ReasonForOurHope

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

I'm a New Evangelizer



Newevangalizers.com is a website dedicated to the New Evangelization that has been promoted by the Pope and Bishops.

They asked for interested bloggers to write about issues regarding the New Evangelization, such as apologetics, morality, the Bible, etc.  I submitted my services and I was accepted.  (thought based on the first article of mine that they published and its liberal mentioning of violent diarrhea, I can't imagine why)

My columns will appear every other Wednesday.  You can check out the first one here.  Any feedback is appreciated :)


Tuesday, July 24, 2012

Wednesday Comics: My Ultimate Justice League


Wednesday Comics: My Justice League

Instead of a review this week, I thought I would share with you my fantasy line up for the Justice League.

This is the premiere hero team of the DC universe. It should only be populated with A-listers or people who can rise to the occasion and become an A-lister. I was never a big fan of the League from the mid 80's to mid '90's. That's not to say that there weren't some great stories told. But it wasn't until Waid and Morrison brought together the “Big 7” that the JLA felt like they took their preeminent place in the world of comics.

A good team shouldn't be too lean or too unwieldy 7 is minimum, but not more than 12. And you have to diversify your team because of the varied problems that could arise to threaten the universe.

So, with that in mind, here is my Justice League:
From Right to Left: The Riddler, The Flash, Zatanna, Batman, Martian Manhunter, Cyborg, Stargirl, The Atom, Superman, Blue Lantern, Green Lantern, Booster Gold

  1. Superman. This is, of course, a no-brainer. He is the leader both morally and in terms of battle.

  2. Batman. There is no one who comes close to being as necessary to the strategic life of the League.

  3. Flash (Wally West). While he may be MIA right now in the comics, he is one of those sidekicks that got bumped up the majors. He's lived his whole life as a hero and can bring that perspective.

  4. Green Lantern (Hal Jordan). While Kyle Rayner is my favorite, Hal can take more of a leadership position in the League and he handles the ring better than anyone.

  5. Zatanna. You need a magician on the team to deal with supernatural threats. Dr. Fate would be a more obvious choice, but I think Zatanna has a much more level head and she has more power than she lets on.

  6. Martian Manhunter. His telepathy makes him an ideal communications person on the team to allow for better coordination. He also is as strong as Superman

  7. Cyborg. Whether we like it or not, more and more of our lives are governed by computers. You need someone who can master them and use them to your advantage.

  8. Blue Lantern (St. Walker). The team needs a healer. St. Walker can help and protect the team not only with his power ring but also his unfailing hope.

  9. Booster Gold. The Justice League often finds itself facing threats from the future and the past. You need someone who can handle time travel with the greatest of ease. And that would be Booster Gold.

  10. The Atom. You need someone a pure science mind. Ray Palmer can tackle all of the challenges that are in the field of scientific inquiry. Mr. Terrific was the alternate for this spot, but Palmer's ability to go sub-atomic could be invaluable (see what he and Green Arrow did to Darkseid in JLA #14)

  11. Stargirl. She represents the next generation of heroes. She comes with a unique perspective, but she does not need on-the-job training. She is already the hero she should be.

  12. The Riddler. He is the wild card. The Riddler has always skated the line between hero and villain. The League can use this to their advantage. He not only has contacts that the heroes do not, but he can get inside the heads of the bad guys better than them because he often is one of them. Batman will have to keep an eye on him.


The Ultimate Justice League of America

You may notice I left off two important JLA mainstays: Wonder Woman and Aquaman. They are both great characters, but I was never able to find a specific area where Wonder Woman had a unique necessity. And with Aquaman, I just ran out of room.

Thoughts?

Popularity of Women Religious

My friend Linda has an article on the Popularity of Women Religious in the US on the Notre Dame blog.

Thoughts?

Logic Lessons pt 6: Fallacies of Argumentation



Fallacies of Argumentation
These are fallacies that are very similar to something we shall look at later: formal fallacies
In these, there is a problem inherent in the truth of the argument.

  1. Non sequitur = “it does not follow.” Conclusion does not follow from premises and evidence. This is inside any invalid argument but it is a material fallacy. Note the following example:
    a. The sky is gray
        b. I am angry
        c. Therefore, the sky is making me angry.
        The above example is a Non sequitur, because premise a and b are completely unrelated and you cannot draw a valid conclusion from it. It is different that a formal fallacy, like so:
        a. Sky is Blue
        b. Sea is Blue
        c. Therefore Sky is Sea
Here, the two premises are related, but the conclusion is incorrect because of some problem with the logical form (more on this later).

Non-sequiturs are often used when people are need to make an emotionally charged argument with little data. Putting the 2 concepts in proximity gives the illusion of a conclusion. I remember I was talking with someone who asked my what I thought about the newly elected Pope Benedict XVI. I said I loved him and thought he was great. This person was disgusted and responded, “What about AIDS?” I was a little taken aback and said, “Um... I think it's bad.”
The argument as presented informally to me by this person was:
a. AIDS is bad
b. Pope got elected
c. Therefore, Pope wants to spread AIDS.
(to be fair, her argument was a little more sophisticated than that if you factor in 2 hidden assumptions. But as it was presented, this was the argument). Notice how similar a non-sequitur can be to a fallacy of diversion. The main problem for a non-sequitur is that it is missing something called a “middle term.” (more on this later)


  1. Ignoratio elenchi = “ignorance of the claim” or “irrelevant conclusion.” This is giving reasons that prove a different conclusion than what you claim. For example, imagine this dialogue (example taken from Dr. Peter Kreeft):
    Neville Chamberlin: “Peace is preferable to war. Do you agree?”
    British People: “Yes.”
    Neville Chamberlin: “Therefore let us appease Hitler, because not doing so would lead to war.”)

