ReasonForOurHope

Tuesday, June 25, 2019

Film Review: Toy Story 4



Sexuality/Nudity No Objection
Violence Acceptable
Vulgarity No Objection
Anti-Catholic Philosophy No Objection


Francis Ford Coppola stated that his Godfather trilogy is misunderstood because it actually isn't a trilogy.  The first two are one complete story.  The third Godfather movie is an epilogue.  It is not meant to be the final act of the main journey.  It is there to explain the fate of the main character.

And that is how you should watch Toy Story 4.

The movie begins with a flashback to nine years earlier.  Woody (Tom Hanks) is in the midst of rescuing a struggling toy when his love, Bo Peep (Annie Potts), is sold to someone else.  This moment explains her complete absence from Toy Story 3 (which I always thought was the only thing missing from that film).  Back in the present, Bonnie (Madeleine McGraw) is getting ready for kindergarten.  She finds consolation playing with her toys: Buzz Lightyear (Tim Allen), Jessie (Joan Cusak), and the rest of the gang from the previous film, except for Woody.  In kindergarten, Bonnie decides to make a little makeshift toy out of a spork, glue, popsickle sticks, pipe cleaner, and silly eyes.  She names him Forky (Tony Hale).  Because he is made of trash, he constantly tries to throw himself away and it is up to Woody to make sure Forky is saved for Bonnie.  While on a road trip, Forky gets himself lost and Woody must leave the group to help him.  If that plot point feels very similar to other Toy Story movies, you would be right.  But the movie wisely only uses this as one of its plot points.  Their adventures lead to a dangerous antique story and carnival where Woody must look into his soul and find his life's meaning.

If that last part sounds deep and heavy, that's because it is.  But PIXAR has always masterfully been able to create stories that plum the depths of the human heart while creating a magical adventure that is accessible to all the children who watch it.  Toy Story 4 really is a movie for all ages to enjoy.

I constantly marveled at how beautiful the movie is.  Computer animated movies are a dime a dozen now.  And while the textures and the motion of most of them are top notch, technology is not a substitute for artistry.  You have to know how to use the colors and the lighting to give the movie its maximum emotional appeal.  This is the feature directorial debut for Josh Cooley, and his style fits in perfectly with all that has come before him.  And Randy Newman's score is as powerful as ever, full of adventure, joy, and sadness.

The new characters that have been added are just as wonderful as any in the franchise.  Hale's Forky is so odd and vulnerable.  He is like an alien being terrified of his own surroundings.  Ducky and Bunny (Keegan-Micahel Key and Jordan Peele) and some wonderfully aggressive humor to the adventure.  The main villain of the piece is a doll named Gabby Gabby (Christina Hendricks) who appears to be in the mold of Lotso from Toy Story 3, but whose story takes a few surprising turns.  But the best addition is Duke Caboom (Keanu Reeves), a stunt-cycle toy who has never been able to live up to the action ability promised in the commercials that advertised him.  Reeves' roles in the last few years have been so serious that I forgot that he can deliver his lines with such wonderful comedic timing.

In fact, the movie is incredibly funny.  Caboom brings a number of jokes, but the film constantly hits you jokes both spoken and visual.  My absolute favorite is a running gag about Combat Carl (Carl Weathers) in a snow suit seeking a high-five.  The film is a delight that will make you laugh, or at the very least make you smile throughout.  And as with most Toy Story films, the humor is balanced nicely against the heartache that this movie evokes.  I found myself getting excessively emotional during the film's finale as some characters said goodbye to each other, perhaps forever.

The biggest flaw in the film is a problem of focus.  This is not so much a Toy Story movie as it is a Woody movie.  While Woody and Buzz have been the main characters for the entire series, all of the other characters were incredibly important and had their own particular story arcs.  Here, everyone is used as supporting players to Woody's journey.  This is especially noticeable with Buzz.  Even though he has more screen time than most of the other toys, he really doesn't go on any journey of incredible depth.  Of course, the running gag of him listening to his "inner voice" is a great one.  But overall, I had a mild sense of disappointment that I didn't also get to spend more time with these characters I've come to love.

