ReasonForOurHope

Tuesday, December 19, 2023

Vatican News on Blessing Those with Same-Sex Attractions

 Just because I have been reading so many misleading and erroneous headlines and just in case it comes up in any Theology classes, here are a few points of clarification:


-Pope Francis has not approved same-sex “marriage”

-Pope Francis has not approved blessings to same-sex unions

-The definition of sacramental marriage has not changed

-The recent document has reiterated how it is pastorally permissible to bless any person or persons, regardless of their current life situation. For example, a murderer on death row can receive a blessing as a means to encounter the Grace of God as a step towards changing his heart. 

-people in same-sex relationships may ask for blessings from clergy. This, again, is a blessing of the person, not the activity. 

-no ritual is permitted for blessing same-sex couples so as not to confuse such a blessing with marriage

-no liturgical actions or things like liturgical actions may be used in blessing those in same-sex relationships so as not to give the impression that the relationship is being blessed.

-this is not a first step towards changing the Church’s teaching on marriage

-the stated purpose of the proclamation is to say that anyone, no matter their state of sinfulness, may ask to encounter God in the form of a blessing. The hope is that this openness to receive a blessing will be a first step toward holiness. As Christ did not wait for us to become righteous before drawing near to us, the hope is that the presence of Christ’s blessings will lead us towards righteousness.

Will there be those who will weaponize confusion to sow discord and frustration?  I'm sure there will be.  But we are always called, as Catholics, to offer clarity with charity.

I would encourage everyone to read the document itself here.  

Sunday, December 17, 2023

Film Flash: Wonka

 

undefined

15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)

Charming children's film that could have been great with better music and not anti-clergy.


Star rating 3.5 of 5.png

Friday, December 15, 2023

Film Review: Napoleon

 



Sexuality/Nudity Mature

Violence Mature


Vulgarity Mature

Anti-Catholic Philosophy Mature

It may not be fair to compare one historical biopic with another, but I could not help thinking about how different Ridley Scott's Napoleon was from Steven Spielberg's Lincoln.

Napoleon tells the story of Napoleon Bonaparte (Joaquin Phoenix).  It focuses on his rise to power from an officer in the French military during the Revolution to the rank of Emperor through to his eventual downfall.  Woven into the story is his long and tortured relationship with Josephine (Vanessa Kirby).  In fact, most of the film centers around their marriage woes.  After every intense battle scene, we always seemed to return to the two of them on the couch talking about how much they love and hate each other.

It should be said at the outset that Napoleon is a gorgeous movie to look at.  Scott has lost none of his power as a visual storyteller.  You can feel the squalor and opulence of the era in a powerful and visceral way.  The romantic imagery is lush and the battle scenes are exciting.  In fact, I would say the battle scenes are the best part of the film.  It is just a shame that there are not more of them.  For a man who is legendary for his prowess on the battlefield, Napoleon gives short shrift to the man's military genius.

The film is also very well-acted.  Phoenix's performance is sometimes befuddling and beguiling, but it is always fascinating.  He shows you different sides of Napoleon from his fear, his hubris, to his amorous nature.  Some of his acting choices are odd, as when he indicates that he wants intimacy with his wife, but they are always interesting.  Kirby is also quite good as Josephine.  She is able to show a wide range of emotional intensities that make you understand why Napoleon was drawn to her.  Rupert Everett also does a short but memorable turn as the Duke of Wellington.

However, all of that talent cannot fix the problems of the script.

Let me return to Spielberg's Lincoln to compare.  Both of these movies deal with larger-than-life historical leaders from the 19th Century.  Spielberg treats his subject with a sense of awe.  We are invited to come into the presence of the great man and experience his grandeur.  He gives us hints of the hidden depth behind the mystique.  Lincoln also only deals with a very specific few weeks where he works to pass the 13th Amendment.  Instead of trying to cram his entire biography into a movie, Spielberg helps us have an experience of the man by his actions in a great cause.  Lincoln also has a trouble relationship with his wife, but this is not his defining characteristic.

Napoleon does the opposite of Lincoln.

Instead of focusing on his greatness, we focus on how Napoleon is petty and broken.  Napoleon may not have been a good man (I will leave that to your judgment), but he was a great man in terms of his influence on history.  We get some measure of him as a tactician, but it is overshadowed by his flaws.  It makes you wonder how he could rise through the ranks the way he did.  Scott takes you too far behind the curtain to create a mystique.  The movie also falls into the trap of most biopics in that it tries to cover too much of his life so that the power of his character is spread too thin in the narrative.  And by putting his relationship with Josephine at the heart of everything, it makes the man feel smaller.

