ReasonForOurHope

Tuesday, July 16, 2019

Film Review: Stuber



Sexuality/Nudity Mature
Violence Mature
Vulgarity Mature
Anti-Catholic Philosophy Mature

Stuber is a difficult movie to review not because it was amazingly good or horribly bad.  Instead, it was exceedingly average.  For that reason, it is difficult to be passionate about anything in the movie one way or another.

The movie is about Vic Manning (David Bautista) who is after a very dangerous drug dealer who got away six months earlier.  On the day that he gets Lasik surgery, Vic gets a tip as to a big bust going down.  Since he cannot see, he orders and Uber driven by Stu (Kumail Nanjiani): hence the title: Stuber.  Stu desperately needs a five-star rating or he will lose his Uber job, so he goes along with Vic's increasingly insane demands.  All the while, Stu wants to get together with Becca (Betty Gilpen), with whom he is stuck in the friend-zone.  Vic wants to get his bad guy, but he also wants to make sure his estranged daughter Nicole (Natalie Morales) is kept safe.  Each step of the journey gets crazier and crazier until it all comes to a head.

All of the plot points are fine and by the numbers.  The action sequences are adequate.  The jokes are average, with some clever lines here and there.  But there is nothing about this movie that is very memorable.  

That is a shame, because the cast is actually very good.  Bautista carries the movie a lot more than I was expecting.  He is a brutal action tank, but his line delivery is spot on for the humor.  He also plays Vic like a real, three-dimensional character instead of a bland stereotype.  That doesn't stop him from going extremely hyper-masculine, but Bautista makes it work.  Nanjiani is also very likable in his role of Beta Male, metro-sexual.  He is a great yin to Bautista's yang.  Their completely opposite personalities and physiques give the movie all the energy that it has.  Morales comes off as very cool and grounded.  Gilpen does have strong comedic talents, but is only allowed to show them off a bit in the first act.  Other than that, she is very underused.

The movie wants to say something about Vic's hyper-masculinity, but for the most part it is a commentary on Stu's lack of masculinity.  As Stu gets dragged from horrible situation to horrible situation, he constantly has to dig a little deeper and man up.  Stu tries to get Vic to be a bit more sensitive, especially regarding his daughter, and there is movement here.  Yet it seems strange to me the turnabout.  I try not to let anything outside of the movie enter my review, but I heard a little bit of an interview with Nanjiani about how this movie was going to rip on the narrow ways traditional masculinity is defined.  I took this to mean that Vic would be the butt of most of the humor.  But the final product produced the opposite effect in me.  Vic was brave and driven.  Stu was weak and feckless.  The entire film had me wishing Stu would become more like Vic and not vice versa.

Still, the message did not distract from the movie because I took most of it to be Stu's cowardly ravings.  Director Michale Dowse does an adequate job of telling the story.  The opening action scene offers a nice glimpse into his talents visually, especially in the scene where Vic jumps from a balcony.  But that spark never really builds into a flame in this movie.  Perhaps all involved would have produced a better film with a better script or punchier jokes.  It gets a bit raunchy at times, visiting male strip clubs and the like, but most of the explicitness is in the dialogue.

It wouldn't be a stretch to say that I enjoyed my time in the theater watching Stuber.  I like the actors enough to want to see them in other films.  But the memory of the movie began to fade as soon as the credits rolled.


Monday, July 15, 2019

Film Review: Godzilla - King of the Monsters



Sexuality/Nudity Acceptable
Violence Acceptable
Vulgarity Acceptable
Anti-Catholic Philosophy Acceptable

I have found that die-hard Godzilla fans are their own sub-culture.  I don't say this in any way as an insult.  But from the outside looking in, Godzilla is just another classic movie monster.  But on the inside, there is a rich history and tradition with a level of complexity that I find quite astonishing.  

This is why whenever you review a Godzilla film, you have discern if the movie made for Godzilla fans or for general audiences.  There can, of course, be overlap between both, but each film seems either to be expecting the audience to already Godzilla devotees or else the movie acts as an ambassador to non-Godzilla fans.