This is why I stated that the film should be taken like an epilogue.  Its purpose is to focus on what happens to Woody now that Andy is gone.  Woody's whole arc in Toy Story 2 was to be there for Andy until he grew up.  But that ended with Toy Story 3.  With Bonnie, Woody isn't needed.  So what does he do?

The relationship between Woody and Forky is a fantastic place of growth to explore.  Essentially, Woody becomes a dad.  Forky is like a child who is innocent but self-destructive.  Woody has to constantly pluck Forky from the jaws of death in the way that dads have to use their "dad-reflexes" to stop their children from injuring themselves.  You can see the constant wear and frustration that this has on Woody who now has to be responsible in a way that he has never had to before.

But the question lingers: what is Woody's purpose?  And even more importantly, what is his reward?  It is said that virtue is its own reward and the same can be seen in Woody's vocation to make Andy happy.  I love the way the film explores why toys are just frivolities but are actual important.  Toys are the means of bringing joy, exciting the imagination, and giving comfort and courage in times of darkness.  Woody has done all of that and he treasures those times.  But Andy is gone and Woody is still here.  Thankfully, the movie isn't simply ponderous, naval-gazing.  Woody is a toy of action and it is through he deeds that he discovers what he should do and who he should be.

The only other flaw I see in the film is the fact that Bo is constantly emasculating Woody.  Their relationship has turned more antagonistic than ever.  She has been living "in the wild" for years and has become jaded and aggressive.  She constantly berates Woody for his naivete and she consistently lectures him when he screws up.  This would be a bigger problem if Woody simply rolled over.  While he does acknowledge her leadership and value, he stays true to his optimistic attitude and challenges Bo to find the joy she has since lost.

This is not the best of the series.  But do not let that dissuade you.  If you love this world and love these characters, then this is the Toy Story four you.






Monday, June 24, 2019

New Evangelizers Post: Public Sin vs. Private Sin


I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  
Brebeuf Jesuit High School in Indiana has been at the center of a news story. One of their faculty members has entered into a same-sex “marriage.” The Archbishop of Indianapolis urged the school to dismiss the teacher for giving public scandal to Catholic teaching. Brebeuf has refused and the Archbishop has disallowed them the label of “Catholic” in his archdiocese.

Today’s article is not about this issue per se. Instead, I want to focus on a response by Fr. James Martin SJ, who took to Twitter to condemn the actions of the archdiocese. He tweeted:

“If employees’ “professional and private lives must convey and be supportive of Catholic Church teaching” that means that, to be consistent, all Catholic institutions (schools, parishes, hospitals, retreat centers) in the Archdiocese would also have to fire the following people:
1) Catholic straight individuals living with someone before being married.
2) Catholic married couples who use birth control.
3) Catholic straight individuals who are divorced and remarried without an annulment.
4) Catholic couples who use in vitro fertilization.”

He goes on, but I think we need an important clarification here on the difference between public sin and private sin.

Always the problem with public sin is that it can lead to the additional problem of scandal. We are all called to be witnesses to Christ in our lives. Because we are broken by Original Sin, we almost always fall short of that high calling. At the very least, I know that I am constantly struggling to overcome sin in my life. We are all sinners, no one disputes this. Fr. Martin sees people with same-sex attractions as being particularly hounded for their sins. To bolster his perspective, I will say that in my years teaching high school, students with same-sex attractions feel like they are being particularly singled out for any sinful behavior regarding their sexuality.

But that really isn’t the issue. The issue for the employment is not the same-sex sin as such, but the public scandal of it.

