ReasonForOurHope

Friday, August 3, 2012

The Philosophy of The Dark Knight Trilogy






Christopher Nolan and company have created what is arguably the most celebrated comic book movie trilogy of all time. Not only have the movies been box office smashes but they have been lauded with critical acclaim, most famously Heath Ledger's posthumous Oscar for his riveting portrayal of the Joker.

Now that the series has come to its conclusion, it is worth investigating the philosophy presented to us in these films. Since the last movie is still in theaters now, I will try to remain as spoiler free as possible, but I do not know if that will be very successful.

METAPHYSICS

There appears nothing metaphysically extraordinary The movies make no specific comment as to what the underlying metaphysical principles are at work. The universe does appear to have random elements to it. Bruce's parents are not killed by some master criminal, but by a desperate lowlife who was in the wrong place at the right time. But we can see how justice does not sleep and that eventually good wins out. The world is not empty of meaning. In fact, meaning is one of its central points in the form of symbols.

“People need dramatic examples to shake them out of apathy. I can't do this as Bruce Wayne. A man is just flesh and blood and can be ignored or destroyed. But as a symbol... as a symbol, I can be incorruptible, everlasting.”

Bruce says these words as he begins to gestate the idea that would become Batman. But the point is that symbols matter. What is flesh and blood is passing. But there are some things that cannot be destroyed that way because they are not material. Now, it is not clear if this points to some kind of spiritual reality or if this is only in reference to concepts and ideas. Either way, there is an acknowledgment that matter is not enough. A material symbol is needed to bring about awareness of an invisible reality.

EPISTEMOLOGY

As with the philosophy of the Terminator, The Dark Knight films focus heavily on experiential knowledge. Bruce has to experience fear as boy from his fall into the bat cave and his parents' murder.

When he confronts Carmine Falcone, the mobster puts him in his place when he says, “Now, you think because your mommy and your daddy got shot, you know about the ugly side of life, but you don't. You've never tasted desperate.” As cold as those words are, Falcone was correct. It's these words that start Bruce's training in his war on crime. He needed to experience criminality in order to understand it, so he left and became a street thief.

But the role of parents is also very important in the series. While Bruce needs the experiences to shape his abilities, it is his father who imparts the great moral lessons of his life. We see this in two areas. First, his father teaches him that failure is a tool to learning. “Why do we fall? So that we can learn to pick ourselves up,” his father says. We learn about the world and ourselves by failing and starting again. The second lesson is ethical. His father teaches him that he must give back to Gotham. Thomas Wayne's example of doing good for others is the ethical core of Bruce's life.

This parent/child relationship also has a terrible flip side noted in The Dark Knight Rises. The grand designer of all the evil in that movie is motivated by the lessons of that person's father. The moral core was poisoned because of the influence of the parent.

ANTHROPLOGY

Here we find the central thematic elements of the series. Are we essentially good or essentially bad? Thomas Aquinas said that humans are essentially good and that given the choice between good and evil they will always choose the good (even if it is only an apparent good). Martin Luther said that people are by nature bad and given the choice, we will always choose the bad. Both acknowledge that human nature is fallen, but one thinks that we can rise above it, the other does not. Thomas says that we can be transformed and become good. Luther says that we have to be covered up by the righteousness of another.

The Dark Knight Trilogy recognizes the worst and the best in humanity. The Joker is the embodiment of evil. It is important that we do not know his origins or his true identity. It does not matter what his upbringing was. “[S]ome men aren't looking for anything logical, like money. They can't be bought, bullied, reasoned, or negotiated with. Some men just want to watch the world burn.” The trilogy recognizes that some men will choose evil no matter what. They cannot be persuaded or moved by compassion. Men can become monsters.

But men can also be heroes. Batman is incorruptible on the issue of life. He refuses to kill (though he does skirt the line at the end of Batman Begins and The Dark Knight Rises). He constantly puts others before himself. There is a lot of Christology in the Batman character. Though he is too flawed to be a perfect Christ figure, Bruce goes out of his way to take on the burdens of others.

But what about the common man? Sure we have great saints and horrible sinners in our history, but those are the exceptions. What about the rule?

Man is corrupt and fallen. Ra's Al Ghul says to Bruce, “You are defending a city so corrupt, we have infiltrated every level of its infrastructure.” We are weighed down by our desire to do what is evil.