Writer/Director Michael Dougherty made a movie for Godzilla fans.

Godzilla: King of the Monsters is a follow-up to often maligned 2014 Godzilla remake.  Both movies take place in the same cinematic universe as 2017's Kong: Skull Island.  A group of scientists led by Dr. Emma Russell (Vera Farmiga) have found a way to awaken the titanic monsters: in this case Mothra.  They do this with the use of special device called "The Orca."  However, Emma and her daughter Madison are taken by Alan Jonah (Charles Dance), the leader of an environmental terrorist group.  The monster experts at the organization known as Monarch, led by Dr. Ishiro Serizawa (Ken Watanabe), seek out Emma's husband Mark (Kyle Chandler) to help them track down Emma and the Orca before more monsters awake.  As this occurs, Godzilla stirs and seeks to restore his dominance over the other monsters.

What works about this movie is that it does a much better job of taking us ring-side into the big monster fights.  One of the biggest criticisms of the 2014 film was that director Gareth Edwards would often cut away from the action when it became interesting and he would choose to view the combat from the least interesting perspective.  While this new Godzilla film often films the action from the point of view of the humans, it focuses a lot more of its time on letting us see these fights play out.  The special effects are very good and fill you with a sense of our own smallness in the face of these gargantuan creatures.  Doughtery knows how to use his monsters to build up tension and then release it in a cathartic explosion.  There is a sequence towards the middle of the film with the fire creature Rodan that is as exciting as anything I have ever seen in a Godzilla film.

The movie also does a good job of presenting Godzilla himself as a character without making him too relatable or too human.  Godzilla is terrifying to all the humans, but he is less terrifying than the more destructive monsters like King Ghidorah.  It reminds me of a line from The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, where the Beavers caution the children about the mighty Aslan: "He's not a tame lion."  There is nothing tame about this Godzilla.  The movie draws the fine line between awe, respect, and fear of the great monster.

The script is better than most Godzilla movies I have seen, but it still isn't very good.  The dialogue is stilted and unnatural.  The human characters are painted flatly, with little to make us feel connected to them.  Particularly annoying is Mark, who is very much a Mary Sue in this movie.  With the exception of his intense drive to kill Godzilla, Mark constantly makes out of left-field suggestions that almost always turn out to be right.  Yet there is almost no reason that anyone at Monarch should listen to anything he say.  The script also has the same problem as most Godzilla films: we really don't care about the human story.  There is a thematic subplot about broken families, but it feels like a distraction from the monster fights.

The performances are fine, but most are nothing spectacular.  A few exceptions are Watanabe, who brings a noble reverence to his relationship to Godzilla, and he has one of the best scenes in the film.  Dance always carries with him strength and dark charisma.  But almost no one else makes an impression, even established actors like Bradley Whitford, David Strathairn, or Ziyi Zhang.  They do what they can with their parts, but they don't have much to work with.

I found it very interesting that the main villains were environmental extremists.  Pope Francis emphasized care for the planet in his encyclical Laudato Si, but I have noticed a strain of misanthropy in some environmental movements.  These groups talk about humanity as a blight on the planet and that we have to preserve other life instead of human life.  This is such a diabolical flip to the words of God in Genesis when He told us to fill the Earth and subdue it.  This corruption is understandable in a society where we de-emphasize God.  Humans need to have their actions directed to a higher cause.  Without God, many would look to the world to give them meaning, but they fall into the trap St. Paul warned of:  "For they exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and worshiped and served the creature rather than the Creator, who is blessed forever. Amen.  " (Romans 1:25)

But never explores the issue too terribly deeply.  The movie is there to show us fantastic monster destruction.  And if that is what you want, Godzilla: The King of the Monsters will satisfy.


Saturday, July 13, 2019

Film Flash: Stuber


15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)

An average buddy cop comedy with very likable leads.  Not bad, but not great.

