ReasonForOurHope

Sunday, November 14, 2021

Sunday Best: Top Ten Martial Arts Movies

 I grew up on martial arts movies.  

I didn't just watch the standard fare.  Not only do I know Bruce Lee and Jackie Chan, but I'm familiar with the work of Dragon Lee and Bruce Li.  However, I freely admit that I am not such a devotee that I am an expert.  For every movie that makes this list, I'm sure there is someone out there who knows of something that is more popular among martial art film fanatics.

You will notice, for example, that there are no Jackie Chan movies on this list.  I think that the man's talent is without question.  However, as entertaining as his movies are, they never really clicked with me on an emotional level.

You will also notice more American films than would normally make a list like this.  It is important to note that I am grading what are the best films, not the films with the best martial arts.  Now, the quality of the martial arts in the movie can elevate the whole film, but it is the whole film that is being judged.   

So here is the list:

10. The Matrix

The Matrix Poster.jpg

When the original Matrix was released it was a feast for the eyes.  One of the things that made the action soar wasn't just the CGI, but the outstanding martial arts fights between Neo and Morpheus as well as Neo and Agent Smith.  The former is particularly fun to watch as we see the different styles of fighting cycle through Neo's arsenal as the fight progresses.

9. Kung Fu Panda

Kungfupanda.jpg

I thought this was going to be a cheap PIXAR knock-off, but it is one of my favorite animated films.  Not only it is beautifully directed, but the use of martial arts as a theme about gaining self-respect was very well done.

8. The Karate Kid

Karate kid.jpg

One of the reasons that this was such a big hit when it came out was that it showed how the martial arts can give you power.  But this power was not like that of Cobra Kai, where it was simple force.  It gave Daniel power over his life through strength of character.  And the amazing performance by Pat Morita makes this movie incredibly rewatchable.


7. Rapid Fire

Rapid fire ver1.jpg

This is pure B-movie fodder except for the fact that Brandon Lee fills this movie with some of my favorite action sequences of this era.  You can see in him a cross between his father Bruce's intensity and the innovativeness of someone like Jackie Chan.  This should have been the opening salvo in a fantastic film career.

6. Invincible Shaolin

What makes this movie work so well is that the villains aren't villains.  In this Shaw Brothers classic, our South Shaolin heroes train to take revenge against the North Shaolin men they think murdred their friends.  Not only are the training sequences and fights so well done, but the build up to the actual final showdowns has real tension and stakes.

5. Kid with the Golden Arm

KidWithTheGoldenArm.jpg


This movie was my first experience of a Shaw Brothers film and it is the lens through which I see all other movies from this studio.  A security group must escort gold to an area hit by famine, but the deadly Chi Sa gang plans to steal it along the way.  The heroes and villains are so colorful, that this could easily be a superhero film with names like "Golden Arm," "Silver Spear," and "Iron Robe."  And Agent Hai Tao is one of my favorite on screen heroes.  He is a deeply intelligent and pensive person who masks his inner pain with alcohol and buffoonery.  But when the time comes, he unleashes all of his power.  And through all the over-the-top action there is a hidden murder mystery.

4. Deadly Strike


I do not enjoy this movie.  It is a bit too dark for me.  But I have to admit that it is excellent.  Bruce Li plays a police chief who is tasked with taking down an organized crime boss.  However, the job is a suicide mission.  So he gives pardons to deadly criminals in exchange for their help.  This is a movie with real stakes as the roguish characters you come to love face fatal challenges along the way, making it clear that most of them are not going to get out of this alive.  This also is Bruce Li's best movie and plays to his stoic strengths when he isn't trying to be a Bruce Lee imitator.

3. Enter the Dragon

Enter the dragon.jpg

There is a reason this movie broke through the way it did.  It has an aesthetic that is still deeply rooted in the 1970's.  However, rather than this being a detriment, it feels like a window into the past.  You can see Bruce Lee's complete command of the screen and why this movie made him an international star.