But the most important anthropological statement comes at the end of The Dark Knight. The Joker sets a bomb on two boats, one with convicts, the other with ordinary citizens. Each has explosives and the detonator to the others boat. Either they blow the other up or they both blow up. This test was the Joker's ultimate point. “See, their morals, their code... it's a bad joke. Dropped at the first sign of trouble. They're only as good as the world allows them to be. I'll show you, when the chips are down, these... these civilized people? They'll eat each other. See, I'm not a monster, I'm just ahead of the curve.” He is trying to prove that everyone, deep down, is like him. So what do they do? These people are faced with a choice for survival: Murder others or die.

At first, everyone starts leans towards killing the other. It is so tempting. But when the time comes, they cannot do it. And though the desire was there, the words from Batman Begins are important: “It's not who I am inside, but what I do that defines me.” Our desires and pre-dispositions may be inclined to some evil. But it is not how we feel, but what we DO that is important. Here is where the is actually defeated. It is a great moment in the movie where we can see the look on his face how his whole view of the world collapses in a moment.

But that is not to say that people will ALWAYS choose the good in a crisis. The scene that follows shows the total fall of Harvey Dent. He was arguably the most moral character in the entire series. But the Joker pushed him to the breaking point. The most important thing the Joker did was that he took away Harvey's sense of free will. There is no choice or plan, only chaos and chance.

“You thought we could be decent men in an indecent time. But you were wrong. The world is cruel, and the only morality in a cruel world is chance,” Harvey says. Notice is complete abdication of moral agency. Rachel wasn't killed by the Joker, but by chance. Harvey doesn't murder people, it's chance that does it. When Harvey surrenders his ability to make choices, he can no longer be a moral man. The people on the boat were given a choice. Harvey removes choice from the equation.

There is one more example of how human nature can be horrible corrupted. In The Dark Knight Rises, Bane turns much of the city into a roving, French Revolutionary-esque mob. If everyday people are basically good, then how is this possible? First, Bane creates for them an inescapable situation, which leads to panic. The second is that he appeals to their sense of envy and injustice. Notice his words outside Blackgate Prison. He tells the poor of the city that the rich have robbed them and that they have a right to take it. Like all Marxist revolutionaries, Bane paints the rich as evil who get what they deserve. This is the dangerous sense of self-righteousness that I wrote about yesterday that allows for the dehumanizing of your “enemies.” And by mobilizing the people into a mob, Bane knows that groupthink can also sublimate the individual conscience. Mob mentality is a real thing that can warp the common sense morals of a people.

But that does not mean that all people will be corrupted. Though it is more difficult to resist, you still have a choice. Many in The Dark Knight Rises resist and fight this mob, even at great personal cost. But humans need a symbol to rally behind. They need a hero like Batman.

One more note going back to first part of this section on the Aquinas/Luther split. Note how at the end of The Dark Knight Batman and Gordon try to cover the city in the righteousness of Harvey Dent. They use his name and his story to cover the sins of Gotham and make it appear clean. But it is only an apparent good. The evil festers beneath the city until it explodes to the surface. This method of making people righteous does not work. The point of The Dark Knight Rises is that people need to be transformed from the inside. People are given choices and those choices will define them. If they choose to embrace goodness, they will find themselves becoming heroes. As Bruce tells John Blake, Batman could be anyone. We all have it within our power to do what is right and become that ideal.

ETHICS

While the first movie is about overcoming fear, the main ethical dilemma is not between fear and courage. It is between fear and sacrifice. In all 3 films, the main villain inspires fear so as to push the moral buttons of the people into self preservation. And while courage is necessary, it is only a means, rather than an end.

The Joker is the best example of this. He is beyond fear. Notice how he wants Batman to kill him. He orders him run him over with his batpod. He laughs as Batman throws him over the edge of the building. He puts a loaded gun into Harvey Dent's hands. He has no fear. Bane also shows no fear in the face of certain death. Courage without compassion can be as destructive as fear.

In The Dark Knight Rises, Bruce says that he is not afraid to die. He is afraid to fail his people. He is completely selfless. Notice when Selina tries to convince him to leave before Gotham is destroyed:

Selina: You don't owe these people any more! You've given them everything!
Batman: Not everything. Not yet.