Whereas Lincoln was constructive, Napoleon was reductive.

Scott is let down by David Scarpa's script.  I remember the exact moment I began to realize the full problem with the script when at dinner, Napoleon triumphantly shouts, "Destiny as brought me this lam chop!"  It became very difficult to take the character seriously after that.  The characters besides Napoleon, Josephine, and Wellington are so ill-defined that I could not keep them straight.  This is also Scott's fault since so many of the characters look exactly the same.  I could not tell who was who because they all looked alike.  Again, contrast that with Lincoln, which also sported a large supporting cast, but everyone was given a distinctive look.

The movie is also unnecessarily graphic.  I don't believe there was nudity, but the sex scenes were guttural that it was completely off-putting.  Something tells me that filming Abe and Mary Todd doing the horizontal Mambo would have added anything to Spielberg's film  And while the sex life of Napoleon had a big impact on his story, I find this need to show historical figures in comically animalistic passion to be disgusting.

For a movie that wants to be deep, it is surprisingly shallow.  Napoleon is simply a man with a "Napoleon Complex."  He feels small so he wants to make the world see him as a big man.  While there may be some truth to that analysis, this oversimplifies the man.  Besides his victories in battle, you never get a sense of why he was so popular with the people.  You never get a sense of how he was able to hold together such a chaotic country with his reforms of law and religion.  You may argue that this was not in the scope of the movie, but they did have time for an hour of marital conflict.  There is some justice in that the movie shows horrible people coming to unhappy ends, but the impact feels dulled by the length of the film.

The more I think of the movie, the less it holds up in my mind.  My hopes were high, so perhaps it is unfair that this movie did not meet my expectations.

But when you have an A-list director and cast along with a subject that is the stuff of legends, your final product should be legendary.

Instead, Napoleon is a forgettable film that will match the greatness of its subject




Tuesday, December 12, 2023

Doctor Who and the Loss of Storytelling

 

Rework of the Watermark BBC Doctor Who Logo by NeoRame

As you may know, Doctor Who is celebrating its 60th Anniversary with the return of David Tennant in three special episodes.

Instead of being a gigantic cause of unifying celebration, the reception has divided the fandom.

Why?


Well, here is what happened in the first special:


The Doctor arrives in London where he bumps into Donna Noble.  Donna has an adult daughter named Rose who is now a born-again Catholic.  Later on in the episode as Donna and Rose are walking home, a group of Rose's atheist classmates ride by on bicycles and make fun of Rose for her belief in Christ.  Once home, Donna and her mother struggle with how best to talk to Rose about her newfound faith without offending her.  Rose feels different than everyone else because of her Catholic faith and she befriends an alien who appears to be hunted.  When the Doctor talks to the alien, Rose berates him for assuming that the alien has not already been baptized and accepted Jesus Christ as his Lord and Savior.  The Doctor apologizes for this assumption and asks the alien about their baptismal status.  It turns out that the alien is evil and tries to destroy London.  To save London, the Doctor must awaken Donna's memories, but this will kill her.  However, for the greater good, Donna agrees and they save London at the cost of Donna's life.  But Donna comes back to life because she was able to share her power with her daughter.  It is explained that because Rose has been born again in Jesus Christ, she has been twice-born and thus has two lives to accept the Time-Lord energy.  By being reborn in Christ, she explicitly says that she is more than those who are not baptized in His Name.  In the end, Rose and her mother are able to survive the Time-Lord metacrisis because, as a devout Catholic, Rose has the humility to let go of that power.  Before Rose does so, she points out how the non-Catholic Doctor could never understand what Rose has figured out because of her Catholic Identity.


If the above description sounds weird, you can understand why.  Would you not agree that this describes less of a science-fiction story about The Doctor and more like a Christian parable that is meant to preach a lesson?  Even as a devout Catholic, I find most Christian movies unpalatable because they choose sermonizing over storytelling.  For them, it is more important to give a lesson on the message than it is to move and entertain.  Even if I agree with the wholesome message of faith above, the prioritizing of message over story ruins both the story and the message.

And that is what has happened with Doctor Who.  

The above description of the first special episode is accurate.  Except you should replace Christianity with Gender Ideology.  Those who dislike the sermonizing of the show have been accused of being bigoted.  But that dodges the main problem.  Even if the themes were explicitly Catholic, as we find in the above example, it would still be terrible storytelling.

