Catholic Skywalker Awards 2019 : BEST IN TELEVISION

With 2019 coming to a close, it is time for us to choose what the best entertainment of the year was.  And just as the Academy Awards have their "Oscars", so too the Catholic Skywalker Awards have their "Kal-El's"

To reiterate:  the reasons for choosing a Superman statue as it's award, and not something from Star Wars are 3-fold:

1.  The Catholic Skywalker Awards will cover movies, television, and comic books.  Superman is an icon for all three.
2.  The pose he has here, revealing his inner hero, is symbolic of the revelation of truth and beauty that we should find in all good art.
3.  It's a statue I actually own, so I can use this photo on my blog.

(My appreciation and judgment of a TV show should not be taken as a recommendation. Choosing to watch any of these films is the reader's responsibility)

And now we here at Catholic Skywalker would like to celebrate the best in Television this year.

There are a lot of wonderful (so I'm told) programs out there that, unfortunately, time has not permitted me to see such as The Expanse, The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, etc.

Shows we watch:

COMEDY	DRAMA	REALITY
Jack Ryan This is Us The Rookie Stumptown The Flash The Orville Arrow Veronica Mars The Walking Dead Game of Thrones Stranger Things	Big Bang Theory Bless this Mess Perfect Harmony Schooled Goldbergs Saturday Night Live Simpsons Brooklyn 99 Last Man Standing Single Parents	Dancing with the Stars Survivor The Amazing Race Child Support Shark Tank Th Masked Singer Mental Samurai

Best Drama:

The Mandalorian

Up until a few weeks ago, I thought that Game of Thrones had this award.  I was not expecting The Mandalorian to be as good as it is.  There are so many reasons why this has been the best series of the year, but here are just a few of the reasons:

1. Visual Storytelling:  "Show, Don't Tell" is the principle of good storytelling and The Mandalorian always fell back to this idea.  So much of the show is without any dialogue and we come to understand the characters by what they do more than what they say and the camera tells the story.  Think about this: Baby Yoda has become one of the most beloved characters in all of TV in this last year and he never says a word.
2.  Primal Themes:  Star Wars works when it touches on the universal truths.  Here, we see the universal struggle of moral duty.  The Mandalorian does not want to be Baby Yoda's protector, but he has no choice: his conscience will not let him do otherwise, even if it means his death.  And not a lot of dialogue needs to be said.  You just feel it.
3.  Length:  This show does a good job of not drawing things out too much.  If they the show needs only 38 minutes, they don't give it filler like you find in shows like Jack Ryan (which is half filler).
4.  Fan Service:  This is often looked at as pandering.  But in this case, it simply demonstrates that this is a show made for fans by fans.
5. Action:  The action scenes on this show have been incredibly exciting and I found myself on the edge of my seat.
6.  Casting: The very odd casting choices (Bill Burr?) seemed strange at first, but they give the show a flavor and character that would be missing otherwise.  I forgot how charismatic Carl Weathers can be.  And Pedro Pascal's performance needs special praise for being able to give us a strong senes of his character without showing his face.
7. Magic:  Star Wars should make you feel something magical is happening.  One of the problems with Rogue One was that it was too cynical.  Here, we have a dark anti-hero who must learn to become a true hero.

All of these reasons and more make it the best show of the year.

Runners-up

-Game of Thrones
-The Orville
-Veronica Mars
Stranger Things

Best Comedy

The Big Bang Theory

The Big Theory was able to do what few shows get to do: plan for the end.  The final season wrapped up the character arcs for most everyone while giving us some strong laughs along the way.  Usually when a show lasts this long, people begin to feel like it wears out its welcome.  And to be sure, the final season was not the funniest.  But it was still funnier than most shows and the cast and crew were still working hard.  The finale closes the loop on this group centered around Sheldon.  His final speech reminded us that we got to watch these characters grow in men and women, husbands, wives, fathers, mothers, and all the while keeping strong the bonds of friendship.  To this day, I still watch this show whenever I can on reruns.  You don't need to unravel the mystery of why this show remained for over a decade.

Runners-up

Schooled

Single Parents

Bless This Mess
The Goldbergs

Best Actor in a Drama

Kit Harrington - Game of Thrones

Jon Snow has always been the heart of a sometimes heartless how.  Kit Harrington has always been good at showing us the struggle of being a good man in a horrid world.  But this season, he took it to an entirely different level.  The final episode has some of his finest acting.  I have watched his final scene with Emilia Clarke several times and I love the way that he lets his emotions off the leash while always staying in control with a strong technique.  You believe his struggle and how even he doesn't know what his final decision will be until it happens.  He is horrified by the choice and it is amazing to watch.

Runners-up
Pedro Pascal- The Mandalorian
John Krasinski - Jack Ryan
Seth MacFarland- The Orville

Milo Ventemiglia - This is Us

Best Actress in a Drama

Kristen Bell - Veronica Mars

Kristen Bell has always been a great actress.  Coming back to Veronica Mars could be seen as a step backwards, but she continued to plum the depths of this character.  She tries so hard to be cynical, but the crushing pain of her life is that she deeply hopes for the happy ending that never comes.  Her pessimism pushes away the people in her life.  Bell is able to play her with all of her horrible flaws while never repelling us as the audience.  She always conveyed Veronica's sharp wit and intellect, but now we can see the years of experience both help and hurt her life.