Notice that Selina is right about not owing them anything. His love for Gotham is completely gratuitous But also see how simply Bruce looks at his situation. When he says “Not yet,” he assumes that his love will cost him everything. And he serenely accepts this truth. Once again we see the Christology come back into play. We see it work out imperfectly at the end of The Dark Knight, when he takes upon himself the sins of Harvey Dent.

But this points to the fact that sacrifice is also weak by itself. It needs truth. At the end of The Dark Knight, Batman says “Sometimes the truth isn't good enough.” But that is the major sin that causes so many problems in The Dark Knight Rises. Sacrifice must be done in truth. Lies are always destructive. We see this personally when Alfred burns Rachel's letter to spare Bruce pain, but this only makes things worse. We also see this socially, where the lies of Bruce and Gordon light the fire that causes the mob uprising.

In regards to killing, there is not an absolute moral prohibition in The Dark Knight Trilogy. Batman will not kill because he must be the ideal. He must be above killing because he is not a duly deputized law enforcer/executioner. But other characters kill for the side of right like Gordon, John Blake, and Selina Kyle. They times they take life are not presented as wrong, but necessary.

The last point about morality is that it does not have to be big like saving a city from a madman. In one of the most touching moments in The Dark Knight Rises, Batman says to Gordon “A hero can be anyone. Even a man doing something as simple and reassuring as putting a coat around a little boy's shoulders to let him know that the world hasn't ended.” We can all be moral heroes. Mother Teresa of Calcutta said that
“Not all of us can do great things. But we can do small things with great love.” The true ethical message of Batman is that we must have the courage to truly put others before ourselves in our every day lives.

CONCLUSION

While the series holds up an often dark reflection of human cruelty, it is overall one of the most optimistic pieces of cinema in the last decade. Human beings can be cruel. But at our core we are good and capable of being heroes in our world today.

Thursday, August 2, 2012

Trailer Time: Skyfall


When they rebooted the Bond franchise back in 2006, I was horribly skeptical.  Not only because I had no idea who Daniel Craig was at the time but when I when I finally did see him he was... blond!  For some reason I couldn't get past it.  A blond James Bond?  That would be like a toupee-less Captain Kirk.   I went into the theatre thinking it would be awful.

I can say now that not only is Casino Royale my favorite Bond movie, but Daniel Craig is the best James Bond (and now I wait to incur the wrath of the Connery lovers.  I fear no such reprisals from Team Dalton).

Which is why you can understand my disappointment at the utter mess that was Quantum of Solace.  Not only is it a terribly confusing title (they could have called it Viscosity of Torpor for all the difference it would have made), but I didn't realize that directing would be awful and the story so convoluted it was nearly impossible to follow.

But I still believe in this Bond incarnation so I am hopeful for Skyfall.  The title is potent and straightforward, as I hope the movie will be.  It takes Bond in a direction I have never seen, so that should be interesting.

But does Javier Bardem have somewhere in his contract that whenever he plays a villain they have to give him the haircut of '60's female pinup girl?  I mean, look at his hair!  It's... blond!

Thoughts?


Bane's Evil Body Language

I saw The Dark Knight Rises again yesterday, this time in IMAX (which was quite awesome, but I'm not sure is worth $17.00).

Anyway, Bane has a very specific power stance that I noted last time and noticed again:
(click the links below because I don't want to post any copyrighted pics)

http://media.theiapolis.com/d8/hMO/iI3F/k8/lRX/w1HC/tom-hardy-as-bane-in-the-dark-knight-rises.jpg

and again here...

http://cdn.screenrant.com/wp-content/uploads/Dark-Knight-Rises-Bane-Tom-Hardy.jpeg

It was bothering me, but I knew I had seen that same body language before but I couldn't remember when.  And then I was having a conversation the other night with my friends Rick O. and Matthias.

That's when it hit me:

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-62hpFkvgzIA/T1Fhx1Bf1qI/AAAAAAAAAVk/mRaIJbis0MM/s1600/cobra.jpg


Truly evil indeed...


Wednesday, August 1, 2012

The Dangers of the Righteous Self.




I was planning to write about something else for this post. But then I saw this video:




If for some reason the video doesn't play for you, it is of a man in a drive thru at Chick-Fil-A who verbally harasses the young lady working there. I hope you had the same horrified reaction that I had at this poor girl trying to act professionally at someone assaulting her character. But the thing that struck me the most was that the man was actually proud of his accomplishment. He drove up to a complete stranger and called her names. And in his mind he was the good guy?

