ReasonForOurHope

Thursday, January 14, 2016

Remembering Alan Rickman


photo by Marie-Lan Nguyen

I was shocked and saddened when I heard about the death of the great actor Alan Rickman.  It is the gift of actors that we connect with them so emotionally even having never met them, but it is the reason their parting affects us like losing friends.

Much of what is written below is from an earlier post as one of the 25 greatest actors of all time.

GREAT PERFORMANCES:

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1
Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
Bottle Shock
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban
Love Actually
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone
Galaxy Quest
Dogma
Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves
Closet Land
Die Hard

Alan Rickman entered the acting profession very late in life. And yet he has given some of the most memorable performances that the silver screen has seen.

Let's start with his first and, arguably, his most iconic role: Hans Gruber in Die Hard. I think people often forget what a surprise Die Hard was in its day. It was a big action film with the star of Moonlighting. What could have easily been a direct-to-HBO movie was instead an action masterpiece. And Rickman's villain is a huge part of that. Rickman conveys raw ruthlessness and intelligence. You have no trouble believing that he could kill a whole building full of innocent people but he there was a part of you that kind of pulled for him. When he gets the vault open, you get a little happy for him because he sees his plan come to fruition. He charms you by his skill and makes you want to be him a little bit.

But above all he showed great restraint and I will speak more about this later. First, it should be noted that he could turn up the volume on a performance in a way that few actors could. Watch his deliciously over-the-top turn as the Sheriff of Nottingham in Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves. He has none of Gruber's silent menace. He is all puffed-up bluster. The character is written in a very one-dimensional way, but Rickman makes his horrid personality so big and lively that cannot take your eyes off of him. He just chews the scenery up and it is fun.

And he can also bring the volume way down. I loved his performance as Steven Spurrier in Bottle Shock. A frustrated, small man, he seems well worn from living. There is a hang-dog melancholy to his character, but his absolute love of wine makes him endearing. He loves the beauty of wine and wants other people to see it too. He does all this while maintaining his deflated tone and stature.

He can disappear into roles like few others. His alternately sympathetic and sadistic interrogator in Closet Land is riveting.

He is also the only good thing in Kevin Smith's blasphemous movie Dogma. A bit more about this part.  He plays the Voice of God who is worn out from having to deliver bad news.  His monologue about how he had to reveal to Jesus His destiny to die for the sins of men is amazing.  It is beautiful and sad in a way that you feel the performance deserves to be in a better movie.

His Eeyore-voiced Marvin in The Hitchhiker's Guide to the galaxy provided the film's biggest laughs.   It should be noted how iconic his voice became.  That long English drawl that was filled with dark emotion could convey a character so skillfully.

He even brought both gravitas and goofiness to his frustrated TV-star in Galaxy Quest.    There are so few actors who can successfully do comedy and drama.

And now there is one fewer.

But his most amazing work was his role as Severus Snape from the Harry Potter movies.

(WARNING. SPOILERS AHEAD FOR THOSE WHO HAVE NOT SEEN THE MOVIES).

On the surface, he appears to be only playing the “mean teacher” stereotype from so many school stories; he's a wizard-world Assistant Principal Vernon. Look at some of his deliveries in Sorcerer's Stone and Goblet of Fire and it could seem that he's simply rolling out lines dripping with venom and condescension

But the brilliance of casting Rickman was his restraint. Severus Snape is a character who must constantly be in control of every thought, word, and action. He cannot give away what he is really thinking or feeling. He needs to be inscrutable. It would be much simpler and easier to play the character as a blank slate. But when you watch what Rickman does, you feel his hand on the brakes, keeping the torrent of feeling from coming through. This leads to that signature Snape style of slowly speaking out each word so that every syllable lands a punch with either dramatic weight or comedic flair.  And only on the rarest of occasions do you see the weight of it behind the words.  The last line he ever delivers in the series is one word: "Always."  And that one word spoken by Rickman is more eloquent than pages and pages of heart-felt dialogue.

Rickman used every acting tool at his disposal and none of them were wasted. His change in voice inflection or subtle shift in eye contact did more to convey his character than what most actors could do. He seamlessly transitioned from comedy to drama, knowing the exact right tone to take with his characters and he disappeared into them in order to create something truly great on screen.

As long as there will be movies, we will remember the great Alan Rickman.

Always.

Tuesday, January 12, 2016

Movies of My Life: Updated 2015

I posted this earlier on this blog, but now I have an update for 2015:


I usually don't participate in Facebook lists (especially since I am not on Facebook), but this one intrigued me.