Scandal has been a serious issue from the beginning. In 1 Corinthians, Paul is furious that Christians in Corinth are suing each other in public court. He says that this gives horrible witness to the love we are supposed to have for each other. He writes:

“I say this to shame you. Can it be that there is not one among you wise enough to be able to settle a case between brothers? But rather brother goes to court against brother, and that before unbelievers? Now indeed [then] it is, in any case, a failure on your part that you have lawsuits against one another” (1 Corinthians 6:5-7)

The problem is not just that some Christians are taking things without returning them. The problem is that their brother and sister Christians are taking them to court and that this is causing scandal. This could cause confusion, frustration, and rejection of the true faith.

I had a former student who asked me if it would be okay to move in with her boyfriend as long as they were not engaging in pre-marital sex. She was a devout Catholic, but they both had trouble maintaining to two residents. I told her not to do so. Even if she was living correctly. Cohabitation of a romantically linked couple implies sexual activity. This would lead to a negative witness that sex outside of marriage was morally acceptable for Catholics, even if they themselves were not engaging in it.

In 2 Maccabees, the old man Eleazar is forced to choose between eating pork (which defies God’s Kosher laws) or death. Some of his friends sneak him some lamb meat that he can eat and pretend it is pork, thereby saving his life and not sinning. But Eleazar refuses. He says:

““At our age it would be unbecoming to make such a pretense; many of the young would think the ninety-year-old Eleazar had gone over to an alien religion. If I dissemble to gain a brief moment of life, they would be led astray by me, while I would bring defilement and dishonor on my old age.” (2 Maccabees 6:24-25)

He understands that even if he does not personally sin, the scandal could lead others astray. And that is what is at issue with Brebeuf High School. Fr. Martin is probably correct that there are many others who are not living in perfect accord with Christian morality. You will find that in any community. But a civil “marriage” is not a private matter but a public one.

We need to make a further distinction between persistent and non-persistent public sin. In a persistent public sin, a person is clearly and visibly living in defiance to Christian morality and appears to have no intention of changing. A non-persistent public sin could be some horrible offense that is past. The non-persistent kind is not what is at issue at Brebeuf. If it was discovered that, for example, a Catholic couple working at a school had engaged in fornication with each other in the past. If it was a one-time fall from grace, from which both had repented, then the scandal would be less. If that couple, instead, decided to publicly flaunt their illicit sexual relationship to the world, this would cause scandal.

At Brebeuf, it is not simply a matter of having someone who has same-sex attractions on the staff. It isn’t even a matter of someone on the staff having engaged in sexual activity with someone of the same sex. The issue is that someone on the staff is publicly and persistently engaged in sexual activity that is at odds with the Gospel message. And now we run an even greater risk, as the wise Eleazar understood, of leading many other young people into error.

I must take a few moments and speak about private sin. Please do not think that simply because scandal is attached to public sin that it is somehow less horrible than private sin. In some ways, private sin is worse for the soul.

You can read the whole article here.

Sunday, June 23, 2019

Sunday Best: TOP 10 PIXAR Movies

With the opening of Toy Story 4 a few days ago, I thought it would be appropriate to go back and rank the top 10 PIXAR films thus far.

Very few studios have maintained such high quality for so long.  Cars was the first movie that I thought was sub-par, but not bad.  And there have been others like Brave that never met their full potential.  Regardless, it is incredible to me that they are still able to make excellent films.

10.  Toy Story 4

This latest epilogue to the Toy Story trilogy is as thrilling and fun and emotional as any in the franchise.  Less of an ensemble, focusing mainly on Woody, this story explores what the hero does when they complete their mission.

9.  A Bug's Life
The poster features Flik peeking out of the leaf with the rest of the circus bugs including Francis, Dot, Heimlich, and Slim.
This was the movie that made me realize that PIXAR could be profound.  After Flick the Ant is beaten by Hopper and his hordes, he struggles to his feet and stands in defiance.  The way that scene was visually rendered was incredibly powerful and it showcased foreshadowed the depths that PIXAR would explore in the future.


8.  WALL-E
WALL-Eposter.jpg
While the rest of the movie does not live up to the first act (with the exception of the finale), the opening to WALL-E is an amazing example of brave, confident storytelling through the visuals.  We come to fall in love with our hero in this desolate world and are completely drawn in to his fascinating story.