I want to step back from this moment specifically and draw attention to the really horrible problem: Self-righteousness. In the Gospels, Christ had very gentle words for sinners who came into his presence, but he had loosed his verbal wrath on those who thought themselves holy. Read Matthew 23 and you find a Jesus brimming with anger, so unlike the caricature of mushy, la-la Jesus of much modern spirituality. Christ did not play around when it came to people who thought themselves better than others. It was not because this was his personal pet peeve. It was because self-righteousness is poisonous to the human soul and dehumanizing to others.

There is nothing wrong with being righteous. In fact, we must strive to have the righteousness of saints. There is nothing wrong with fighting for a good cause. Those are the only causes worth fighting for. The mistake occurs when the good of the cause is confused with the good of the person. If I judge that the cause for which I am fighting is right and true, I can easily fall into the trap that fighting for this cause de facto makes me good.


How many fanatics have we encountered in history or in our own lives that bear this out? The 9/11 hijackers were visiting strip clubs before they carried out their monstrous plan. And why not, since in their minds they were obviously the good guys in their own minds and could wink at their small offenses? Hollywood celebrities lecture us about global warming and then fly around on private jets. That's okay because by raising of the AWARENESS of global warming they are absolved of their eco-sins.

The spiritual problem with self-righteousness is that it blinds you to the truth: you are a sinner. Peter Kreeft once said that there are only 2 kinds of people in the world: Sinners who think they're saints and saints who know they are sinners. The former hold themselves in such high regard while the latter to do not. The saints were wise enough to see that even though they fought on the side of angels, they were not themselves angels. They constantly reflected on their sins and how unworthy they were to be a part of God's work. This caused them to constantly seek God's mercy and forgiveness.  And if they acknowledge that they were horrible sinners, they realized that they were in no position to judge others.  But the self-righteous cannot turn to God because they cannot see why they need to do so.

I recently went to the doctor for a checkup. I asked them to do blood work to check for things like signs of diabetes, heart disease, and cancer. I was not presenting any symptoms, but I knew that I needed to a thorough examination of my health. If I could find even the smallest hint of a serious disease it would be better to attack it when it is not life threatening. When the symptoms present, it may be too late. Praise God that everything came back fine. But I must be vigilant or I could miss something malignant down the road.

What is true of the body is also true of the soul. I have to constantly examine my conscience, my motivations, my righteousness and go see the Divine Physician to cure me. If I do not, if I think that my own shortcomings are “no big deal,” then I will not notice the cancer of sin choking off my soul before it is too late. As AA reminds us, we will not get any better until we realize we have a problem. If I do not acknowledge that I am a sinner, and take this problem very seriously, then I will never get better.

Now you may say that this is all well and good for personal spiritual growth, but what does this have to do with my daily life? Everything.

The second problem with self-righteousness is the dehumanizing effect it has on your “enemies.” When you cast yourself in the role of the hero, all of those who oppose you become the villains. They are the rouges gallery of your life that must have justice served to them. Does Superman kvetch when he throws a bank robber in jail? Of course not. He is the hero, they are the villains. Should Aragorn feel badly about throwing a torch at a Nazgul's face? No, because the Ringwraiths are soulless monsters who should be face-torched. Perhaps I'm being too overly simplistic, but look at that video again. The man looked at this poor young woman and labeled her an enemy who had to be vanquished. I'm sure in his own head he heard the swell of score from The West Wing as he got the better of this heartless harpy who perpetuated the profit of an evil corporation that tacitly encourages hate crimes on gays. He really stuck it to THE MAN! (or in this case a polite employee trying to give him a free water).

How easy is it for us to flip that switch in our heads and say, “The deserve it?” How many of us are fine with torturing someone as long as they are a terrorist with important information? Jack Bauer did some unspeakably immoral things, but he was a hero to many because he was the good guy giving the bad guy what they deserved. How many of us have felt that sweet sting of pleasure when we hear something bad happening to someone we don't like? Why? Because they are bad and they deserve it. And how often do we justify our own bad behavior towards another person because we are on the side of right and they are on the side of sin?  