Friday, July 12, 2019

Terminator is the New Ghostbusters

Terminator Dark Fate poster.jpg

A beloved 80's film with sequels.

A devoted fan base.

A modern remake with mostly women leads.

A trailer that most people found terrible.

Filmmakers attacking the fans as sexist for not liking the trailer.

This is what we saw with the bomb that was 2016's Ghostbusters and now it looks as though Terminator: Dark Fate is following in the same footsteps.

I want to say at the outset that I have no idea if T:DF is good or bad.  The following analysis has no bearing on the actual final product.  We saw echoes of something similar with Captain Marvel's promotions, but that turned out to be a fairly good movie. 

The thing that needs to be addressed is how the T:DF like Ghostbusters are adopting a strategy of antagonism towards potential customers rather than trying to win them over.

In a recent interview with Variety, director Tim Miller discussed the action lead played by Mackenzie Davis.  He said of her: "If you’re at all enlightened, she’ll play like gangbusters. If you’re a closet misogynist, she’ll scare the f–k out of you, because she’s tough and strong but very feminine. "  There is a heavy problem with his logic and his implications if you do not like the character he has created.

Let us take a look at his first syllogism.  Forgive this slightly technical digression on syllogisms.  I fear that it may come off as techno-babble, but I could not think of a way to make my point clear and avoid it.

There are parts to a hypothetical syllogism, the antecedent (IF statement), the consequent (THEN statement), the affirmation or denial of the consequent or antecedent, and then the conclusion
:
-IF: You are enlightened -THEN: You will love this character
-I do not like
-THEREFORE: I am not enlightened.

This is a valid syllogism where by denying the consequent then the premise must be false.  He is stating that his character is such a clear and shining example of a great film character, that if you do not like that you are not only lacking in taste but are morally flawed or unenlightened. 

In the next syllogism, affirming the consequent doesn't prove the antecedent.  So she could scare the you-know-what out of you for reasons other than the antecedent.  But what I find fascinating is his use of the adjective "closet."  Without that adjective, the statement is straightforward and makes sense.  Misogynists hate women and the lead actress is a woman so it would make sense that they would not like her.  But the added qualifier implies that someone who hates the character and shows no outward signs of misogyny is actually a closeted misogynists.

This is similar to a particularly distasteful idea known as "dog-whistling," which means that someone could say something that is on the surface innocuous, but it has hidden meanings that are communicated.  In this case, "I hate this character" is taken as a dog-whistle for "Women are bad."  The reason I find this type of implication so distasteful is that it eliminates the meaning of words.  How can I defend against a charge of dog-whistle misogyny if my arguments defending myself can be interpreted as more dog-whistles.  Instead of people trying to discover the meaning of each other's statements, the way Socrates would do, we would now simply place whatever meaning we judge on top of the words of another.  Anything you say to me can be a compliment or an insult depending on my judgment of you.

And this seems to be what Miller is doing to people who do not like what they have seen so far of T:DF.  Don't like my character?  Then you are an unenlightened potential misogynist.

Can someone please explain to me how this type of promotion is supposed to increase ticket sales?  The cast and crew of Ghostbusters came hard at their critics and the movie bombed.  Why would you poison the well like this and what is the alternative?

I remember when it was announced that Joaquin Phoenix was cast to play the new Joker.  I thought it was a terrible idea.  I'm sure that there were other skeptics online as well.  I do not recall how vocal any of them were.  But then they released the first teaser and I was mesmerized.  If people didn't believe that Phoenix could pull of the character, the point of the teaser was to show you how amazingly he embodied the character in body, voice, and performance. 

In other words, Joker won me over.  I am now very excited to see this movie.

People are skeptical about this new Terminator.  The last three were also not well-received.  The fact that Miller is making a preemptive strike ad hominem strike against his critics tells me that he is not confident about his work and is not convinced that it will be popular. 

I wish Miller and the Terminator franchise all of the best and I truly hope that it is a good movie.

But Miller shouldn't assume that people who don't like his movie have a character flaw.