2. The Chinese Connection 

FistofFuryHongKongposter.jpg

Originally titled Fist of Fury, the name was changed for an American release.  This is easily Bruce Lee's best film.  It has his best action sequences, including the classic scene where he takes on an entire dojo of karate fighters.  This is a story of revenge and as such has deadly and violent consequences.  In the end, you can see how his quest of vengeance removes all joy, with just a sliver of hope for the future.  But the final seconds of the movie always get me.

1. Death Chamber

Shaolin temple poster.jpg

It took me years to track down this film because it is known by several names.  But this is THE martial arts epic.  Set in the Shaolin Temple, this movie follows an ensemble cast as they enter into the ways of mastering different styles of Kung Fu until it all builds with an invasion of soldiers.  Rather than the fights being struggles for victory, they are intense battles for survival.  Or if survival is impossible, then the fight becomes taking out as many enemies as possible to give your friends a chance to survive.  I would put this movie up against any other action epic.

Saturday, November 13, 2021

Trailer Time: Being the Ricardos



Something you need to understand is that my family consists of I Love Lucy fanatics.  Our mother raised us on this show.  As my sister very lovingly points out, anyone in our family can relate our life experience somehow to I Love Lucy.

Many years ago, they made a TV movie called Lucy and Desi: Before the Laughter.  It looked cheap and it was over-the-top melodramatic.  This looks like they hired A-list actors and this is spearheaded by talented writer/director Aaron Sorkin.

And honestly, this looks so much worse than that TV movie.

It is understandable when a biopic cannot find someone who looks and sounds exactly like the person they are playing.  But when you take on the role of television icons, the visuals and voices matter so much more.

Because of this, my biggest issue is the casting.  Javier Bardem looks and sounds nothing like Desi Arnaz.  I don't see any of the wide-eyed masculine, yet boyish charm in him.  Nicole Kidman reaches some connection to Lucille Ball, but these seem like small moments.  Although I do have to say that even though JK Simmons does not look like William Frawley, there is something in the way he is carrying himself that feels right.

The other big problem I have is that this movie seems to be taking the most uninteresting approach to these TV pioneers: politics.  The trailer implies that Lucille Ball is caught in some kind communism scandal.  But this carries little-to-no interest to me.  At least Before the Laughter tried to take a more complete picture of their life and their relationship.  Being the Ricardos looks like it is taking a page from Lincoln by focusing on one particular time in their lives to give us a window into their character.  That is fine, but a political angle worked in Lincoln, but doesn't really work for Being the Ricardos.  I get the feeling that we are being set up for a big lecture about how Hollywood stars and producers have to stand up and speak truth to power and political blah blah blah.

This movie also seems to make the same mistake that Before the Laughter made.  It is true that Lucy and Desi had an incredibly volatile and dramatic relationship.  But that is not why we love them.  It may be why people still remember Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor, but it isn't the case for the couple from I Love Lucy.  

We love them because they made us laugh.  

And even after all these years they are still there on our televisions making us laugh.

I don't see a lot of laughter coming from Being the Ricardos.

But I could be wrong.  I hope I am wrong.  I will be very happy if I am wrong.

Thoughts?

Tuesday, November 9, 2021

New Evangelizers Post: Guard Against Casual Cruelty

           


 


I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  


I was reflecting on the Parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus. It began like this:

“There was a rich man who was dressed in purple and fine linen and lived in luxury every day. At his gate was laid a beggar named Lazarus, covered with sores and longing to eat what fell from the rich man’s table. Even the dogs came and licked his sores.” (Luke 16:19-21). The story continues where both the rich man and Lazarus die. The rich man goes to hell and Lazarus goes to heaven.

There are many fruitful reflections we can gain from this story, but I wanted to focus on these first three verses. What I find so fascinating and terrifying about these sentences is that it sets up why the rich man is condemned. Notice that it does not say that the rich man beat Lazarus or mocked him. It does not even imply that the rich man stole from Lazarus or commit any other kind of harm to him.

The rich man goes to hell because he ignores Lazarus.

We could enter into a discussion about charity and taking care of the poor, but I think we should examine the broader implications. I wonder if the rich man had any idea of how he was failing to live up to his responsibilities towards his fellow man? I wonder if we are often in the same boat.