Self-righteousness gives you licensee to treat your fellow human beings like crap. It lets you wrap yourself in an invisible blanket of protection that somehow gives moral immunity from the horrible things you say and do to others, like girls who work at the Chick-Fil-A drive-thru. I make no comment here about whether or not the man in the car was right to protest the restaurant.  That is not the point. But even if his cause was so spotless as to be beyond reproach, his self-righteousness blinded him to the humanity of his victim. How often that happens in this world! How many of history's greatest crimes have been done for the “greater good?” The man at the drive thru is not atypical. We judge each other so quickly and so often.  Even as I write this, I have to fight the temptation to look at this man and enjoy any backlash he receives because "he deserves it."  I must remember the words of Hamlet, "Use every man after his desert, and who should 'scape whipping?"

The thing that scares me the most about self-righteousness is that it closes off the possibility of love. Yes, a moral busybody can say that they are imposing their morality on another because they love the person and only want what is best for them. “It's for your own good.” “This is your wakeup call.”   "You'll thank me one day."  But you cannot have love AT someone. You have to have love WITH someone. True, love can be unrequited. But it can only given to the person through some kind of relationship. I must truly care about someone as a person before I can love them. But if I paint a picture of you in my mind and color that picture with the broad brush of self-righteousness, then I will never actually see the real you. And if I never get to know the real you, I can never love you.

And isn't that the whole point, in the end? Love takes us out of ourselves and focuses on another. Self-righteousness imprisons us in an ignorant cocoon of egotism. When I see the person who believes things differently than me politically, religiously, or morally do I label them as an enemy that must be defeated? Or do I take a breath, remember that I am probably a much bigger sinner than they are, and try to understand who they are as a person? Can I see them first as a child of God, made in His image?

When someone exalts the righteousness of the self, they turn from the humanity of others and into selfish aggrandizement.

Only by being selfless can we ever hope to make the self righteous.

Campaign for Humanae Vitae

There is a very good article at Lifesite News about the campaign for Humanae Vitae.

They quote George Weigel in the article, and I couldn't agree more with his assessment.  The most important reason why we have a Magesterium is so that the authentic truth of faith and morals will not be compromised.

I was at a conference once where the priest made an interesting observation.  Karol Wojtyla was on Pope Paul VI's commission that led him to issue Humanae Vitae.

Wojtyla was supposed to draft the encyclical for him, but instead he returned to his Diocese of Krakow.  As a result Paul's letter has its basis in the Church's teaching authority and its claim to obedience.  The priest pointed out that when Karol was elected to become Pope John Paul II, he based his letter on the subject (Evangelium Vitae), on the theology of the body.

The priest pointed out that there was no contradiction between the two and that Paul made a perfectly legitimate appeal to authority.  But the priest said that if he instead took JP2's approach of explaining the rationality of the position first as tied to the overall nature of the human person and the theology of the human body, then we may not have had as much dissent.

I don't know if the priest was right or not, but I find it interesting to think about.

82% of American Catholics do not see a moral problem with contraception.  Tomorrow's essay will be about dissent and the Catholic Church.

Litany of Blog Humility


Anyone who has ever gone through those little blue Pieta books has come across the Prayer for Humility:

O Jesus! meek and humble of heart,Hear me.
Fromthe desire of being esteemed,

Deliver me, Jesus.
From the desire of being loved...
From the desire of being extolled ...
From the desire of being honored ...
From the desire of being praised ...
From the desire of being preferred to others...
From the desire of being consulted ...
From the desire of being approved ...
From the fear of being humiliated ...
Fromthe fear of being despised...
From the fear of suffering rebukes ...
From the fear of being calumniated ...
From the fear of being forgotten ...
From the fear of being ridiculed ...
From the fear of being wronged ...
From the fear of being suspected ...
That others may be loved more than I,
Jesus, grant me the grace to desire it.
That others may be esteemed more than I ...
That, in the opinion of the world,
others may increase and I may decrease ...
That others may be chosen and I set aside ...
That others may be praised and I unnoticed ...
That others may be preferred to me in everything...
That others may become holier than I,
provided that I may become as holy as I should…


Well the amazing Curt Jester  (who every Catholic online should be reading) wrote his own Litany of BLOG Humility.  I read this on his website and then was sent it via email from a friend.  I think my friend realized how much I've been blog-obsessing over the summer and I needed a healthy reality check.