Runners-up

Mandy Moore - This is Us
Emilia Clarke- Game of Thrones

Millie Bobbi Brown - Stranger Things
Cobie Smulders - Stumptown

Best Supporting Actor, Drama

Jason Dohring- Veronica Mars

Especially when you compare Dohring's early performances as Logan, it is amazing to see what he does with his character this season.  He was a wild beast, whose dangerous temper helped attract Veronica.  She tamed him into a tiger purring in her hand, which seems to make Veronica less interested.  Dohring shows us that caged beast lurking beneath the surface as he holds him in with calm military discipline.  You feel the tragedy he perceives in that becoming a better man, Veronica doesn't think she's good enough for him.  His love and frustration are evident in every scene they share and he plays the contradictions beautifully.

Runners-up

Jake Johnson- Stumptown
Sterling K. Brown - Game of Thrones

Jesse L. Martin - Stranger Things

Jeffrey Dean Morgan - Stranger Things

Best Supporting Actress, Drama

Maya Hawke- Stranger Things

I was impressed by the level of restraint used by Maya Hawke as she played Robin.  She begins as a smart-alec co-worker to Steve, in many ways the opposite of his former flame, Nancy.  She seems self-possessed, confident, and not at all needy.  As the show continues and the layers peel away, it was so fascinating to watch her vulnerability get to the point where she could share with Steve her deepest secret.  It is a tender moment of vulnerability that is very well-acted.  And all along the way, her chemistry with Joe Keery is both endearing and hilarious.

Runners-up

Maise Williams- Game of Thrones
Penny Johnson Jerald- The Orville

Susan Kelechi Watson - This Is Us
Meilissa O'Neil– The Rookie

Best Actor, Comedy

Taran Kiliam- Single Parents

As the overly involved single father, Kiliam's Will Cooper could easily be a one-note stereotype.  And to be sure, Kiliam is not afraid to go from broad comedy.  He knows how to play to his strengths.  But he also able to extract a lot of laughs with the simplest change of facial expression or shift in the tone of his voice.  On top of that, Kiliam has given us strong glimpses of his ability to tone things down into quite, reflective moments that show nuance and subtlety.

Runners-up

Jim Parsons - The Big Bang Theory

Dax Shepherd - Bless This Mess

Johnny Galecki - The Big Bang Theory

Jeff Garlin - The Goldbergs

Best Actress, Comedy

Lake Bell - Bless This Mess

The "fish out of water" trope keeps coming back because it is a gold mine for comedy and Lake Bell has hit the motherload.  Her urban transplant to rural Nebraska is someone who is constantly out of her depth.  What makes Bell stand out is that she is willing to swing for the fences and try the strangest things in order to get a laugh.  One of the funniest things I have seen her do is talk out of her nose in order to not let an unwanted guest understand what she is saying.  This kind of insane energy helps make this show as funny as it is.

Runners-up

Wendy McLendon-Covey – The Goldbergs

Kaley Cuoco – The Big Bang Theory

Leighton Meester - Single Parents
AJ Michalka - Schooled

Best Supporting Actor, Comedy

Ed Bagely Jr. - Bless This Mess

The key to Ed Begley Jr.'s performance is his complete commitment.  His Rudy is a character that is so insane that he would be unbelievable without Begley Jr.'s dedication.  He understands the often overlooked principle of comedy that "Serious is funny."  As Rudy, he takes every line as seriously as if he was reciting a line from Hamlet or The Godfather, even though often what he is saying is insanely ridiculous.  In one scene he comes up with codenames for he and Lake Bell's Rio.  He says he is "Potato 1" and she is "Potato 3."  When she asks what happened to "Potato 2," he looks at her with the most dire seriousness and says, "You don't want to know."  It was one of the funniest deliveries I have seen all year.

Runners-up

Brad Garrett - Single Parents
Kunal Nayar - The Big Bang Theory
Brett Dier - Schooled
Simon Helberg - The Big Bang Theory

Best Supporting Actress, Comedy

Mayim Bialik- The Big Bang Theory

I have praised Bialik's portrayal of Amy on The Big Bang Theory on this blog.  While she started off her tenure on the show a bit stiff, she developed Amy into a fully realized character.  In the final season, we see her deal with strange struggle of now being Sheldon's wife while the two compete for a Nobel Prize.  She consistently had some of the best line deliveries on the show and was also able to play the dramatic parts without it taking us out of the comedy.  She will be one the characters that I will miss the most.

Runners-up

Kimrie Lewis - Single Parents
Melissa Rauch - The Big Bang Theory
Pam Grier- Bless This Mess

Lennon Parham - Bless This Mess

Stay tuned tomorrow for the Catholic Skywalker Awards for Best Movies of 2019