But he arrived this way to show us that even in the midst of all of that, God is victorious.  Love conquers all.

 So, as Linus reminded us, these are the words that bring us hope this day:

Now there were shepherds in that region living in the fields and keeping the night watch over their flock. 
  
The angel of the Lord appeared to them and the glory of the Lord shone around them, and they were struck with great fear.

The angel said to them, “Do not be afraid; for behold, I proclaim to you good news of great joy that will be for all the people.

For today in the city of David a savior has been born for you who is Messiah and Lord.

And this will be a sign for you: you will find an infant wrapped in swaddling clothes and lying in a manger.”

And suddenly there was a multitude of the heavenly host with the angel, praising God and saying:


“Glory to God in the highest and on earth peace to those on whom his favor rests.”