The challenge is to go through your life and list the best movie from each year of your life.  You can have a tie once per decade.

I found this idea challenging and interesting.  What I found the most interesting is how little interest I had in most of the movies that came out just before I was born, but I have a strong affection for movies from my early childhood.  I wonder if that is common to most people who do this?

Anyway, here is my list.  For the sake of anonymity, I have started my list with the decade of my birth rather than my birth year (maybe).


1970Julius CaesarHeston as Marc Antony is cinematic gold.
1971The Big BossBruce Lee's first starring feature.  A bit violent, but you can see the star power
1972The Godfather An unquestionable masterpiece that changed cinema.
1973American GraffitiThe influence of this movie is unnoticed but powerful, especially on television

Enter the DragonThe gold standard of modern martial arts movies
1974The Godfather Part IIDarker and a bit overly long, but the best movie of this year
1975JawsA nearly perfect film
1976RockyDespite being sequalized repeatedly, it is still raw and strong
1977Star Wars Episode IV: A New HopeMovie magic.
1978SupermanThe best superhero movie ever.
1979Time After TimeA tense and clever thriller. Malcolm McDowall's best performance
1980Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes BackEven better than the original Star Wars
1981Raiders of the Lost ArkFor the sword fight alone
1982ET: Extra-TerrestrialOne of the most transcendentally child-like films
1983Star Wars Episode VI: Return of the JediThe best of the Star Wars Saga
1984GhostbustersUnrepeatable comedy/action/adventure/horror
1985Back to the FutureExtreme laughs, thrills, and nostalgia all at the same time
1986AliensThe greatest action movie ever made.
1987The UntouchablesBrian DePalma's best film. Powerful.

PredatorManliest movie of the 1980's.
1988Young GunsIt has one of the strongest last lines of any film
1989Indiana Jones and the Last CrusadeThe greatest adventure movie off all time.
1990Presumed InnocentThe best legal drama of all time.
1991Dead AgainThe best thriller of all time.
1992Noises Off!One of the funniest films I have ever seen.
1993Schindler's ListEvery frame, every angle, every cut is genius.
1994The Shawshank RedemptionOverlooked when released, it has stood the test of time.
1995BraveheartEpic in scope, action, and human spirit
1996HamletVisually stunning and enveloping

SwingersA small, indie comedy with confidence and cool
1997TitanicDespite the haters, this is actually a fantastic, moving film.
1998Life is BeautifulA unique film that uplifts with laughs and tears
1999The Green MileSad and profound. It sticks with you long after its over
2000MementoOne of the best films ever made. Unlike anything else.
2001The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the RingA fantasy with some real gravitas
2002The Lord of the Rings: The Two TowersImproves upon the first
2003The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the KingOne of the most emotionally satisfying movies.
2004The Passion of the ChristThe greatest film ever made.
2005Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the SithThe best of the prequels.
2006Casino RoyaleThe bond reboot works on so many levels. Best of the Bond films.
2007JunoSimple premise with lots of heart. Sneaks into your heart like a child's laugh.

Lars and the Real GirlA strange movie that should be filthy but is richly innocent
2008The Dark KnightThe best Batman movie ever.
2009UpDevastating, hilarious, and uplifting.
2010InceptionA puzzle wrapped in an enigma
2011Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2The best of this franchise
2012Les MiserablesPure emotional power
2013Man of SteelVisually and thematically mature take on Superman
2014Captain America: The Winter SoldierTaught political thriller and action film

InterstellarAmazingly bold in concept and emotion
2015Star Wars Episode VII: The Force AwakensA worth successor to the series that is full for fun and heart.

A few observations on my own list (updates in bold):

-5 movies directed by Steven Spielberg
-4 movies directed by Christopher Nolan
-3 movies directed by Peter Jackson
-3 movies directed by George Lucas
-3 movies directed by Kenneth Brannagh
-only 4 movies are comedies (not to be confused with drama-dies)
-only 6 are tragedies (in the sense that they do not have a "happy ending")
-5 of the 7 Star Wars movies are represented
-4 of the movies are superhero films 
-2 movies based on Shakespeare plays
-2 movies not in English
-only 1 Western
-only 1 Musical
-3 movies involve time travel
-only 5 of the movies have a woman as the lead.
-7 Harrison Ford movies
-13 are sequels
-7 won the Oscar for best picture
-14 were nominated for best picture but did not win

Thoughts?