It could just be that the movie has a flawed character.

Thursday, July 11, 2019

Film Review: Aladdin (2019)





Sexuality/Nudity No Objection
Violence Acceptable
Vulgarity No Objection
Anti-Catholic Philosophy Acceptable


I am not someone who is opposed to the concept of live-action remakes.  In fact, I am one of the few people who think the modern Beauty and the Beast is an improvement on the animated version.  But with Aladdin, there is an incredibly big problem with any attempt to recapture the magic: Robin Williams.

Williams once said that Aladdin was a Looney Tunes cartoon in "Disney drag," meaning that even though it was under the Disney name it had an insane aesthetic like Bugs Bunny and Daffy Duck.  But that is only true with Williams as the Genie.  Without him, you are left with a pleasant and enjoyable fairy tale, but far from a classic.

Aladdin is the story of the title character (Mena Massoud) who falls in love with the strong-willed Jasmine (Naomi Scott), but he is forced into the Cave of Wonders by the evil Jafar (Marwan Kenzari) where he finds and befriends the Genie (Will Smith).  Most of the story follows the original, though writer John August and co-writer/director Guy Ritchie are much more efficient at introducing the characters and setting up the story.

The big question is whether or not Smith can replace Williams.  The answer is a simple "no."  But that isn't really fair to Smith, who is not trying to mimic anything about William's mad comedic genius.  Instead, the Genie is a hyper-stylized version of the Will Smith persona.  In this way it absolutely works.  It isn't nearly as funny, but Smith has enough charisma to keep us watching.  Underneath it, he actually layers some of the more heartfelt moments with some actual depth.  But it is his swagger and magnetic personality that make his anachronistic style work so well on screen.

The other performances are decent.  Massoud has near-perpetual smirk on his face for most of the film that is more annoying than endearing.  But the further the film goes, the more you get used to him.  The chemistry between him and Smith as well as him and Scott is excellent.  Scott is wonderful as Jasmine, sharp and strong.  But they go a bit overboard in the script to emphasize the "girl power" aspects of her character.  Kenzari does a nicely understated Jafar, making him intelligent a little bit cool.  Nasim Pedrad is a nice addition as Jasmine's handmaid Dalia and provides some nice comedic moments.

The best parts of the movie are the song and dance numbers.  If you put up a sceptical wall when going to see this film, that barrier will melt away once "A Whole New World" starts.  The beauty of the song and the nostalgia factor, along with some nice staging, cannot help but lighten the heart.  Ritchie also wisely hired an excellent choreographer in Leah Hill, who infuses the live-action musical numbers with some great spectacle.  This is also evident in the chase scenes that feel very balletic and whimsically light of foot.

There is one exception to this.  For this version of the movie, they gave Jasmine her own solo power ballad: "Speechless."  While it is from the original composer of Aladdin, Alan Menken, it just doesn't seem to fit.  It feels like a 2nd-class Demi Lovato song.  The song is supposed to represent Jasmine's struggle with being taken seriously in a Middle Eastern society a thousand years ago.  But the placement of the song, especially the refrain, is less empowering and more cringy.

I found myself enjoying this film more than I expected, which is a compliment to the filmmakers for winning me over.  While it cannot match the unique magic of the original, it is a fine and enjoyable children's musical.

Wednesday, July 10, 2019

Wednesday Comics: And the Dead Shall Walk No More - The Final Issue of THE WALKING DEAD



I had stopped reading The Walking Dead comic book many years ago, just before the introduction of Negan.  While I was still impressed with the quality, the darkness of the story became a little much to bear month to month.  I've seen many people say the same about the TV series as they dip in and dip out.  Regardless, The Walking Dead has been a best selling comic for Image and was moving towards its 200th issue.

And then, to everyone's shock, Robert Kirkman ended his series without warning with issue #193. 

I was so shocked that I bought a copy just to see how it all ended.

WARNING - MAJOR SPOILERS BELOW

It is almost impossible to review this issue without giving away the current storyline and what has happened to the characters since.  I will keep as much of the contents of the final issue as secret as possible for those who haven't read it.