Instead of telling a universal story to celebrate six decades of Doctor Who, showrunner Russel T. Davies has decided that we are children who need to be taught a lesson.  He is the sage from on high who will set our wayward minds in the right direction.  .  This is the fatal flaw in most writing: to forget that the writer serves the audience and not vice-versa.  

That is a shame because there are some good moments in the anniversary specials.  However, Davies has lost his touch.  Or rather his skill has reverted back to what it was in his first season of Doctor Who.  I have nothing against Christopher Eccleston, but his season of the show was not one of my favorites.  It wasn't due to his performance, but it was primarily Davies' failures as a storyteller.  Remember this was the season that showed us that they would still be playing The Weakest Link in the future.  He would take fads and fashions of the day and project them as universal and timeless, which they are not.  So much of what he made that season is dated.  His metaphors were clumsy and his themes were too on the nose.  That is what has occurred here in the 60th Anniversary shows.  

And Davies forgets that sometimes the best way to deliver a message is by never saying it explicitly.  JRR Tolkien said that The Lord of the Rings is a clearly Catholic story, but Christ and the Church are never mentioned.  JK Rowling is clearly a Christian, but there is almost no reference to Christianity.  That is because their faith is woven into the fabric of the story.  So if you wrap yourselves up in the story, you will be receiving their themes of love, heroism, and sacrifice.  

I am convinced that the works Tolkien and Rowling with be read decades from now.  But if they keep doing to Doctor Who what Davies is doing, will time be kind to the Time Lord?

Monday, December 11, 2023

New Evangelizers Post: No Room at the Inn

                                                            


 


I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  


Like many of you, I notice how packed the pews become during Christmas mass. It is wonderful having large crowds gather to celebrate the birth of Our Lord. And yet there is a sadness that many of the people who crowd the congregation will be absent in the coming weeks. We often call them the “Christmas/Easter” Catholics because those are the only days when we see them in Church. All the other Sundays of the year are filled with work, leisure, vacations, and other things besides the Table of the Lord.

There is no room for Christ in their weekends.

It reminds me of how Luke writes how Mary “wrapped him in swaddling clothes and laid him in a manger, because there was no room for them in the inn.” (Luke 2:7). We are all familiar with the Nativity story: how Joseph and Mary traveled to Bethlehem because of the census. And when they arrived, all the inns were full so they had to go to the stable. Even at His birth, we see the foreshadowing of His passion: this is the story of the first time Christ was rejected. Imagine the glory that would have been given you if Jesus was born in your home. But the houses were too filled. And so the unborn Jesus was turned away.

There was no room for Christ in their homes.

And how so like the “Christmas/Easter” Catholics are those homeowners of Bethlehem. Jesus wants to come into their lives and be close to them in the Eucharist every Sunday. But there is no room for Him in their lives. So He is banished to the barn. He gets only the most minimal shelter and the smallest welcome. The King of Glory knocks on our door and we throw Him our scraps.

Now, you who go to Church every Sunday, do not climb up on your high horse either. While acknowledging the sadness of the “Christmas/Easter” Catholic, Jesus orders us not to be their judge. One of the reasons for this command is that we are in position to judge our brothers and sisters.

I may welcome Christ into my life every Sunday, but what about the rest of the week? I don’t only mean going to daily mass. Reflect on your life and see if there is anywhere that Christ has not been given Lordship? Is there any part of my life where Christ is not invited?

Is Jesus a part of your friendships? Do you freely share him with your buddies?

Is Jesus a part of your marriage? Do you pray with your spouse and share you soul with them?

Is Jesus a part of your finances? Do you ask Him to guide the spending of your money and ask Him to help you be generous?

Is Jesus a part of your future plans? Do you say to Him, “Jesus I have hope and designs for the future, but not my will but Yours be done?”

If there is any part of my life where I have not invited Jesus to enter, then we are like the homeowners of Bethlehem who say, “There is no room for you here, Jesus.”


You can read the whole article here.




Sunday, December 10, 2023

Film Flash: Godzilla Minus One

 


15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)


One of the best films of the year and the best Godzilla movie I've seen.
Star rating 4.5 of 5.png

Monday, December 4, 2023

Lack of Updates December 2023

 

Hello all,


Thank you for your patience.  The first few weeks of December may have only a few updates.  I am coming to the end of my first semester of Diaconate Formation and I have three papers that are due in this next week-and-a-half as well as a great deal of grading to do at work.  

As soon as I am able to finish these projects, we will return to our regular blog schedule.

Thank you for continuing to read and I look forward to spending time with you hear, particularly as we start looking back at the best movies, TV, and comics of the year!


God Bless,

Catholic Skywalker