7.  Inside Out

No one does "high concept" like PIXAR.  The fully-realized emotional world of this movie is not only incredibly funny, but has so much to say thematically about how our emotions get out of balance when as we grow up and why its okay to be sad.  It also has what is maybe the best scene in all of PIXAR when we see into the mind of the young man who bumps into our main character at a hockey game.

6.  The Incredibles
Theatrical release poster depicting the Incredibles running from an explosion
I've often said that this is the best Fantastic Four movie ever made.  It is slick and stylish while at the same time being a strong message about the importance of intact families and strong marriages.  Here, PIXAR shows us how to make real superhero films that are accessible to all ages.


5.  Toy Story
The poster features Woody anxiously holding onto Buzz Lightyear as he flies in Andy's room. Below them sitting on the bed are Bo Peep, Mr. Potato Head, Troll, Hamm, Slinky, Sergeant and Rex. In the lower right center of the image is the film's title. The background shows the cloud wallpaper featured in the bedroom.
The one that started it all is still one of the most re-watchable of the franchise.  The premise is so simple: what if our toys came to life when we weren't looking?  But more than that, it gave us a strong emotional thru-line with Woody's jealousy of Buzz and their inevitable friendship as they are forced to journey into danger together.  And that score... magic!

4.  Toy Story 2

This is superior to the first by adding the emotional complexities that will be the trademark of all the Toy Story movies going forward.  This was also the movie that made beautiful melancholy a hallmark of PIXAR with Jessie's flashback of her old owner.  That scene alone is so full of heartbreak that it is surprising that the movie is able to bring itself back.  And the airport chase at the end is thrilling!

3.  Toy Story 3
All of the toys packed close together, holding up a large numeral '3', with Buzz, who is putting a friendly arm around Woody's shoulder, and Woody holding the top of the 3.
There are many people who say that this is the greatest of all the PIXAR films and I respect that decision.  This movie takes us to the dark days forecast in the previous film, where Andy has grown up.  What are the value of the toys now?  The movie is an emotional wallop.  First, the scene at the dump is harrowing.  Watching Buzz's silent reaction when Jesse asks what they are going to do is so moving and tragic.  But the final goodbye playtime at the movie's very end perfectly captures the inescapable sadness of growing up and moving on.

2.  Monsters, Inc.
Monsters Inc.JPG
To this day there are gags in this movie that make me laugh out loud at the thought of them.  Billy Crystal and John Goodman are a pitch-perfect duo in this wonderfully inventive film that was the most beautifully rendered up until that point.  Exploring deep themes in accessible ways while nearly overdosing on cuteness with Boo, this movie is amazing up until the final perfect shot of the movie as it fades to credits.

1.  Up
A house is floating in the air, lifted by balloons. A dog, a boy and an old man hang beneath on a garden hose. "UP" is written in the top right corner.
I don't think they will ever top this film.  It is quite amazing that they built a fantastic adventure around an old, hobbled widower.  Most people remember the montage in the first act as the best part of the film.  And it is truly one of the great movie montages of all time.  But unlike WALL-E, the rest of the movie matches the excellence presented in that beginning.  With one of the best movie scores of all time, the movie has PIXAR's most beautiful imagery.  All the while the adventure touches on timeless truths about loss and relationships and letting go.  But for me, the greatest message of all is that an ordinary life filled with love is the greatest adventure there is.


Saturday, June 22, 2019

Film Flash: Toy Story 4


15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)

Toy Story franchise is four-for-four in making animated classics. Wonderful trilogy epilogue.

Film Flash: Late Night

Late Night poster.jpeg

15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)

Not bad.  But to work, movies about comedians must be extremely funny.  This isn't.