I will say that The Walking Dead #193 is a great final issue because it give us the thing long-time fans need the most: closure.

Even with an abrupt ending, fans of any long-time series need a chance to say goodbye to the characters on the journey.  I know many people who do not like the epilogue at the end of the Harry Potter series, but I think it is one of the finest, most necessary parts of the story.  You want to know what happens to these people with whom you have spent the last few years of your life with and you hope that everything is okay.

The final issue picks up many years after the previous one.  Carl Grimes is an adult and now married to Sophia.  They have a little girl, Andrea, who they named after Carl's stepmother.  Things have been very peaceful for the last few years.  It sounds like there have not been any major human conflicts and inside of their "safe zone" there haven't been any walking dead. 

That is until the first page of this issue.  Carl finds a zombie on his farm and kills it.  This becomes a problem, because it belongs to Hershel, Maggie and Glen's son, who uses zombies as part of his travelling stage show.  This sets Carl at odds with the law.  Throughout the course of the story, Carl comes in contact with most of the surviving characters and we get a sense of what this new world is like.

Safety and stability finally seems to have taken hold in the "safe zone" which appears to be ever expanding.  In fact, their Commonwealth has grown so large that they are about to create a new continental railroad with the "western front."  Civilization seems to be back in the world, along with a sense of law and order prevailing over the wilder days.

One of the things that makes this issue work so well is that it highlights the fact that The Walking Dead has essentially been a Western in its entire run.  Men and women on the frontier of civilization who have to face wild and scary enemies both from within and without.  Without the safety net of civilization, they had to become rough and violent, but they were filled with a strong urge towards independence and learned to trust their own moral compass.  When civilization eventually came to pacify the Wild West, it was both happy and sad.  Happy in that it became a place to raise a family and children in security.  But it was sad in that there was something of that fighting spirit that went soft and went away.

In The Walking Dead Carl can see this very thing happening.  Worse yet, those who are growing up in this time have no idea what their civilization cost them.  Rick's presence throughout the book is felt.  If you were a person living at this time, you can see how someone would look backwards and want to tell Rick's story from the beginning of civilization's fall and how he was instrumental in building the new one.  Too often those of us who live under the blanket of freedom that our country gives us do not truly appreciate the sacrifice that was needed to make my ordinary life possible.  It made me think of that powerful line from Saving Private Ryan, "Earn this."

The story also reminds us about how powerful storytelling is and how it connects us to our history.  Carl laments that his daughter can be dismissive of the history that brought them here.  But he is overjoyed that she can live in a world where she doesn't have to live in constant terror and danger.  The only thing that can bridge that gap are the stories that Carl tells.

Kirkman nailed this point completely and artists Charlie Adlard and Cliff Ranthburn drive it home with those final poignant pages.

I also couldn't help thinking about Christ during this story.  Rick Grimes is hailed as a hero who saved everyone.  In that way he is most definitely a Christ-figure, though obviously not a perfect one.  Carl can see that those for whom Rick is a real person to whom they owe their lives, that they are seeing the world with the correct eyes.  I can't help but feel the same way about Our Lord.  When I was 17, I made a retreat where it really hit home for me what it cost Him to love me.  I owe everything to Him.  Once I was able to see Him in this light, the world looked completely different. 

Carl is us.  We have been given so much and because we are still here, we have a duty to bridge the gap between those who gave us this world and those who will carry it forward.  With that deep and primal theme, along with a strong sense of closing the loop on our survivors, I would say that The Walking Dead #193 is one of the best comic book finale's I have ever read.

Tuesday, July 9, 2019

Film Review: Yesterday



Sexuality/Nudity Acceptable
Violence Acceptable
Vulgarity Acceptable
Anti-Catholic Philosophy Acceptable

"Do you want to drink from the poison chalice of money and fame?"

This is the key question behind Danny Boyle's new musical dramedy: Yesterday.