One of the ways we can do an internal gut check is to ask ourselves about our level of casual cruelty.

In this case, I am not talking about overt acts of cruelty to others. These are hard to mistake in your life. If you go out of your way to injure another person simply because of some animosity you carry, then this reflection is not for you. If you get a thrill of victory and triumph when you drag others down, then you have a different set of problems than those addressed here. I am often amazed at how some people go out of their way to injure others. In the men’s room at my school, I will often see pencils, gum, and even bottles in the urinals. Someone went out of their way to make the life of the custodian that much more frustrating. I find it hard to comprehend someone seeking joy in this kind of pain. Or if you dig through someone’s social media posts just to find ways to hurt or condemn or cancel them, then these words are not addressed to you.

What I want to talk about are the ways in which we are cruel and may not know it.

One of the most basic social concepts is that of in-group/out-group. We are constantly wanting to be on the inside of a social group and not on the outside. Inside that group we have a circle of people to whom we attach. Once in the group, we fear being placed outside.

CS Lewis wrote about this in-group, he called “the inner ring.” Lewis stated:

“There are what correspond to passwords, but they are too spontaneous and informal. A particular slang, the use of particular nicknames, an allusive manner of conversation, are the marks. But it is not so constant. It is not easy, even at a given moment, to say who is inside and who is outside. Some people are obviously in and some are obviously out, but there are always several on the borderline.”

We constantly desire to be on the inside. As a result, we often seek to differentiate ourselves from those outside. It becomes incredibly easy to casually cast aspersions on people outside the group, to focus on their flaws, or to gossip about them. How often have you and your friends found yourselves bonding over the foibles of those outside of the group. Sometimes we justify it by couching it in legitimate grievances. For example, someone at work may be short with his fellow co-workers, so you and others begin to make fun of him behind his back. It is amazing how quickly talking about legitimate issues that need to be addressed can devolve into petty meanness. But we have to be careful about this.

And very often we don’t see how we are being cruel because our cruelty falls on those outside the group.

Sometimes our cruelty is like the rich man’s in that we become blind to the needs of others. Every day I interact with hundreds of people. It is difficult to be strongly attuned to every person’s need. And yet I often fail to notice things that I should. As a teacher, one of my biggest failings is not giving attention to the students who shrink away in class. My focus is often on those who are either highly engaged or highly disruptive. But to the quiet student who needs the positive attention of a teacher, I often fail to reach out. And ignoring someone who is in need, like Lazarus, is a type of cruelty.

The problem with these types cruelties is that they often escape our notice. And like any disease that is left unchecked, it can grow and become malignant, as it did in the case of the rich man.

So what are we to do?

You can read the whole article h    ere.




Sunday, November 7, 2021

Sunday Best: Top 10 Favorite Queen Songs

 Queen is one of the greatest rock bands of all time.  

If you look at the list of hits that have been able to stand the test of time, then you can attest to the power of their song-writing abilities.

Now, I am not a music guy.  I love music, but I do not have a keen, discerning ear.  I cannot speak to all of the complexities that go into composing a good song.  As a result, this list is not the Top 10 Best Queen Songs, but Top 10 Favorite Queen Songs.  

I did a post a few years ago about the best Queen songs in movies.  This was a bit more objective and it fell into my wheelhouse of film.  But ABC television did a lot with Queen music this week, so I thought I would share my favorite songs and why.


10. "One Vision"

A bold ballad that makes you feel like flying (maybe that's because I always associate it with Iron Eagle.


9. "Flash Gordon Theme"

I love this movie so much.  I know it is cheesy, but it has a special place in my heart.  The sound of the music's bass always gets me excited for adventure.  I love the complete commitment that the band has to this song.  When they sing Flash's name it is followed by a scream of ecstasy and then a hyperbolic statement like "He'll save everyone of us."  Not just some of us.  Not just most of us.  Every. One. Of. Us!  And Queen does not play this with any kind of humor, but with zealous devotion.

8.  "We Will Rock You"

I have fond memories of this song as people in school would stomp and chant it.  It always felt like a song where it wasn't just the band singing, but we were part of the song too.