Thursday, June 20, 2019

Film Review: The Public


Sexuality/Nudity Mature
Violence Acceptable
Vulgarity Acceptable
Anti-Catholic Philosophy Acceptable


I have been a fan of Emilio Estevez for a long time.  His last film, The Way, is a thing of beauty that is insightful and inspiring with its visual beauty and thematic depth.  So I was eager to see his follow up, The Public.  Once again Estevez aims high to tell a story of importance.

Unfortunately, this movie falls short.

Estevez stars as Stuart Goodson, one of the floor managers at the Cincinnati Public Library in the downtown area.  For him, the library is almost hallowed ground.  It is a place where ideas can change people's lives.  However, most of the people around him do not see that majesty.  Mostly, Stuart's job is managing the homeless population who seek shelter in the library during operating hours.  The city is experiencing a cold snap and the shelters are pushed to capacity.  The homeless patrons led by Jackson (Michael Kenneth Williams) decide to occupy the library at closing and refuse to leave.  Stuart has choose: does he stand with the rule of law or the safety of the homeless.  That choice defines the rest of the film.

As a director, Estevez is still at the top of his game.  He makes us feel the bitter chill of the Cincinnati streets and the warmth, both literal and figurative, of the library.  He makes the location a kind of character throughout the film.

He is also fantastic at casting.  The cast includes Alec Baldwin, Taylor Schilling, Jena Malone, Gabrielle Union, Jeffrey Wright, and Christian Slater.  Wright is a particular standout as an actor who portrays all his characters with a strong sense of truth about them.  Even when he gets emotional, I never catch him "acting."  

The movie wants to use this cast and this setting to raise important and controversial questions about when morality and legality clash.  The set-up is fairly strong and the first act is fairly even-handed in its approach to the problem.  But the movie never gets to where it wants to go because of the shortcomings of the script.

In general, I am not a fan of "Christian movies."  Though I obviously am receptive to their themes, this films tend to fail artistically.  One of the main reasons this happens is that they put message over storytelling.  They are so concerned with telling you the moral of the story that they forget to tell the story well.  While they have moments of inspiration and uplift, they tend to collapse under their own moral weight because they have not built a solid story structure to support it.

And that is the case with The Public.

There is no place where this is more evident than in the villain played by Christian Slater.  The "bad guy" is a district attorney running for mayor of Cincinnati.  He cares for nothing instead of his own political ambitions and he sees the library incident as a means to bump his poll numbers.  He lies about Stuart and the protest and maligns them maliciously to the media.  As in most Christian films, the antagonist is painted in such broad brush strokes as to be cartoonish.  The film would have been so much more interesting if they can made it a movie without bad guys: just good people on opposite sides of an important and dangerous confrontation.  To his credit, Estevez does not fully idealize the homeless patrons, bringing up their struggles with addiction.  And even his allies, like co-worker Myra (Jenna Malone), display shallowness as they strive for depth.  But it never feels like a fair moral fight.

The other problem is that the plot doesn't seem to know where it wants to go.  The tensions between the two sides build and build to a point.  But the resolution to the confrontation is so... odd.

I really can't explain why without spoiling the film.  But I got the distinct sense that as the story points came to a head, Estevez tried to come up with a novel solution to the problem.  But it is so bizarre that it was much more confusing than cathartic.

Having said all this, like most Christian movies, there are moments of inspiration and uplift.  Estevez makes us feel the courage of Stuart grow as the film progresses.  The movie moved me to reach out more to the homeless and those in need.  Estevez wants very much to get the audience to see the presence of God in the poor.  It is clear that he is following the lead of his father, Martin Sheen, and trying to be a good son (or in the case of this movie, "Goodson.").  

In The Way, he let us see the slowly unfolding humanity and beauty of four flawed travelers.  He did not feel the need to spell out the main morals as he does in The Public, because in that film, he trusted his audience to see it for themselves.  If he had done that with this movie, it would have ranked much higher.

However, I would rather have a director that swings for the fences and misses than one that never really tries.




Wednesday, June 19, 2019

Wednesday Comics: Superman - Year One #1


Image result for superman year one #1

"You can't have justice without truth."