Monday, January 11, 2016

Film Review: The Hateful Eight



There are worse things than going into a movie with high expectations only to be disappointed.

You can go into a movie with high expectations, start having those expectations exceeded... and then the movie decides to crap all over you.

That was my experience with The Hateful Eight.

I have not been Tarantino's biggest fan.  Though I think Reservoir Dogs is genius, I still hold that Pulp Fiction is ridiculously overrated.  I enjoyed the Kill Bill movies and I thought that there was some marked improvement in his style with Inglorious Basterds and finally Django Unchained.  With this upward trajectory in mind I was incredibly excited to see The Hateful Eight.

Set in post-Civil War Wyoming, the movie involves bounty hunter John "The Hangman" Ruth (Kurt Russell) and his prisoner Daisy Domergue (Jennifer Jason Leigh) traveling by stagecoach ahead of a blizzard.  Along the way they encounter Major Marquis Warren (Samuel L. Jackson), another bounty hunter and Chris Mannix (Walton Goggins) who claims to have just been elected the local sheriff.  Ruth treats both men with great suspicion with eyes on his bounty.  The paranoia gets worse as the group is snowed in to a cabin with General Sandy Smithers (Bruce Dern), a retired Confederate officer.  Also in the cabin are the properly English Oswaldo Mobray (Tim Roth) and the silent Joe Gage (Michael Madsen) along with Bob the Mexican (Demian Bichir).  The rest of the movie plays out at the paranoia builds and things eventually get bloody.

To be fair to The Hateful Eight, the first act is a fantastic piece of work.  Tarantino writes some of his best work as he slowly introduces the characters.  He does an excellent job of making them intriguing without a shred of sympathy.  These are all hard-bitten, violent individuals with no heart or sympathy.  And yet there is a crispness to their characters that draws you to them in the beginning.  And as they are introduced, he wisely withholds a lot of information from you so that you look at them with the same jaundiced eye that Ruth holds.  Ennio Morricone's amazing score fills up the atmosphere and makes the action on the screen seem bigger.

Some of the acting is also top notch.  This is one of Kurt Russell's best performances, and that is saying something.  Samuel L. Jackson plays the same character he has in a other Tarantino films, but with that same amazing charisma.  And Jennifer Jason Leigh deserves an Oscar nomination for her Daisy who is alternately insane and introspective.  You get the sense that her madness is somehow her own internal escape but only a temporary one as reality constantly breaks through.  Also, Dern is able to wring some humanity out of an evil, racist war criminal which is no easy feat.

And for most movies, this would be enough to recommend it despite whatever deficits.

But not The Hateful Eight.

It is very difficult to explain the movie's flaws without getting into spoiler territory, but I will endeavor to do so.

As great as any first act is, it only is effective if there is a satisfying payoff in the rest of story.  Stories usually set up plot points, or "story debts" if you will, that must be paid off by the end or you will feel cheated.   And Tarantino eschews this completely.  He thinks he is being horribly clever by playing with your expectations and then totally subverting them.  Some film critics praise this as fresh storytelling.  In the case of The Hateful Eight, I say that it is bad storytelling.  If you are going to pull the rug out from under an audience, you must give them something new to hold on to.  In Reservoir Dogs, when the twist occurs, Tarantino pulls you into a new and fascinating storyline.  In The Hateful Eight he gives you nothing.  By the time you get to this part of the story, the appeal of the characters has worn off and you are left with complete ugliness.

And that was when I realized that this was only the half-way point.  The rest of the movie would be a long slog to its end, slouching towards the end credits with increasing awfulness.

When things derail, it gets ugly.  Things begin to make less and less sense.

The story begins to meander and linger needlessly.  My wife observed that Tarantino is in love with his own writing and thinks we should all bask in its glory.  And the movie horribly underutilizes talented actors like Roth and Madsen.  Many critics like Goggins' performance as Mannix, but he felt empty and dead behind the eyes.

I've mentioned before that I usually have no problem with violence.  But I was left disturbed by the level of blood and carnage that Tarantino showed on screen.  I don't often use the phrase "pornographic violence," but I think that it applies to this movie.  He takes a sadistic glee in pushing his disgusting, bloody violence.  Whereas Kill Bill had a cartoonish, over-the-top nature, Tarantino wants to revolt you with this movie and he thinks that he can get away with it because of the cache he has earned from critics.  And even the dialogue takes an ugly turn.  Right before things go off the rails, Jackson's Warren gives a monologue that is so revolting that it wonder what mind of malice could come up with it.