7. "Princes of the Universe"

With Queen you either get the ecstatic highs or crushing despair. This is a song about being on top of the world, feeling like the whole universe was made just for you.  This is a song to sing while speeding down the highway after a victory: "I have no rival!  No man can be my equal!"

6. "Who Wants to Live Forever"

And then we crash into despair with this song.  Filled with melancholy grief and loss, it describes a life that is empty and devoid of any joy.  This is a song to play in a dark room with the blinds closed after a break up.

5. "Bohemian Rhapsody"

I love the way this song had a second life in the 90's thanks to Wayne's World, which is when I discovered it.  There is something incredibly fun about its odd shifts in musical tone throughout.  You feel like you are able to live through the entire emotional gamut by the time you are through.

4. "We Are the Champions"

I love how this song starts off slow.  It begins with a sense of reflection and relief that builds into the realization of victory.  It's a song that acknowledges the long, hard road that we all have to take in order to achieve the things you dream of.  I love how it is a communal song: "WE are the champions, my friends."  It's a song about making it to victory together.  

3. "Don't Stop Me Now."

The more I hear this song, the more it brings me joy.  Yes, the lyrics a bit on the bawdy side, where he sings about being a "sex-machine."  But there is something about once the song takes off it captures the exhilaration of letting yourself go and being in the moment.

2. "Under Pressure."

A friend of mine said that this might be one of the greatest songs ever written, and I don't disagree.  For me, what makes it work is how it builds to those last lyrics.  The music converges as if trying to break through the despair it has created by clinging to hope that love can save.  And I adore how the lyrics say that love dares us to change our way of caring.  Love always calls us to shake loose our complacency and reach out to those on the edge of the night.

1. "'39"

I know this will be an odd choice for many people, as this is not one of Queen's most popular songs.  But it is so odd in their collection.  It is a completely acoustic ballad that tells a complete story about interstellar travel. But rather than getting bogged down in the sci-fi nature of it, the song is a tragedy: the story of love lost to the ravages of time.  That last verse always sticks with me:

"Don't you hear my call, though you're many years away?  Don't you hear me calling you?  All your letters in the sand cannot heal me like your hand.  For my life still ahead, pity me."


Honorable Mentions: Another One Bites the Dust, It's a Kind of Magic, Gimme the Prize, I Want to Break Free, Keep Yourself Alive, Radio Ga-Ga, and Somebody to Love


Thoughts?

Monday, November 1, 2021

Trailer Time: The Book of Boba Fett



I was surprised how many people online are panning this trailer.  

Admittedly, it doesn't give a lot of details, but it really only a teaser.

The biggest complaint I've seen is in trying to turn Boba Fett into a hero.  It seems clear to me that this show is setting him up to be an anti-hero.  The Mandalorian tried the same thing, but his connection to the child quickly changed him into quickly from anti-hero to hero.  I don't see that happening as quickly with Boba Fett.

I think the worry is that this how will tame him a bit too much.  One of the characters great appeals is that he was dangerous.  He was smart and deadly.  The trailer seemed to show both those elements.  I like the idea of him trying to carve out a piece of the Tatooine underworld.

For me, the atmosphere is selling me.  The first shot of the B'Omarr monk immediately made me nostalgic for the book Tales From Jabba's Palace.  That was a wonderful book of short stories about the lives of the characters around the Hutt's criminal enterprise.  I'm hoping for something similar with The Book of Boba Fett.

Thoughts?

Saturday, October 30, 2021

Film Review: Dune (2021)

 




(Thank you again for your patience this month, Dear Reader.  In addition to the time constraints mentioned earlier this month, we had a family health emergency which has required frequent visits to medical facilities.  Your continued patience with updates is greatly appreciated.)


Sexuality/Nudity Acceptable
Violence Mature
Vulgarity Acceptable
Anti-Catholic Philosophy Mature


Dune is one of the most beautifully shot films I have seen in a long while.  Visually, it reminds me most of Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings trilogy.  It has a sweeping grandeur that not only shows you epic vistas, but it makes you feel like something grand and momentous is happening right before your eyes.  Seeing Dune is a real cinematic experience.