Jack Malik (Himesh Patel) is a struggling musician who is living at one England, stuck in a dead-end job and going from one pathetic gig to another with the help of his life-long friend and manager Ellie (Lily James).  Just as he decides to give up the music life forever, a world-wide blackout hits and Jack is hit by a bus.  When he wakes, he discovers that no one on Earth remembers the music of the Beatles.  So Jack decides pass off the songs as his own, thus receiving acclaim and notoriety.  He eventually is brought to the Malibu home of record producer Debra Hammer (Kate McKinnon) who asks the above question about money and fame.  The movie follows Jack's rise to stardom along with its benefits and costs.

Boyle makes a movie that is pleasant, but not great.  The script by Jack Barth and Richard Curtis make our main character likeable enough even as he attempts to deceive the world with his borrowed talent.  But honestly, without the Beatles music, this movie would score lower with viewers.  I've always espoused the belief that music is a shortcut to emotion and it can cause you to respond in ways beyond the rational.  This is the reason I think a show as horribly written as Glee became so popular so quickly.  Yesterday is not horribly written, but the music gives it a much higher elevation than it would have on its own.  If you are a fan of the Beatles, which I am, you wait with eager anticipation for which song will come next.  Unlike Across the Universe, where each song was introduced with an eye-rolling non sequitur, Yesterday finds just the right song for the right place in the story.  Hearing all the songs together will renew your appreciation for the place the band has in musical history.  Even some songs I had forgotten were given a strong spotlight.  In a scene where Jack has to go into a song-writing contest with Ed Sheeran (playing himself), we are reintroduced to "The Long and Winding Road" and how poetic and lyrical it is.  I still have "O-blah-di, O-blah-da" running through my head.

The story hinges on the romance between Jack and Ellie.  From the beginning, it is clear that Ellie is head-over-heels for Jack, who is completely oblivious.  Honestly, this was the biggest problem with the story.  My suspension of disbelief can accept a world of collective amnesia for a '60's pop group, but I draw the line at a red-blooded single man putting Lilly James in the friend-zone.  It is the plot point on which all of the story rests, but it makes no sense.  The filmmakers don't even go to the stereotype of making her look a bit frumpy.  Yes, this is a trope, but it helps create the cinematic language for the story.  They could have even done a few short scenes to give any kind of reason for Jack's lack of attraction towards Ellie.  Instead, I could not invest in this central conflict of the film, because I couldn't believe it could happen.  

However, I will say that the third act takes some nice and pleasantly surprising paths.  Just when I thought I had the movie locked-down, it introduced some new perspectives.  And there is a scene at cottage by the beach (which I will not spoil here), that was so touching it actually made me let out a little gasp.

Besides the Beatles music, the other thing that raises this film out of mediocrity are the performances of the leads.  Patel is great as Jack.  He is a flawed and temperamental artist, but he gives him enough charm and humanity for us to stay with him through his great deception.  James is also great as Ellie, effortlessly showing us her emotional range and making the audience desperate for her character to find happiness.  The rest of the supporting cast is fine, but nothing too memorable.  Ed Sheeran still has much to learn as an actor, but he did a fine job of showing the fake face of admiration that is covering a seething jealousy.  

I also enjoyed the exploration of the "poison chalice" of fame.  So many of us want to be rich and famous and yet movies like this constantly warn us against it.  I couldn't help but think of Patel and how he was playing the part of a man who learns the emptiness of fame all the while the actor is hoping this movie brings him more fame.  Can you decry the decadence of stardom while being a star?  I suppose you can, but how believable will your message be?  Regardless, I love the way the movie contrasts the two worlds of celebrity and ordinary life.  As with Spider-Man: Far From Home, there is a strong pull to the beauty of the simple things of life like love and family.  But can Jack walk away from being a legend as big as the Beatles?

You'll have to see the movie to find out.

Yesterday is not as great as it wants to be.  But it is good enough that you will enjoy the time you spend watching it and being awash in nostalgia for the Fab Four.