Throughout the movie I couldn't help of think of John Carpenter.  This is not a big leap considering that this movie borrows heavily from Carpenter's other works, especially The Thing to the point where Tarantino even uses some of the score from that movie.  But while Tarantino wants you to think of The Thing and Assault on Precinct 13, I thought of Ghosts of Mars.

Ghosts of Mars is a terrible film that feels like an elderly director trying to hold on to his former glory by mixing in elements from all his previous hits, hoping to recapture the magic.  The result is a sad effort of a formerly great storyteller who has lost his originality.

And that is what I saw in The Hateful Eight.  The further you get into the story, the more you see how Tarantino samples from his own previous hits.  He uses plot devices from Reservoir Dogs, Pulp Fiction, Django Unchained, Kill Bill and Inglorious Basterds.  Rather than seeing them perfected in a more seasoned and skillful story, it feels old and tired.  Things that were shocking in Pulp Fiction feel tired in The Hateful Eight.

The movie begins with a long, extended shot of a snow-covered crucifix as the stage coach leaves it behind.  This film is a long day's journey into night away from the mercy of God and into the abyss of evil.  Watching it, I was reminded that in Dante's Inferno, the deepest circles of hell are the coldest.
As the deep freeze settles in on The Hateful Eight, you can feel the coldness of hell.

1 and 1/2 out of 5 stars

Sunday, January 10, 2016

Sunday Worst: The Bizzaro Awards 2015

My good friend the Doctor said that I should do a parallel list to my Kal-El Awards that reflect to worst in pop culture from the year.  He suggested that I call them the "Lenny Luthors" after the horrible Jon Cryer character from Superman IV: The Quest for Peace.  The rational for choosing Lenny was that "he is terrible in every way that Superman is awesome."

I liked the idea, but I thought instead of Lenny Luthor we would name the awards after the true opposite of Superman:

Bizarro.


Bizarro is the anti-Superman, literally.  He even maintains speech patterns that are the opposite of what he means.  "Good-bye, me am not Bizarro.  Me like you!  Live!"  said by Bizarro actually means "Hello, I am Bizarro.  I hate you! Die!"

So since Superman is my mark of excellence.  Bizarro will be my mark of utter awfulness.   Unlike the Kal-El awards, these will be focused only on movies.  The reason is that serialized work like television and comics require a longer time commitment in order to understand the material.  You may have to watch a show or read a comic for several months before you discover if it is truly bad or good.  It took me a few episodes to understand the logic behind Vincent D'Onofrio's performance in Daredevil.  The investment of time and/or money also precludes a lot of unnecessary sampling, so my exposure to bad material is a bit less.

With a movie, you can have a complete understanding of the product after 90-180 minutes

So now, here are the Bizarro Awards for movies this past year.  (based on the movies I have seen).


WORST MOVIE

Terminator Genisys

The Terminator franchise, like that of Highlander, has endured a slow, agonizing death spiral.  They have so twisted and mashed up their own continuity that it is unrecognizable.  One of the great things about the original Terminator is that even though there were some plot holes, the ideas sounded so well-thought out that you overlooked them.  But in Terminator Genisys, nothing makes a lick of sense.  Not a single action from any of the characters moves close to something that could be considered rational thought.  It lacks the raw terror of the first movie and it lacks all of the spectacle and innovation of T2.  It feels too sanitized and soulless.  The kicker for me was when Kyle and Sarah time travel to the present and get hit back a car on the highway.  The car slams into their naked bodies, which sends them flying through the air and then they roll and skid on the hard asphalt at 35 MPH, and they sit up with barely a scratch.  At that point I mentally threw up my hands and said, "I guess nothing is supposed to make sense.  Okay."  Not to mention that this movie has some of the worst performances of the year.  The more I think about this terrible film, the more I mourn the missed opportunity to do something good, or at least not awful.


WORST ACTOR

Jai Courtney - Terminator Genisys

I feel a bit awkward picking on actors.  Sometimes a film actor can only give as much as their director gives them.  Look at how Joel Schumacher got horrible performances out of good actors in the irredeemable Batman and Robin.  Having said that, I have to say that Jai Courtney gave the worst performance as the new Kyle Reese.  As I said in my review: "I'm not sure that it is even really his fault.  He is just horribly cast.  He has nothing of what made the original version of Kyle so good.  If you remember from the first Terminator, Kyle is haunted, hunted solider.  There is an intense desperation in his eyes.  His body is sinewy but not bulky.  You believed he grew up desperate and starving.  Michael Biehn deserves more credit than I think I have given him the past.  Courtney's Kyle is a thick-necked brute.  He is way out of his depth.  I couldn't find anything compelling about him in this role.  "  Jai Courtney looks less like a scarred soldier of the future and more like poster-boy for Gold's Gym.  If you don't believe me, please check out the link below (I'm not posting it here because the video has mild nudity) to see a comparison between Biehn and Courtney.