  1. Begging the Question = assuming what you set out to prove. In the movie Legal Eagles, a defense attorney played by Robert Redford seems to snap in court and tells the jury to convict his client. When A juror says that she deserves a fair trial, Redford says, “Okay, we'll give her a fair trial. And then convict her.” Obviously, she cannot have a fair trial if the conclusion is set. One of the most important things Socrates taught us was to follow an argument where it goes and not to try to force a conclusion that did not follow the evidence.
  1. Complex Question–asking a question which cannot be answered without begging another question. For example, there is the classic: “Yes or no: Have you stopped beating your wife?” Of course a yes answer implies that you did beat your wife at some point. A no answer means that you still are beating her. The question that should have been asked first is: “Have you ever beaten your wife?” Another example is the question, “Who made God?” There is a hidden assumption here that everything that exists has a beginning.

  1. Arguing in a Circle = using a conclusion to justify a premise after using the premise to justify the conclusion. Unfortunately these arguments are often used when talking about religion. A dialogue may go like this:
    Unbeliever: How do you know God exists?
    Believer: The Bible says so.
    Unbeliever: Why do you believe the Bible is telling the truth?
    Believer: Because God wrote it.

This also happens from the other side of the belief spectrum
Unbeliever: There are no miracles
Believer: But people witnessed them.
Unbeliever: Those people are liars
Believer: Why?
Unbeliever: Because there are no miracles.

  1. Contradictory Premises: When there is an obvious contradiction in your statement. (e.g.“I will not tolerate intolerance.”
  2. False Assumption: This is the basis of all jokes. Once again to take an example from Peter Kreeft:
    A mailman on his daily round was confronted by a large, ferocious dog in front of a house. An old man sat on the front porch.
"Hey," yelled the mailman, "Does your dog bite?"
"No, he doesn't." said the old man.
The mailman proceeded to move toward the house, and the dog immediately bit him on the leg! After fighting the dog off with his mailbag, the mailman proceeded to the house, keeping a watchful eye on the dog. After straightening his mailbag, he handed the old man his mail.
"I thought you said your dog doesn't bite!" he sneered at the old man as he pulled up his pants leg, revealing a large bite mark.
"That's right. He doesn't bite." said the old man calmly.... "That's not my dog!"

Monday, July 23, 2012

10 Years of the Curt Jester

Bl. Miguel Pro: "God's Jester," Patron Saint of the Curt Jester


The Curt Jester is one of my favorite blogs.  Jeff Miller has a wonderful story of conversion.  But the think I love about him the most is his humor.  He loves to bring joy, and his humor is rooted in a solid rationality that not only lightens the heart but pierces the mind.

Check out his reflection on 10 years of blogging.

God bless the Curt Jester

Grayson



I saw this fan made trailer to a fictitious movie a few years ago.  A commenter on the Batman movie post reminded me of it.

Dick Grayson is my favorite comic book character of all time.  I loved the idea of doing a whole movie around him as a Dark Knight Returns style mystery pulling in the older DC universe.

The thing I love most, though, is that a group of people got together and made the type of movie (trailer) that they would like to see.  This goes back to my point about the internet/digital age and how it is democratizing movie making.

(I do have to credit John Nolte for coming up with this main idea about the future of film)

Monday Poetry: The Jabberwocky




My first encounter with the Jabberwocky was from a TV mini-series of Alice in Wonderland, and I found it horribly frightful.

But I love the poem for its completely insane use of diction.  You can say the poem and speak the words that you think sound like other words, but the words have completely different meanings.  Lewis Carol successfully shows the insanity of a world were words are no longer connected to terms.

Enjoy

"Jabberwocky"

'Twas brillig, and the slithy toves
Did gyre and gimble in the wabe;
All mimsy were the borogoves,
And the mome raths outgrabe.

"Beware the Jabberwock, my son!
The jaws that bite, the claws that catch!
Beware the Jubjub bird, and shun
The frumious Bandersnatch!"

He took his vorpal sword in hand:
Long time the manxome foe he sought—
So rested he by the Tumtum tree,
And stood awhile in thought.

And as in uffish thought he stood,
The Jabberwock, with eyes of flame,
Came whiffling through the tulgey wood,
And burbled as it came!

One, two! One, two! and through and through
The vorpal blade went snicker-snack!
He left it dead, and with its head
He went galumphing back.

"And hast thou slain the Jabberwock?
Come to my arms, my beamish boy!
O frabjous day! Callooh! Callay!"
He chortled in his joy.

'Twas brillig, and the slithy toves
Did gyre and gimble in the wabe;
All mimsy were the borogoves,
And the mome raths outgrabe.