The story of Dune is difficult to explain.  Frank Herbert's novel is an incredibly complex tapestry of sci-fi, fantasy, politics, and prophecy.  The story centers around Paul Atreides (Timothee Chalamet).  He is the son of Duke Leto Atreides (Oscar Isaac) and his consort Lady Jessica (Rebecca Ferguson).  They are the royal house of the planet Caladan.  There are several rival houses in the galactic empire, include House Harkonnen (the enemy of the Atreides), who are led by Baron Vladimir (Stellan Skarsgard).  The Harkonnens have controlled the desert planet Arrakis.  As barren and violent as this world is, it is the most important because it is the only world where they have the Spice Melange which not only has psychic and longevity properties but is what makes interstellar travel possible.  

At the beginning of the movie, the Emperor has ordered House Atreides to take over Arrakis.  However, this is a trap for Duke Leto and his family.  On Arrakis, they will have to deal with assassination plots, gigantic sandworms, and hostile natives called the Fremen.  Helping House Atredies are warriors Duncan Idaho (Jason Mamoa), "mentat" (which means someone with a brain like a computer) Thufir Hawat (Stephen McKinley Henderson), and head of security Gurney Halleck (Josh Brolin).  

On top of this, Lady Jessica belongs to a mystical order called the Bene Gesserit, who have been trying to bring about a prophesied messiah.  And this messiah may or may not be Paul.

That is a lot for any audience to process, but director Denis Villeneuve does a fantastic job of balancing everything in a way that is not overwhelming.  To again bring up Jackson's Lord of the Rings, both directors knew how to use the complicated backstory to lay down a lived-in world with a rich history in which characters can richly explore the story space.

The first half of the movie moves with some wonderful tension.  You can feel the noose tightening around the Atreides family.  Villeneuve takes this world seriously enough for you to feel the gravity of everything that is happening.  Compare this to David Lynch's awful 1986 version of the film and you can feel immeadiately a difference in the love for the story.

I can understand if some people think the film takes itself too seriously.  There is no winking at the camera like we see in Marvel films.  The only real humor comes from Duncan Idaho.  Everything else is treated with the seriosness of a Shakespearean tragedy.

The performances are excellent.  I think that I have now become a fan of Chalamet, rather against my will.  After watching his charming turn in Little Women and now his excellent work in Dune, I see now what other big-name directors have seen.  He is able to play the contradiction that is Paul: he is caught between childhood and manhood, between innocence and wisdom, between power and powerlessness.  Vileneuve makes sure to surround Paul with exceedingly masculine men to show his smallness.  But Chamalet uses every ounce of his charisma to push through this physical limitation to command every scene he is in.

Isaac plays a stubborn nobility that rages against the inherent dishonesty surrounding him.  Ferguson does a great job of someone who has spent their entire life in control of their emotions, so that when her fear overwhelms her it forces the audience to feel that fear as well.  I was surprised how much I enjoyed the subtley of Skarsgard's evil.  He is able to convey a lot of malice with a simple tone of voice.  Brolin does a good job, along with other actors Javier Bardem, Sharon Duncan-Brewster, Chang Chen, David Dastmalchian, and Zendeya.  But Momoa is absolutely the standout.  If there is a Han Solo to Dune it is Duncan Idaho.  He has a devil-may-care charisma while making you feel his absolute loyalty.  If there is any one character you want to be from this movie, it is Duncan.

The movie tackles some big themes like fate, free-will, violence, power, cultural clashes, etc.  To the movie's credit it does not try to dumb down this challenges but invites the audience to enter into the complexity.

The movie does have some flaws.  The biggest one is that the second half is not paced well.  The most intense parts of the movie are in the middle and then Paul's journey requires the entire plot to slow down and it involves a number of sequences of vague visions.  

Another issue is that there is a slight emotional distance to the story.  There are some great moments in the beginning of real pathos, like with Leto tells Paul that all he ever has to be his is son.  But as most people play nobles who are constantly playing diplomacy and politics, there is a formality to everyting that is a little cold.  And as Paul becomes more hardened, this becomes even more true as the story unfolds.  