So here it is:

The Litany of Blog Humility
From the desire of my blog being read
Deliver me dear Jesus
From the desire of my blog being praised
Deliver me dear Jesus
From the fear of my blog being despised
Deliver me dear Jesus
From the fear of my blog being forgotten
Deliver me dear JesusFrom the fear of no page views
Deliver me dear Jesus
That other blogs may be loved more than mine
Jesus, grant me the grace to desire itThat Nihil Obstat may find all my grammatical and spelling errors
Jesus, grant me the grace to desire it
That Google may never list my blog
Jesus, grant me the grace to desire itThat comments always be negative and abusive
Jesus, grant me the grace to desire it
That my commenting system always say “commenting temporarily unavailable”
Jesus, grant me the grace to desire itThat Mark Shea may notice every blog but mine
Jesus, grant me the grace to desire it
That others may be pithier than I, provided that I may become as pithy as I should
Jesus, grant me the grace to desire it

Wednesday Comics: Daredevil





For decades, Daredevil and his alter ego, blind lawyer Matt Murdock, has been the whipping boy of the Marvel universe. Ever since Frank Miller tore his life apart with the “Born Again” storyline, The Man Without Fear has had his life torn apart, rebuilt, and torn apart again. Brian Michael Bendis and Ed Brubaker turned Daredevil's life into hell by outing his secret identity, sending him to prison, and a host of other dark, depressing stories. That isn't to say that these stories were bad. But everything, down to the gritty, noirish art made the book compelling but in no way fun.

This is why Mark Waid's take on the character is a breath of fresh air. Waid famously re-invented Wally West as the Flash and I get that same kind of vibe from his Daredevil. The tone, the stories, even the color pallet show a marked change from his predecessors. Matt Murdock has reopened his law practice and is trying to get his life back together. This is difficult because even though he denies it, most people think he is Daredevil. It therefore makes it impossible for him to litigate cases in court. On top of this he has people scrutinizing his every move, forcing him to constantly re-enforce his supposed shortcomings Clark Kent style.

But Matt Murdock tells his trusty law partner and friend Foggy Nelson that he has decided to enjoy life. And that is very evident in the book. Daredevil swings from rooftops with a smile. He plays chicken with Spider-Man, makes out on rooftops with Black Cat, and soaks in the sensory rich city of New York. When he doesn't resist Black Cat's amorous advances, she seems surprised. His response is “Who am I? Spider-Man?” (much to the Wall Crawler's chagrin). That isn't to say that this book lacks seriousness. Underneath this new and improved Daredevil, all of his past wounds fester under the surface. There is an inescapable feeling that the laughs are there only mask the tears. And we want Matt to be happy. The heart of drama is tension, which is one of reasons why Daredevil books have has such a high level on intensity After all the crap that has been flung his way over the years, I as a reader openly embrace the fun tone of the book. It doesn't disregard what has come before it, but it is smart enough to take the story in a different direction.

Also, after so many writers have had a hand in shaping the Daredevil mythos, you would think that the exploration of his powers would be exhausted. But Waid does the same thing he did with the Flash: he looks at a character who sees the world in a way that is uniquely different from everyone else and then proceeds to show us how they see the world. With Wally West, we saw the world from the perspective of a man who lived lifetimes between heartbeats. With Matt Murdock, we explore the depths to which his heightened senses define his world. It is delightful to the imagination when he smells a basket of strawberries and says that each one has a slightly different fragrance. When fighting Captain America, he grabs his shield and says that it is the most perfectly balanced thing he's ever felt. “Like touching a Stradivarius Highlight of my evening.”

And Waid takes this newfound personality and places him in great peril. He is building to giant conspiracy that will no doubt soon engulf our hero. But he smartly lays out the groundwork through smaller self-contained stories with only nuggets of the larger picture. This makes the one to two issue arcs simple, sweet, and enjoyable.

Waid won an Eisner award (the Oscars of comic books) for best writer this year, deservedly so. Issue #7 of Daredevil won best single issue. Matt Murdock is stuck in the wilderness with a school bus full of dysfunctional children during a blizzard. His senses make his more sensitive to the cold, and the weather essentially disables his hearing and his radar sense. As he treks through the Catskills with hope fading, our hero notes, “This is a gargantuanly stupid way to die.” And yet the peril is real because we feel Daredevil's disability. It is often forgotten because of his powers that he is still handicapped. Waid takes makes that trait front and center, but makes sure to show that it is not his limitations that define him but his ability to overcome them. This issue also touched my heart as Matt searches for a lost child in the snow and finds him huddled up praying the “Hail Mary.”

As I've made abundantly clear, I am a DC man. I collect very few Marvel books.

But that short list has now been increased by one.