Did we really need another Superman origin story.

After reading the first issue of Superman: Year One, the answer is a resounding "YES!"

This is the latest outing for writer/artist Frank Miller.  Miller is, of course, a legend to anyone in the comic book world.  His biggest hit is the seminal The Dark Knight Returns, which is always paired along with Watchmen as the two masterpieces of the 1980's.  Miller is also responsible for other great work like the "Born Again" story in Daredevil, his critically acclaimed Sin City, the historical action epic 300, and Batman: Year One.

However, Miller's name is not without stain.  Two of his two most high profile works: The Dark Knight Strikes Again and All-Star Batman and Robin are so notoriously awful that any mockery of them seems better than the work itself.  So hiring Miller to take on the central DC hero is not a sure thing.  Even though John Romita Jr. comes with talent to aid Miller in this telling, I approached this story with very low expectations.

It begins, as usual, on doomed Krypton.  Miller does an excellent job of painting the scene with the words as well as the pencils.  He describes "crystalline structures meant to last eons shattering like porcelain."  That line particularly struck me in the way that it reduced the hefty accomplishments of this advance culture into a fragile edifice, destined for collapse.

Miller also does something incredibly interesting with the narration.  Instead of the word boxes being simple third-person omniscient or first person monologue, he blends the two together.  You read what seems like an objective statement, but you realize that he is infusing it with the voice and point of view of one of the characters.  And Miller slyly slips from one voice to another in a way that is never jarring.

When baby Kal El arrives, Jonathan Kent finds him and the little Kryptonian scans his brain to find he is not hostile.  Kal seems almost like a manipulative monster-child in that moment.  When I read this, I was worried that Miller was about to take Superman's origin down a dark path like the horror movie Brightburn.  Instead, what Miller deftly does is create just enough sense of unease and tension to give the story a sense of uncertainty that it needs.  If what you are reading is literally the same old story, then we lose the thrill of the surprise.  Will young Clark Kent become an overbearing monster?  That possibility is left dangling in the air.

The real meat of the story is in Clark's first year of high school.  He could easily side with the popular students, but he decides to hang out with "the weirdos."  He tries to look out for them as they are harassed and bullied.  All the while, you keep waiting for the possibility that he could snap and go full killer.  But he works so hard at restraint.

This is also one of the book's greatest strengths.  Superman is understood as the one with the greatest power.  But honestly, his solution to most of the great villains is to punch them really, really hard.  But Clark finds that his interventions sometimes make things even worse.  Escalation seems to be the rule, rather than the exception.  And here is where we begin to see why Clark started on a path towards his career as a reporter.  The best way to get justice is to pursue truth.

The doomed romance between Clark and Lana is also one of the most beautiful things about this book.  It feels very slow and natural, filled with the endless possibilities of high school love.  And the more you root for them, the more it hurts knowing that they are not destined to be together.

But the best part of the story is Jonathan Kent.  He teaches his son restraint, but he is not afraid of his son's power.  Martha is, of course, appalled at the idea of ever using force to solve problems.  But Jonathan tells Clark that he should always try and find a non-violent solution to everything.  But when that fails, sometimes you need to act decisively.  The humanity and the morals that Superman has are products of his earthly parents' upbringing.  But the MAN in SuperMAN is all from Jonathan.  This story demonstrates how much we need fathers to teach our sons not only to be good men, but simply to be men.

The story ends by taking Clark on a path never explored before in comics.  It feels fresh and different and I look forward to the next chapter.

Superman: Year One is done in the oversized format of the DC Black label, but it is worth the added price.  This helps give the story its larger-than life feel.  Nothing about the story felt rushed.  About half-way through I felt like I was reading something big and special.  The art matches the tone of the book beautifully.

Recently, there have been a lot of books that have started strong, but failed to stick the landing.  I'm hoping that the quality of this mini-series remains.  I highly recommend going out and picking up this book today.