Finally, as transportive as Hans Zimmer's score is, this movie does what Tenet did where the music and soundscapes drown out the dialogue sometimes.  This may be the effect that is intended, but it makes for a frustrating experience.

Vileneuve has done an incredible job.  He understands what great science fiction films are supposed to do: transport you to a bold and epic universe only experience in the imagination and on the big screen.


Monday, October 25, 2021

New Evangelizers Post: Analogies and the Trinity

          


 


I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  


The Trinity is at the heart of the Christian Faith.

We Christians believe that God is the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. We do not believe in three gods. Like our Jewish ancestors in faith, we are monotheists, who hold only to One True God.

But each Person of the Trinity is truly distinct. The Father is not the Son and the Son is not the Father and neither are the Holy Spirit. And yet even though they are Three Persons, they are still only One God.

To say that this is difficult to understand would be an understatement. In fact, it is impossible to understand. That is because this is one of the three great mysteries of the Christian faith (the other two being the Incarnation and Salvation). A mystery is something that is beyond human comprehension. It is not that the subject of the mystery is irrational or contradicts reason. Instead, a mystery is something that is so infinitely profound that it cannot possibly be encompassed by our limited human intellects.

Very often, people try to explain the Trinity using analogies. They look for common examples that people find familiar and transpose that to the mystery of Trinity. The most famous story fo this is St. Patrick and the shamrock. The story goes that Patrick was having trouble getting the pagan Irish to understand the Trinity. But then he picked up a shamrock and showed it to them. He pointed out how it was three leaves but also one leaf. In that way, the Irish people could see three and one existing in the same substance and thus became open to the concept of Trinity.

Now as wonderful as that story is, we have to be careful that we don’t confuse the analogy with the mystery.

I’ve often had to teach about the Trinity and the temptation is often to oversimply things so that my students can wrap their heads around it. The human mind is very uncomfortable with things that it cannot understand. I can see some of my students become cynical and dismissive. They want to write off the Trinity as a superstitious holdover of a bygone age. So to draw them in, I like using analogies because they are then able to see how some of the truths of the Trinity could be real.

The problem is that all of the analogies break down. And they break down pretty quickly.

For example, the Shamrock analogy ultimately doesn’t work because it implies that each Person of the Trinity is one-third of the whole, which is not the case.

When I was in high school, one of my teachers said that the Trinity was like H2O. It is one molecular substance. But we experience it in three radically different ways: as water, as ice, and as vapor. I have also used this analogy because it is very concrete. I take a bottle of water and I hold it over a student’s head. I ask them what will happen if I empty the contents on the bottle on head. They reply that they will get wet. When I ask them if it will hurt, they tell me “no.” But then I grab a bottle of water that I left in the freezer over night so that it is a solid block of ice. I ask the student if it would hurt if I emptied the contents on the bottle on their head and they say “yes.”

“But,” I respond, “Didn’t we just establish that dumping H2O on your head wouldn’t hurt?”

They respond, “But that was water. This is ice!”

“Yet it is still H2O, isn’t it? It hasn’t changed its molecular composition?”

“No.”

“So ice is not water and water is not ice, but they are still one thing: H2O.”

I can see my students eyes light up as they think they begin to understand. But I am quick to point out that the analogy breaks down. This analogy could give the impression that each Person of the Trinity is just another way to experience the same being. In other words, these are just different names for the same substance. But this is not the case. As stated earlier, the Father is not the Son and neither are the Holy Spirit.

The temptation with teaching analogies like these is that they reduce the mystery into a digestible and understandable example that does not challenge the mind too much. But the true mystery should cause the mind to stretch and reach and ultimately come to the place where it has to accept Trinity not as a concept that has been demonstrably been proven, but as belief to which you surrender in faith.

The Athanasian Creed sums it up beautifully when it says:

That we worship one God in Trinity and the Trinity in unity,
neither blending their Persons
nor dividing their essence.
For the Person of the Father is a distinct Person,
the Person of the Son is another,
and that of the Holy Spirit still another.
But the divinity of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit is one,
their glory equal, their majesty coeternal.

You can read the whole article h    ere.