The Two Kyles

WORST ACTRESS

Emilia Clarke - Terminator Genisys

Most famous for her work on Game of Thrones, many people thought that she would be a strong choice for the new Sarah Conner.  But she has none of the qualities to play the character effectively.  As I wrote in my review: "She feels like a little girl play dress up.  Linda Hamilton was Clarke's age when she originally played Sarah.  But I defy anyone to tell me that Clarke matches the maturity and power of Hamilton as Sarah (and we are talking about Sarah before she became a psychopath in T2).  On top of this, Courtney and Clarke have zero chemistry.  They talk about how they are supposed to fall in love, but it feels like parents from 2 different families telling their kids that they should get married.  It is all artificial."  If you need visual proof of this, just go to the Terminator Genisys trailer.  Something always bothered me about it until I finally realized what it was:  Clarke closes her eyes as she fires her gun:

Sarah Blinks

This may not seem like the biggest deal in the world, but it gives the impression of an actress using equipment that she does not control well rather than the Terminator-trained future mother of the human resistance.

WORST DIRECTOR

Adam McKay - The Big Short

I have yet to write my full review for this film, but one of its biggest detriments is the director.  Adam McKay is used to doing silly comedies, but The Big Short is a kind of serious tragedy.  But he has so little confidence in his ability to tell a serious story.  He needlessly lingers and bores the audience with his shots.  And he consistently does these strange inserts, as if cutting away will give greater emotional or story weight.  For example, he likes to show off his character's bookshelves as if to scream at you "These guys are SMART!"  And he does the faux-documentary style to imitate the cinema-verite, but he keeps breaking the fourth wall so he loses all of this style's net effect.  Ultimately, he was a director who got in the way of his own movie.

WORST SCREENPLAY

David O. Russell - Joy

I was so horribly disappointed by this movie because of Russell's writing.  Instead of delivering multi-layered characters like he has in the past, all of the supporting parts are shallow caricatures there to serve the story.  As I wrote in my review:  "...the movie devolves into inanity.  At one point Joy's sister Peggy makes a horrible deal that is going to ruin her business.  This is the dialogue that follows:

Peggy:  You'll get the money back.
Joy:  How?
Peggy:  I've got ideas too, you know.

The dialogue is filled with stupid non sequitur like that.  Peggy is there simply to play the role of embodied Envy.  Joy's father is there to embody Selfishness.  Trudy is Greed.  Joy's mother is Sloth.  These allegories would be interesting and acceptable if the characters had any kind of depth.  Joy is simply a more adult Cinderella, pushed around by a wicked family.  But this is one princesses who doesn't need a prince to save her.  In fact the first and third act explicitly drive this point home."
MOST ANTI-CHRISTIAN MOVIE

Kingsman: The Secret Service

In the comic book upon which this movie is based, the villain comes up with a device that will turn people into rage-filled murders.  He then tests his device at a beach wedding.  When it came time to do this scene for the movie, the director said that it would be too upsetting to see wedding guests kill each other, so he thought it would be more fun to set it in a church.  The implication is that church-goers are less sympathetic wedding guests.  Not only are the members of this church a group of hate-mongers like the Westboro Baptist types, but the horrible carnage of murder and cruelty is done in a sacred space using sacred objects.  And this scene is very clearly done gratuitously, where you are meant to enjoy the mayhem.

MOST MORALLY OFFENSIVE

Ted 2


I give a lot of latitude to the original Ted because while there is a lot of immoral activity, they are ultimately portrayed as obstacles to the main character reaching a more mature happiness.  But Ted 2 throws all of that out of the window.  It is devolves back into the horrible debauchery of the first film without any of the redemptive qualities.  This second movie is inferior to the original because all of its heart has been replaced with disgusting profanity.


Thoughts?

Saturday, January 9, 2016

Film Flash: The Big Short

The Big Short teaser poster.jpg

15 words or less film review (full review to follow soon)

Terrible directing and disconnected stories interfere with what could have been a fascinating film.

2 and 1/2 out of 5 stars.

Tuesday, January 5, 2016

Film Review: Joy



Have you ever seen a Lifetime Original Movie where the put-upon heroine is surrounded by characters who one-dimensional antagonists who are simply there to belittle her and make her life hell?

Then you don't need to see Joy.

The movie focuses on the title character played by the great Jennifer Lawrence who does the best she can with this script.  She is a single mother with two children.  She also supports her deadbeat mother (Virginia Madsen) and her deadbeat ex-husband (Edgar Ramirez).  She also houses her obsessed father (Robert DeNiro) and Joy also has to put up with her envious half-sister Peggy (Elisabeth Rohm).  The only person who supports her is her grandmother Mimi (Diane Ladd) who tells her she is brilliant and has unlimited potential.  After getting beaten down further and further by life, Joy borrows money from her father's new girlfriend Trudy (Isabella Rossellini) and invents the Miracle Mop.  She then ascends the steep cliff towards success where nearly everyone and everything in the story is designed to turn her into a martyr for successful women everywhere.

Writer/director David O. Russell brings a lot of his signature visual style to this story, but he didn't take time to flesh out any of the other characters.  The scenes felt very disjointed, as if there was a lot more filmed but hacked down to the nub, leaving impressions rather than complete scenes.  Characters would come in for a single seen to yell at Joy and berate her for being a terrible mother or a stupid business woman.  It got to the point where my wife (who saw the movie with me and is not a violent person) turned to me when it was over and said, "I wanted to punch everyone in that movie."

It is a real shame because the plot has a lot of potential.  There are moments of real fascination.  When Joy goes to pitch her Wonder Mop to QVC, she we get treated to several scenes with Bradley Cooper as the cable channel's president Neil Walker.  The scenes that Lawrence and Cooper share stand out in this mess of a movie.  Those scenes have the best writing in the film (it makes me want to research the history of QVC) and the best performances.  It makes me wish that the story was about Walker with Joy as a supporting character and not vice versa.

But outside of these scenes, the movie devolves into inanity.  At one point Joy's sister Peggy makes a horrible deal that is going to ruin her business.  This is the dialogue that follows:

Peggy:  You'll get the money back.
Joy:  How?
Peggy:  I've got ideas too, you know.

The dialogue is filled with stupid non sequitur like that.  Peggy is there simply to play the role of embodied Envy.  Joy's father is there to embody Selfishness.  Trudy is Greed.  Joy's mother is Sloth.  These allegories would be interesting and acceptable if the characters had any kind of depth.  Joy is simply a more adult Cinderella, pushed around by a wicked family.  But this is one princesses who doesn't need a prince to save her.  In fact the first and third act explicitly drive this point home.

As a Catholic, I enjoyed the fact that there is a strong emphasis on hard-work and faith in your God-given abilities.  And I also enjoy the fact that it focuses on showing a strong woman who struggles to have her dignity recognized without losing any of her femininity.  I was disappointed that there were no strong positive examples of marriage and family, but Joy's kindness and patience to those who push her around is somewhat Christlike.

I wanted to like Joy a lot more than I did.  When I think of the movie I am filled with the opposite of joy because of all of this film's wasted potential.

1 and 1/2 out of 5 stars.

Monday, January 4, 2016

New Evangelizers Post: Catholic Pop Culture of 2015

I have a new article up at NewEvangelizers.com.  

As I have for the last two years I shall recall any good things from the popular culture that are harmonious or helpful to Catholic culture. There were many things past year and many things coming up in 2016 that are antithetical to the Gospel. But there were a few bright spots in 2015.

And as I have previously written it is not necessary to indulge a fascination with pop culture (e.g. you don’t have to care about what awkward deviancy Miley Cyrus is advocating this week), but we should have some awareness of it and maybe (if it is our charism) to engage with it to make it more Christlike.

I would like to focus on the most Catholic moments in pop culture from the past year. As a teacher, I have found that using the language of modern television, movies, and the like can be very effective at illustrating all manner of theological truths.

It should be noted that any mention of positive examples from movies or television shows below is not an endorsement of the entire of the entire project. Some stories have mixed messages. Or some may be too explicit or violent. This is merely a touchstone to highlight any good moments that came out of pop culture in 2015. And feel free to disagree. But here are some points that I intend to use in the classroom.

Beware, in order to discuss the Catholicity of the movies and television shows below, 


You can read the entire article here.